Where is the line between plagiarism and influence of another artist

[Маруся]

PS

Regarding the case of Newton and Pusenkoff: sorry, haste, when she wrote, or do not accurately puts it: I do not have the text of the court decision, which came into force.

[iside]

Maroussia, about the cases you've probably already read it?
1 [/URL],
2 [/URL]

[iside]

A perfect example of two-character apropriatsionizma

[Кирилл Сызранский]

In connection with the case of the Belgian artist Luc Taymans/Luc Tuymans, recognized by the civil court of Antwerp guilty of plagiarism when creating a portrait of a Belgian politician Jean-Marie Dedecker problem over again became a subject of discussion.
Luc Tuymans now receives broad moral support from the public and artists, his defense has been even Queen Beatrix of the Netherlands.
The artist believes that the process against him was inspired by far-right politicians, against which Taymans constantly acted, in fact, a photo of one of them, used by the artist in his painting, and became an occasion for the court. However, the policy did not expect such a sharp reaction of the international community and is now accused of Tamasa that he mobilized against them all their international relations.
And the artist is not going to give up - he is preparing to appeal the decision of the court. According to experts, have taken place in recent accusations of plagiarism against Richard Prince, Shepard Fairey and Jeff Koons become a definite trend, already out of control, and if this goes on, the work of Warhol, created with the use of appropriation, soon can be considered illegitimate.

[I]Picture of Tamasa "Belgian politician" 2011 the court found a reproduction of a photo taken in 2010 by photo-reporter of the van Kathrein Gil@

[Гриф]

Сообщение от Маруся

every artist the right to use others ' ideas to create his works.

PLAGIARISM - the deliberate appropriation of authorship to someone else's work of science, literature or art in General or in particular. According to the legislation of the Russian Federation shall entail criminal liability. PLAGIARISM is recognized regardless of someone else's published work or not. Compulsion to co-Pres Lebeda as PLAGIARISM. The victim of PLAGIARISM, the author can apply for civil measures of protection of rights of authorship, including to claim damages. If proof of PLAGIARISM in the work, which signed the publishing contract, the publisher is entitled to his rastorgnuty to recover unpaid fees. Borrowing the theme or plot of pieces of scientific ideas that make up its contents, without borrowing the forms of their expression, is not considered PLAGIARISM.

Yes, he can. Pay for the used and live.

conscious and unconscious reminiscence, as well as "postmodernism" take out the brackets.

About Nutone - the question is not very simple. But most likely Yes. The photo was used.

[Маруся]

Grif, why are You so... Article, obviously, read, "creative" it has processed, and this little miss:

"Possible plagiarism and partial use of someone else's work or citation without reference to the source."

Because the information from here: http://www.copyright.ru/ru/documents...h_prav/plagiat Or am I not right?



[QUOTE="iside;1797263"] I am interested in this practical point, if I, for example, as a young gallery owner decides to put an artist who works in someone's style and I can see it, but will present it as just "inspiration", and suppose there will come a competitor and then wrote in his Twitter, they put one, which is all copied from Takahata@

Also recently remembered this topic. Maybe iside, will be interested in. Just in case Patrick Carew (Patrick Cariou) against Richard Prince (Richard Prince) and was the first precedent. Patrick Carew was not limited to a claim of copyright infringement to Richard Prince, and filed a lawsuit to the art gallery Gagosian Gallery Inc. And its owner Larry Gagosian. The basis for the claim was that the gallery has exhibited the work of Prince, published a catalogue of paintings, and sold them for more than $ 10 million.
In the first instance judge decided to withdraw the remaining copies, negatives, CDs, etc. as well as unsold paintings and destroy; and gallery and Gagosian obliged to notify all owners of the paintings on the violations of copyright.
And the court of appeal overturned this decision in the most part (i.e., recognized the disputed only 5 papers out of 30), with great satisfaction Gagosian.
Details here: http://www.theartnewspaper.com/artic...t-appeal/29342

[Гриф]

Сообщение от Маруся

"Possible plagiarism and partial use of someone else's work or citation without reference to the source."

Because the information from here: http://www.copyright.ru/ru/documents...h_prav/plagiat Or am I not right?

Don't know where. The Internet is big, I'm on the URLs don't look.

As for the "possible plagiarism" - then probably not.
1. if I'm from "War and peace" will take the story a little bit of plagiarism. And if Roman phrase from the War and Mr, and Sakovich do not.
2. It seems that there is expertise on plagiarism, which evaluates borrowing in percent...
3. The quote is not plagiarism, because it is not "assigning authorship". But here , of course, the question of what the "quote". If, sorry, "the author's installation consists of a baguette and state" pictures... Yes, I've removed the signature of the author, but put yourself as the author... (installation!)
It is rather plagiarism.
Here we need to talk about a broader notion of the term "plagiarism".
"Using someone else's work for pecuniary gain."

However, for out - there's generally the chance.
Are weak, as the writer says: Yes, I have a copy, so what?

PS And publishers reproductions eagerly looking at the calendar: well, when did 70 years since the death of turns?

[kozhinart]

An example of plagiarism:
Picture:
1.Kozhin S. L.
The old oak tree in Kolomenskoye. 2003. Oil on canvas. 110 x 160 see
http://kozhinart.com/ru/gallery/gallery/kolomenskoye
2.Bokanowski Sergey
The old oak tree in Kolomenskoye
Size: 50x70
Cost: 12 000
THERE
http://peizaj.com/galery.html#

[художник Федотов]

Сообщение от kozhinart

Example of plagiarism:
Picture:
1.Kozhin S. L.
The old oak tree in Kolomenskoye. 2003. Oil on canvas. 110 x 160 see
http://kozhinart.com/ru/gallery/gallery/kolomenskoye
2.Bokanowski Sergey
The old oak tree in Kolomenskoye
Size: 50x70
Cost: 12 000
THERE
http://peizaj.com/galery.html#
Miniatures

And suddenly,they are randomly, independently copied it from one photo from an old calendar???...

[Кирилл Сызранский]

[QUOTE=художник Федотов;3372561]And suddenly,they are randomly, independently copied it from one photo from the old calendara@

kozhinart is the author of the first landscape and he knows where his "get".