Shishkin? students? copies?

[герой]

addressed through an intermediary owners (do not play well with the internet) want to know the authenticity and value of the paintings
: confused:

[Самвел]

Regarding the second scene, then in my opinion it is a copy, Shishkin-Karabelnaya grove, so she called me. I personally do not like. If you can sell for $ 500, consider yourself udachnikom.

[sergejnowo]

character, it is not Shishkin or his students or students of students.
The price of hard to define, but not expensive.
For comparison, the work that I bought a couple of years ago, on the Crimean Val for $ 150. Please note, this is not Shishkin or his disciples.

[наследник]

Remember we here have recently exchanged views that can be bought for 200 dollars on art Piglet. Great example! It is quite an adequate answer to the question of the Hero.

[sergejnowo]

Сообщение от heir

I remember we here recently exchanged views that can be bought for 200 dollars on art Piglet. Great example!

subject missed.
There is however an ambush.
Here check out still life, 80 x 100 cm, the same year of purchase, the price is twice what you say?
Purchased for $ 300.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от sergejnowo

the price is twice

Above what?
Simply write the price of this still life.

[sergejnowo]

Cyril Syzransky, read l /s

[герой]

Thank you for your kind words. I want to insert and its liber in line at the nartyurmorta. in my opinion, this multi-layered painting, painted in several layers, which gives the effect of volume. If so, then IMHO it should cost much more, if only because of the wasted labor and the number of colors: D

[Amateur]

Сообщение от hero

in my opinion, this multi-layered painting, painted in several layers, which gives the effect of volume.

Dear character! Your words about the still life, generally speaking, can be perceived as undue malevolence. You yourself, probably, you know, that never layering of colors in a reasonable amount will not give "the effect of volume", but would have only a "layering effect". He can give perspective and use different artist optical illusions - as in this still life - and then only partially. Full volume effect gives a stereoscopic image. Type in Google this phrase "Stereo painting" with one of the phrases: "Salvador Dali", "Oskar Fischinger", "Rene Magritte", "Roger Ferragallo" - and you'll learn how painful were artists trying to overcome the barrier of two-dimensional surface of the canvas, a breakthrough in the third dimension. And you - "layering "...: rolleyes: At any art, including a painting, has its limitations and conventions, it is necessary to know in order to correctly assess the painting.

And depending on the price of paintings on the number of wasted paint: eek: ... no comments.

[sergejnowo]

Сообщение от Amateur

The artists use various optical illusions

interesting topic worth discussing.
First, spread the work of renowned German-The Dutch painter Abraham Mignon (* 21. Juni 1640 - † 27. März 1679).