Продам: Saryan, 1911, expert opinion from the State Tretyakov Gallery

[олег назаров]

Alenka, you do not react badly and better listen to the opinion of experienced colleagues .... offer for sale the work Saryan signed Lomize it is not even funny ... before selling better than consult this forum or who do not eat and do not be offended if you say the obvious ....

[Romario]

Сообщение от uriart

Of course terrible, when close to normal.

but by itself I did not like the picture, without any close
Forgive me, I express my art ichsklyuchitelno amateur opinion - like \\\\ dislike

[Alkalan]

James D. Julia, Fairfield, Maine
USA 04937
Auction: February 4 & 5 2-Day Winter Antiques & Fine Art Auction
http://www.juliaauctions.com/auction....asp?pageREQ=1
Lot number 1169 regular Saryan, and a lot of things like product.

[ВЯЧЕСЛАВ]

Сообщение от Oleg Nazarov

Alenka, you do not react badly and better listen to the opinion of experienced colleagues ....

Listening certainly not bad ..... But that's the opinion of anyone?
Experienced ... Read: "Tana, history is very simple.
I bought on internet auction and because of ignorance of the language (English) are not lifted the box with this lot when buying another painting. It turned out that he bought two. Not very worried (which there 15000!), It was hot. I thought that someone selling. So I hung this work .....
 Naivnyak such "experienced" says another, as not good "mow" under the "simpleton." You read and welling tears ... of laughter.

[uriart]

Everything you write - total nonsense!
What does it matter to you my puncture?
With you delishsya, so you're still trying to accuse me of something!
Tears of laughter welling? So laugh!
I am confident that each of us has svom skeletons in their closets!
The only difference is that some are trying to look better than it actually is, and try not to talk about.
And I'm telling you. Yes it was! So what?
Now you cite a letter from Mrs. Ruzanna Sarian. Just received.
Dear Mr. ....
 This is outrageous! I am ashamed of my colleagues from the State Tretyakov Gallery. How can we ascribe Saryan
so disgusting!
 Best regards,
 Ruzan Sarian
Fighter for justice!
And you all very sorry and ashamed of this poor Alenka!
Bemoan it further and buy it fuflyaki!

[Тютчев]

Сообщение от Alenka

If you are interested in this job and you are considering the possibility of acquiring it, then why do not you contact the State Tretyakov Gallery, and to confirm (or disprove) this opinion ...

In this case, I find it totally pointless to do so.

Сообщение от Alenka

... and find out why and on what grounds the experts to draw such conclusions about the authenticity, and why not show "on the incontestable piece, based on which they came to their conclusion. "...

The experts could make such a conclusion only in two cases, a judge did not deal adequately, or goes to deliberate deception. Great wisdom, as you can see, there is no ...

I was surprised at the ease with which you take on faith unfounded statement that is so not typical of the Sarian product would belong to his wrist? In the examination gave no any good reason for such an assertion! Why should we, after you, to trust this strange examination?
 

Сообщение от Alenka

And the issues raised by you, rather to the experts, not me .....

I used to come in their practice from the fact that all questions to the seller! Otherwise, what you are basing those fees, which are dealers? Any attempt to shift the responsibility on anyone else says anything about unprofessional dealer, or a desire to deceive potential buyers! Both are unlikely to be an excuse in the eyes of the man who bought falshak!

[Romario]

I believe that soon the conversation in this topic will join the newly Validating R. Sarian

[Тютчев]

Сообщение от Alenka

interplay prove that you are very clever and can determine the authenticity of the paintings are not holding it in his hands. Good luck.

Why do not do this if possible? It sometimes happens that the photo can not do it, but it happens that you can! I, for example, a child could not even imagine what will be possible such things as cell phone and internet! And now it is commonplace ... Examination on the internet? Why not, if it brings results?

Сообщение от Alenka

How zameteli, no self-respecting judge would not issue a confirmation of authenticity on the internet, not holding a picture in his hands (Quote not literally - but then, God forbid, yet somehow be blamed), the forum welcome molneinosnoe charges of fraud, deception, etc. - Obtain the complete contradiction to themselves.

The Forum welcomed, though as elsewhere where professionals meet, exchange experiences and information! If you have something to argue on the merits, then welcome!

[ВЯЧЕСЛАВ]

Сообщение от uriart

This is outrageous! I am ashamed of my colleagues from the State Tretyakov Gallery. How can we ascribe Saryan
so disgusting!

Сообщение от Alenka

you allow me to fight, but I do it constantly and I will do.

The names of colleagues known fact "for which shame est.Ostaetsya provide the documents to file them in court .... and bring punishment" colleagues. "That is called a" constant struggle ". But what I said or anything that will not . Moreover the authors of the "Expertise" is ... and highly respected art critic of the Tretyakov Gallery. That's it! "
Well very dear - "displays on the Mountain", at least respectable - and writes refutes svoe.Kak said O. Bender - "the office wrote." Not surprisingly, the forgery with expertise in Russian (Soviet art) spawn
 Xia and overlapped over the edge.
Ruins people filthy lucre.

[Тютчев]

Сообщение от VYACHESLAV

And further - "you allow me to fight, but I do it constantly and I will do."

The names of colleagues known fact "for which shame est.Ostaetsya provide the documents to file them in court .... and bring punishment" colleagues. "That is called a" constant struggle ". But what it tells me that neither of which do not be. Moreover the authors of the "Expertise" is ... and highly respected art critic of the Tretyakov Gallery. That's it! "
Well very dear - "displays on the Mountain", at least respectable - and writes refutes svoe.Kak said O. Bender - "the office wrote." Not surprisingly, the forgery with expertise in Russian (Soviet art) spawn
 Xia and overlapped over the edge.
Ruins people pelf.

Why only in Russian? In Europe and America, they "multiply" in no smaller scale (or even large) and a much longer time (historical)! There his Benderov enough! Or do you think there is heaven on earth! Market, it is always the market!