As the wolf nor the feed ...

[Кирилл Сызранский]

ecc4, you offer this subject the author to delete?

[Admin]

Do not, let it stay. Whatever was interesting to read. And, finally, "that is written pen ..."

[Allena]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

ecc4, you offer this subject the author to remove?

Cyril Syzransky, I think, you should not do. Let this branch will remain - learn to understand others, learn tolerance and no one is ever too late. After all, the point here was not the authenticity of the work itself, but in the means by which to enjoy the dispute.

Who sows the wind, he will reap the whirlwind - that's what happened.

I am in this whole discussion certainly agree with Liana and Master - Respect peacemakers!

[iosif]

Rode for two days in the fire - and to you, then just the lists any. Nerytsarsky tournament.
I'll tell monstrous banality, but I really believe in it: almost always have the opportunity to defend their opinion, not offending and humiliating the opponent.
And so absolutely professional debate over what really sympathize with the participants.
Now about more positive. In Kostroma, an excellent museum, much richer than in Penza. Plus - a large exposition Yefim Chestnyakova, failed Repin's disciple, who had worked all his life in a remote village and found by chance (creative heritage mean) seven years after physical death of the artist.
I saw also a remarkable Stozharov picture (but one) in the main exhibition. And Wooden, all as lace, filmed on the street Simanovsky, with a plaque. Grandpa, if necessary - perekinu.

[Allena]

Сообщение от iosif

I'll tell a monstrous banality, but I really believe in it: almost always have the opportunity to defend their opinion, not offending and humiliating an opponent.

Joseph! I wiped out from his post exactly the same phrase, the banality frightened. Thank you for science (seriously, without a smile)!

[Vladimir]

Сообщение от Allena

Who sows the wind, he will reap the whirlwind - that's what happened.

I am in this whole discussion certainly agree with Liana and Master - Respect peacekeepers!

Well, actually, this happened? We're not in the library or in the theater? And not in a museum. We are on the market. Well squabbled people who do not have to choose the expressions on the market emotions do not vozbranyaeyutsya. Moreover, the dispute has been for quite working time.

[Allena]

Сообщение от Vladimir

Well squabbled people do not have to choose expressions, emotions are not on the market vozbranyaeyutsya.

Objection!

[Прохожий]

It is interesting to observe the discussion. To this we would like to add only one thing - as I know, Alexander - one of the few (if not only) the heir of a great artist who, in addition to selling the work his father was a very complete catalog of his works, keeps their "migration" and really has the right assess the authenticity. In this case it is based on knowledge, on the results of own research work, unlike, say, from the granddaughter of Yuri Pimenov, which is not being an art critic, and based solely on his own "I do remember, trying to make some judgments.
Many people know that Alexander, as put it mildly ... no stranger to extra-parliamentary expressions, but each behaves in force received training and their own ethical principles.
If all the heirs of artists took the example of Alexander - the situation with the legacy of the masters of Soviet times would have been much more transparent than it is.

[Glasha]

Сообщение от passers-86025

was a very complete catalog of his works, watching their "migration" and really has the right to assess the authenticity. In this case it is based on knowledge, on the results of own research work,

- it is even seen by, for example, I had the same opinion, even when you first visit the site Maslovka that Alexander does its great mission, and saves care of his father's heritage, and does a lot for this (as a human being very clear).
pedestrian, and you often come in, do not pass by)))

[Евгений]

Gala, Dear Galia, heirs should hold the attribution of the paintings only at this level
  "The fund preservation of the cultural heritage of the artist Pyotr Konchalovsky" http://www.pkonchalovsky.ru/a_found.html
-------------------------------------------------- ----------------------
Examination and attribution:
  A large number of fake Pyotr Konchalovsky and avowed imperfections of the system of examination and the attribution of works of art led the Foundation to organize work in this direction.
Chosen methodology reflects the positive experience of the entire Russian and international expert institutions, including experience in fund artists with a rich cultural heritage http://www.pkonchalovsky.ru/a_principle.html
-------------------------------------------------- ---------------------

Сообщение от Gala

Alexander performs its great mission, protects and cares for his father's heritage,

None of this, and does not argue (and many thanks to Alexander Stozharov for it), but the attribution of the paintings he alone holds MUST NOT (to avoid errors), only the advisory council (which may use the material for the paintings, which amassed A. Stozharau) only conducting technical and technological, art history research specialists, who then put their signatures on the certificate of quality of this picture and will be legally and financially liable for their words.
Including the signature on the certificate and put nasledniki.I then issues practically there will be no attribution. (Especially Alexander lives in Moscow).

Сообщение от passers-86025

, unlike, say, from the granddaughter of Yuri Pimenov, which is not being an art critic, and based solely on their own "I do remember, trying to make some judgments.

  Here's another (fresh) sample diletanskogo approach heirs to the attribution of paintings.
-------------------------------------------------- -------------------
PSOdin times we have already discussed. "Art Consulting" who did not like, you can connect the museum lab .. it is not problema.No principle should be left alone, professionalism, and not diletansky (often just emotional) approach to this problem.