Etude I. Shishkin.

[Дима]

Hello!

I ask you to penetrate the product and to hear the views of respected judges.

[U_Z]

Сообщение от "Dima, 1575053

to the product

You presented two papers?
Formulate the question clearly.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от "Dima, 1575053

Study I. Shishkin.

Who attributed the way?
Where is authorship?

[U_Z]

Mirotochenie miraculous icon !

Entry Dima posted 31/10/2010 at 17:53

-------------------------------------------------- -------------------------

Went through at your leisure foot icons from the collection and found some myrrh-streaming ... Was extremely surprised at this point . Such miracles do happen, the icon was covered with streaks fragrant myrrh ! Although how could he take in the icon , which more than 500 years ? Moisture content of wood at an age less than 10 %...
A fragrant oil here ! Miracle still happens . In the monasteries for a relic to be happy . I'll try to exchange for old books , but above shall seek to impose old arks , yes honey ten pudikov . Miracle ! Miracle ! Miracle !

[U_Z]

Сообщение от U_Z; 1575081 "

move to the leisure of the foot of icons from the collection and found some myrrh-streaming ... Was extremely surprised at this point . Such miracles do happen, the icon was covered with streaks fragrant myrrh ! Although how could he take in the icon , which more than 500 years ?

Dima , Your icon - the end of 19- early 20 th century .

Levkas on the icon and the image is not just a crack , my opinion .

[Дима]

Сообщение от U_Z

you presented two papers ? Formulate the question clearly .

You are right. The first image I put up for comparison , I think many people know this sketch Shishkin stored in a famous museum . Three other photos are mine. Size 40-55 cm Signature product is not visible , nails " stretcher " forged on the plywood parts are then print ( not print) . Above the inscription on the stretcher in pencil Yelabuga .

The question is simple . He or is not he ?

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Dima , 1575103

nails " stretcher " forged

Even if the nails " poramnika " forged out of gold , he " stretcher " very bad , made ​​not even a carpenter , a carpenter .
- You Kashtanka , insect creature and nothing else . Contrary to a person you do not care what the carpenter suprotiv carpenter ... ( c)

[Дима]

Сообщение от U_Z

Dima, Your icon - the end of 19-early 20 th century.


Levkas on the icon there and it just cracks, my opinion.

I have even more to say, that icon of the paper, stuck in a tree.
Just threw bait for the seriousness of this resource.

Added after 2 minutes

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

Even if the nails " stretcher " forged out of gold , he " stretcher " very bad , made ​​not even a carpenter , a carpenter .
- You Kashtanka , insect creature and nothing else . Contrary to a person you do not care what the carpenter suprotiv carpenter ... ( c)

This is understandable, but the painting as I understand you personally not caught ?

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Dima

painting as I understand you personally not caught?

Well there can "hook"?

[Дима]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

Well there might "hook"?

Photos of the bad, and tomorrow will set the daylight.
Authorship of paintings I have no doubt.