What are the critics?

[таша]

Сообщение от Art-lover

And so the critic who just should not be, because it is a psychoanalyst: artists - such loonies who analyzes depths of the subconscious is not shown. For he commanded: "Love your syndrome".))
Psihokritik uncover the depth where the roots of drag artist - and all the damned. The roots will shrink, the audience will pozezvyvat and ozdorovevshy mentally bankrupt artist.)

I have little faith that psychoanalysis can improve someone everything else, including artists. The depths of the unconscious is inexhaustible, syndromes fruitful and multiply to infinity, so that the artist do not worry, the creative bankruptcy of his safe.

Сообщение от Samvel

A good critic, may very well reveal the material submitted, and put in place the artist, that even the actor would not be very jerky, in so many obviously be marked blunders. So that criticism should be that-would eliminate materials that are not worthy of criticism.

I speak for myself: No criticism, exposing lapses can not change my creativity, my mistakes, I see myself always, and if you do not see, no one can convince me that they are. If a person is "equal to me or my superior intellect, knowledge, experience chustvennym show me: have you got growing out of some of the archetypes, and then, from the banal sense, inherent to every woman, and not just an artist, and a third-inspired cartoons and other mass-culture, etc., such a critic has a chance to influence me as an artist, through the analysis (psychoanalysis )
But

Сообщение от Art-lover

And still more, a good critic - the fantasy of the artist.) After all the properties of the critic, the kind Sokurov, cause idiosyncrasy in Pavel'a. And vice versa.

I agree, and say about the criticism from the position himself. You can poke my nose like: "critics do not write for artists, but my fantasy is such a critic as I described, and it was such a critic might have influenced me. Of course for art managers and dealers need another critic, and for collectors even some third appearance. Let's have all sorts of criticism, I'm a plurality
By the way, dealers and collectors would write how they see the critic (critic-ideal dealer so to speak). Or maybe he did not want them?