For the Russian obscenities in Estonia fined

[zarajara]

Сообщение от Victor_art

I have not found, but I see creativity Zadornov positive and creative. All that we are looking for a long time ago to find us, but will discuss this another time. > criticize someone's work, not hard, it's hard to do something himself in life that can bring benefit and happiness of others, and so let it all ...

 
Victor_art, can I have you now also offer video? It hit the last two weeks, you may have seen him. Here, too, archaeologists and anthropologists - fans.
I believe that the exceptional antiquity of a people can tell by the presence of wild species.
That the Armenians - ochchen ancient people. We have wild species Homo Sapiens-s are still inhabited. One of them is my neighbor - the name Armand >
But joking aside, I know how hard working historians, linguists, archaeologists, with many friends. How much work is put before you to say something! One of my friends archaeologists found the burial of a horse, and perhaps the oldest in the world of horse burial, indicating that it was cultivated. So he put the excavations, has invited colleagues from Germany and France, that they have participated. And never really learned not talking about ethnicity in prehistory, such as the Bronze Age inhabitants living in Armenia say the "culture of the Kura-Araks" rather than "ancient Armenians," as do historians, linguists and other lovers.
Specialists are responsible for every word and stands in mortal fear what has been said without good reason, because it's - reputation.
 And then flick of the wrist, with jokes and the audience of many millions. And then this one will be invoked.

[Victor_art]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzran

This is a gee - gee retardation - gee on teleyaschiku during zadornovskih jokes , "Well, that Americans - nN -e " You have a positive and constructive opinion? >

  Cyril , I'm already ten years old, it does not look interesting case , and about the " gee - gee - gee " , etc. So everyone sees what he wants to see. I like , I see something quite different ... >

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Victor_art

I like, I see quite a different ...
>

So I asked you and - what?

Silence the mysterious ...

[Victor_art]

Сообщение от zarajara

Victor_art, can I have you now also offer video ? It hit the last two weeks , you may have seen him . Here, too, archaeologists and anthropologists - fans .

Thank you , Zarajara, for the proposed rendered "video" , but my patience enough for 30 seconds at most , then could not watch . > I'm sorry, but I do not appreciate your humor , I have the previous movie, as an example of removing the problem of politically engaged in Estonia and other social tensions , about any " ethnic groups in prehistory ," I do not here he wrote . > If you bring all of this , as his experience of watching this TV program as a whole, as I recall Zadornov outlined these ancient people as " Praindoevropeytsy ." I've only one I can not understand , and here is my personal attitude to the activities of Zadornov to the topic : "For the Russian obscenities fined in Estonia ?" >

[Мимопроходил]

Сообщение от Victor_art

Here is what Michael Zadornov on Russian material : >

Practically everything that Zadornov writes and talks with screens on the Russian language - it's profanity , trust a philologist . Well, sometimes with small patches of reality.

One of my acquaintance , after watching just such philological - humorous delights Zadornov was seriously convinced that the word hero - a composite of "God" and ( horror of that! ) " Tyrit ." And just explained to his son that the worst thing. Then they both clapped eyes when he told them that the word is Turkic , and " tyrit " - generally later borrowing from Gypsy slang. So there is nothing funny in zadornovskih rethinking of the Russian language I do not see many perceive this nonsense as an axiom , alas. Good luck to everyone !

[Victor_art]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzran

So you and I asked - what is it?
Silence mysterious, but very significant ... >

For me, above all, a great satirist Mikhail Zadornov , the narrator with a very sharp , very lively and observant mind. On his work I was looking through the lens of the image Zadornov as a satirist , the romance - seeker, an adventurer Don Quixote, who rebelled against an all-out policy template- matrix , Google's thinking, in which society steeped potreblyadstva .)) ) Review creativity Zadornov, analyzing it in parts, as historian, philologist, linguist , archaeologist itp It makes no sense , it sort of research on the laurels and is not intended . > The fact that Zadornov his inexhaustible optimism and talent to kindle in the hearts of listeners sparks of creativity and enthusiasm of youth awakens a genuine interest in their native language, its long history , culture and traditions , I personally do not see nothing wrong, he can only express my deep gratitude and appreciation ...

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Victor_art

For me, above all, a great satirist Mikhail Zadornov ...

Yeah?

He steals from the other subjects and the whole works.
>

Сообщение от Victor_art

rebelled against an all-out policy template-matrix, Google's thinking

In-in, and steals from the Internet.
>

[fabosch]

Сообщение от Victor_art

Consider creativity Zadornov, analyzing it in parts, as a historian, philologist, linguist, archaeologist itp It makes no sense, it sort of research on the laurels and is not intended. > The fact that Zadornov his inexhaustible optimism and talent to kindle in the hearts of listeners sparks of creativity and enthusiasm of youth awakens a genuine interest in their native language, its long history, culture and traditions, I personally do not see nothing wrong, he can only express my deep gratitude and appreciation ...

Leaving aside the basic activity Zadornov (for example, I have nothing but bewilderment is not calling, but that can be attributed to the difference in taste), I can not agree with your assessment of its "etymological research." These psevdoizyskaniyami he only teaches people that are, in fact, simply, everything is on the surface and is easily explained, and, therefore, why fund a serious study, when all you can "open" in passing, just a consonance of words (he, to be Maybe it does not state so, but that is exactly what follows from his position for any reasonable person). It was in that its most damage. That is, he tells people that all is easy to solve and all have the answers, we just buckle down and do everything. Meanwhile, the etymology - one of the most difficult and problematic areas of linguistic science. And there just so many questions for which there is no simple answer.
Oh, I'm not talking about his self-confidence with which all this izlagetsya - one is able to avert a reasonable person. It just is not anything any doubts. That's it, full stop! He, as you write, do not pretend to be scientific laurels. Yes it is, he pretends not to academic laurels, and the ultimate truth. And it's much worse.

[Victor_art]

Сообщение от fabosch

Leaving aside the basic activity Zadornov (for example, I have nothing but bewilderment is not calling , but that can be attributed to the difference in taste ) , I can not agree with your assessment of its " etymological research ."

Fabosch, maybe you took the text of the article the journalist interviews, which I placed in the theme, how my rating of " etymological research" Mikhail Zadornov ? >

[Allena]

fabosch, how right you are ! Such amateur linguistics brings very great harm. Interested - I refer to the brilliant book " From the notes of an amateur linguistics" linguist, lexicographer, a polyglot and a remarkable scientist AA Zalizniak . fabousch, for your words I can only add a quote from Leonardo da Vinci: "If everything seems easy , it's unmistakably proves that the worker is skilled and very little work beyond his understanding this ." That's it.