Продам: Saryan, 1911, expert opinion from the State Tretyakov Gallery

[Тютчев]

Сообщение от Alenka

M. Saryan, 1911, 19.2h29.6 cm, cardboard, tempera
Expert opinion issued by the State Tretyakov Gallery in 2003.

Please send proposals to personal mail. Thanks

Despite the expertise of Hoffman and Lomize, I can not make myself believe that this work Saryan. I can not, because the volume of the views I have reproductions of works by the artist depicting his favorite colors so I could not find one similar to this one. Ie Sarian in my life is not written and not painted in any way remotely resembling a flower or a still life or a landscape, or tempera, or oil, or pencil, or watercolor? Of course, in this hard to believe!

Work is Saryan "Lotus", which is referred to experts from the State Tretyakov Gallery, can not serve as an argument in favor of the authenticity of the picture before us. In the "Lotus" is clearly visible, the manner Saryan, which will be characteristic of the artist's works created by them throughout their subsequent life. Pay attention to how the artist depicted a flower. It consists of two large patches of color - white (petals) and yellow (core). This is the color concise and relative shape in the image of the object will be characterized by subsequent works of the artist. If you compare one of the late works of the master - "Poppy" in 1958, where the buds open flowers are the center of the composition, occupying the main space works just like a bud in the "Lotus" in 1911, we see that the artist Over time, remained true to its style and depicts flowers with two or three large patches of color, brings to the conventions of the image shape, but it accurately conveys the plastic of the subject .. Present your work is not consistent with this fine principle Saryan.
 
Perhaps the experts GTG is an irrefutable argument in favor of the authenticity of your pictures, but due to the uniqueness of the case, they should point to the incontestable piece, based on which they came to their conclusion. Otherwise, their examination was inconclusive.

I bring three dozen works Saryan, on which he painted flowers. Emphasis is placed on work 10 - 20 - ies.