Gerard Dou?

[Artoil-A]

Сообщение от Paulig

In fact of the matter is that in both examinations and no one raised the issue prove the authorship of the Dow , and raised the question - What is it all about (for me for example painting on oak in general was unusual even with such casually asymmetrically beveled on the reverse side )

here's another examination which was signed Vyazemskaya

Lack of preparatory drawing even more confusing. Does not mean - whether it up with well-developed sample ? Then become incomprehensible error anatomical modeling.

[redbor]

Сообщение от ANATOLY

my expertise will be cheaper and more.

ANATOLY, you can find out: What is your assessment?
 
You spend it yourself?
How and where?

[Paulig]

Сообщение от Artoil-A

Lack of preparatory drawing even more confusing.
Does not mean - whether it up with well-developed sample?
Then become incomprehensible error anatomical modeling.

We DOW about 390 known paintings, including the point that they are not among this sample

Added after 1 minutes

Сообщение от sergejnowo

Paulig, apparently, you dug a subject very well, deep and wide and it is not spent a penny.

As they say, the end justifies the means.
Tell me please, what is your goal?

One goal is the truth, well, the end result is of course for sale!

[sergejnowo]

Сообщение от Paulig; 2937511"

One goal is the truth , well, the end result is of course for sale !

unfortunately true you do not find , you can make /dial dozen official examinations of the work must be original or non-original will not.
For sale in Russia expertise play a significant role in pricing, but virtually no demand .
In Europe, these documents do not need them , everything is easier.
If you bring this work to the auction , Christie's or Sotheby's say , " chemical analysis " conduct on-site inspection of the operation on all sides , the reason there fingernail yes SNM and ready.
But the starting price will be appointed on the basis of comparison of the painting with the known works of the author. Here ambush, comparative level of painting your work low offer /will start at 10,000 - $ 15,000 and be done with it . Nobody will hammer head , original or not , the answer to this question will give the buyer at the time of the auction.
Certainly make a fuss with original works of high artistic level Bombings provenance , and there are 100,000 - 200,000 $ quick Start .

[Paulig]

Probably agree with you in everything, even in the fact that the artistic value of the picture is not so great ! And the fact that consumer demand in Russia for such paintings almost zero .

 But that's the price of the Dow is still not as modest as you say , and if we admit that this is one of his earliest works , the price for the person who collects the Dow I think will have a mediocre value .

That is why it is so important for me to figure it out early or late Dow scribble art school Doe when pictures on request any fishmonger stamped hundreds of the same nephew DOW being his disciple

By the way I would like to know your opinion on personal signature ( on the photo mismatch specified by an arrow)

[sergejnowo]

Сообщение от Paulig; 2938061"

By the way I would like to know your opinion on personal signature ( mismatch is specified by an arrow on the photo )

annex set signatures artprice, and there you will see similar to your option.
Do artists rarely stable specimen signature for all creative life.
Often the theme of " signature" is a topic without the "bottom" .

Сообщение от Paulig; 2938061"

This is why it is so important for me to figure it out early or late Dow scribble art school Doe when pictures on request any fishmonger churned out hundreds of the same nephew DOW being his disciple

you should already have the answers to all your questions.
For me , if respected themselves and their creative master , began to write and work prescribing 30%saw that he 's not in shape and color , not only did not go in anatomy, but the light is not glued, it would not be hard to build upon the work end.

[Paulig]

So all of you for the fact that this picture was finishing one of the disciples of the DOW ?


But it may well be that the very okazatsya 30 %of the work and the rest belong to Rembrandt 15 year old preschool

Why am I , a person in the picture there is a certain similarity with the father of Rembrandt ? ( dopdlino know that being a disciple of Rembrandt Dow often wrote his father and mother Rembrandt)



That such work Rebranta where he wrote his father

[sergejnowo]

Paulig, refer to the State Museum of Amsterdam, https://www.rijksmuseum.nl/, there may be help.

[Paulig]

Сообщение от sergejnowo

Paulig, refer to the State Museum of Amsterdam, https://www.rijksmuseum.nl/, there may be help.

And what about restitution?

[sergejnowo]

Paulig, show pictures, you do not lose anything.

And if anyone has or claims with evidence of course, and so they may be presented.