The artist and the viewer. The viewer gives good advice

[iside]

Semen Semenovich,

I am very interested to understand the causes of this phenomenon.

Here, for example, I do not consider myself an expert in the art, I like something, something not, without special knowledge and appropriate education, I can only judge the case, although at the moment, I am actively engaged in self-education, reading, go to the exhibition . I have never seen the painting, which I would have liked in general, but something I would have changed.

I wonder at what

[Семен Семенович]

Сообщение от iside

What is self-conceit, self-assurance, the lack of modesty, whether it occurs only in the sphere of art, or is this type of people,

The lack of a common culture ...

[Вивьен]

Tips surely not give artists?
I think that they themselves would like to write something, here presented as they would have done, with articulate his thoughts aloud. My grandmother, who can not draw sometimes pulled out a brush with my grandfather and said: "I would have done so!" and began to paint a picture.
But really funny situation.
People walking down the hall, see picture. Discussed. One aunt came up to me and said: "I like the way an artist paints the sea and sky. But the greens he fails. I do not like his bushes.
I smile, nod.
We talked, asked me who I am.
I say: "granddaughter. Author. She, poor, immediately felt uncomfortable

[iside]

Сообщение от Vivien

Tips make sure not artists?

Yes, but I suspect that at heart they are still oh what the artists. [ QUOTE="Allena; 811621"]You like yourself would ask the viewer - well, how you?[/QUOTE]
Allena no longer ask, because the situation is verbatim from the poem, which resulted in Cyril Syzransky

Indeed specialist art dealer, who sells paintings for 30-odd years, on the contrary was very brief: It is remarkable what kind of prices, the prices are normal, that's selling these, so these - more difficult, not my profile. And yet - here is professionalism.

[Allena]

iside, I said, " as a ask "..." A poem that I, too, especially in the head it until I read your first post "For all its often have to remember - for different reasons.

Do not pay any attention to them

Added after 51 seconds
Art-ort, thanks for Galic!

[Деко]

Iside, I strongly advise - do not listen to anyone. And for this, do not ask. If you ask politely - do not listen.
I know the problem, perhaps, as anybody. I am free from the forums harchevalsya time as a designer. The first time I gave advice to friends and relatives - this is where I currently still under construction. Tips about everything - about the color, materials, structures, etc. I think the main reason for all the advice - people asserting themselves. Council - means, I understand. I understand - then I'm a creative person.
Then I began to give advice to workers and supervisors - Ta no, we do not yet robyly (not done). In every one did, but did not so. Here we have a deputy (president, banker, national artist) has done, so we have done differently. He came to the tinting shop with his master, explained what I needed color and why - asked: Guys, you left a lot to the end? And you paid off? - And what is it? - You get fired ...
That's something I've really lucky - my customers never have advised. Especially funny was the latest. Gave them an apartment, say, the kitchen will make the blue. No, not blue, my husband and I lived in a house there, there was a blue front door, aversion forever. I say, I want the blue. Something explained. A client gave up - do whatever you want.
Then do it the same house. I say, stairs make green. No, my husband does not like green. Well, God is with you. Zabarrikodirovali entrance to the stairs on the second floor, spread it surreptitiously into the green. A client arrives, something suspect. Climbed over the top banks - the one you train in green paint. All have paint.
A year later, I confessed - traveling with her husband in the car (they were from another city), discussing. "He probably Specials asked that we do not like it, so then in this color paint. - I like it because in the end ))))".
Want to have fun and earn money - anything anybody did not ask.

[Veronic]

Сообщение от iside

Semen Semenovich,


I wonder, for whatever reason, people with expertise in the art, even less than I have questionable taste in clothes, for example, feel the right to give advice. What is self-conceit, self-assurance, the lack of modesty, whether it occurs only in the sphere of art, or is this type of people who are always and everywhere give advice? before I had never seen such

If the person you generally disliked, his advice accordingly you do not vospriymete. I am so with their "friends" parted. Not only that negative people in general, and I am their presence hard to bear, so still and are always fond of giving advice, always, even when absolutely no need and no one asks.

And if people are intelligent, educated, finely understands many things, so their advice is worth its weight in gold (and most striking, they are, these tips for yourself cherish, not lavish). Sometimes one such board may change his life. But I like the people in my life met a very few, and would like more.

[Деко]

In matters that can turn whole life, it is better not to consult. For such solutions should be very responsible. because well, if all is well ... And if bad, everyone is looking for advisers.
Freud came to his disciple and asked Council - marry him or not to marry. Freud about him and said - no need to consult on fundamental issues ...
In the extension topic - another aspect. If something advise and it turns out fun - it is, they say, I did. And if advised and did not work - it advised me. Advisor in all versions of the events of Fame will not work.

Added after 6 minutes

Сообщение от VYACHESLAV

the main thing that managed to lay rails and poles with wires

About pillars daughter did not tell ... It is difficult once you have it all arranged ...

[K-Maler]

Сообщение от Deco

In the extension topic - another aspect.

The picture just looked for cobbler
And in the error pointed shoes;
Having immediately brush, mend artist.
Here, podbochas, the shoemaker went on:
"I think the person a little crooked ...
And this chest is not too Naga? .. "
Here Apelles interrupted impatiently:
"Judge, my friend does not boot up!"
                               Pushkin

[Fed]

iside, and you can see a couple of items of discussion? Two paintings about which gave the most tips.
   I do not think that the advice-problem, people still do not listen to them. And the level of people is very different, and often behind the backs of the creators and then laugh at the "creations". And in person is no longer say, do not want to offend or quarrel.
  Picasso, who "does not need advice - isolated geniuses. Artists often like to cite as an example of genius on several occasions of his life, forgetting that his name was Ivanov, and not Picasso.