Etude I. Shishkin.
 

Hello!

I ask you to penetrate the product and to hear the views of respected judges.

You presented two papers?
Formulate the question clearly.

Who attributed the way?
Where is authorship?

Mirotochenie miraculous icon !

Entry Dima posted 31/10/2010 at 17:53

-------------------------------------------------- -------------------------

Went through at your leisure foot icons from the collection and found some myrrh-streaming ... Was extremely surprised at this point . Such miracles do happen, the icon was covered with streaks fragrant myrrh ! Although how could he take in the icon , which more than 500 years ? Moisture content of wood at an age less than 10 %...
A fragrant oil here ! Miracle still happens . In the monasteries for a relic to be happy . I'll try to exchange for old books , but above shall seek to impose old arks , yes honey ten pudikov . Miracle ! Miracle ! Miracle !

Dima , Your icon - the end of 19- early 20 th century .

Levkas on the icon and the image is not just a crack , my opinion .

You are right. The first image I put up for comparison , I think many people know this sketch Shishkin stored in a famous museum . Three other photos are mine. Size 40-55 cm Signature product is not visible , nails " stretcher " forged on the plywood parts are then print ( not print) . Above the inscription on the stretcher in pencil Yelabuga .

The question is simple . He or is not he ?

Even if the nails " poramnika " forged out of gold , he " stretcher " very bad , made ​​not even a carpenter , a carpenter .
- You Kashtanka , insect creature and nothing else . Contrary to a person you do not care what the carpenter suprotiv carpenter ... ( c) :D

I have even more to say, that icon of the paper, stuck in a tree.
Just threw bait for the seriousness of this resource.

Added after 2 minutes
This is understandable, but the painting as I understand you personally not caught ?

Well there can "hook"?
:)

Photos of the bad, and tomorrow will set the daylight.
Authorship of paintings I have no doubt.