What are the critics?

[Peter]

Yes, especially honest, neangazhirovannyh critics think there is neobhodimost.V contemporary art, these "Augean stables" of our days, there must be able to understand the critics, to understand what is good in our art, to compare in the context of historical and metaphysical processes taking place in society. Looking for art non-service personnel bourgeois interests and new trends in dealer interest.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Peter

there must be able to understand the critics, to understand what is good in our art

Well? Critics have settled, understood. What next?

[K-Maler]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzranskiy

Well? Critics have settled, understood. What next?

They are not understood.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от K-Maler

They are not understood.

A-ah ...
Well, let them decide. We will not disturb them.

[Pavel]

Сообщение от Peter

Yes, especially in the honest, neangazhirovannyh critics think there is neobhodimost.V contemporary art, these "Augean stables" of our days, there must be able to understand the critics, to understand what is good in our art, to compare in the context of historical and metaphysical processes taking place in society. Looking for art non-service personnel bourgeois interests and new trends for the percentage of dealership.

Why is serving, or why the servants or masters Nachos. It is in the interests of consumers must work to criticism. Artist needs podskazskah is not an artist. The artist is a person free, otherwise it is not interesting to anyone. Who needs paraphrases of others' opinions and morals?
The buyer should be sure to buy a thing, not a collection of quotations in favor of the poor or the rich.
In general, we should start, and what must earn a critic? In my opinion, need to see what they earn and earn. History must dig.
Now the critics and the critics are parasitic on the artists and all together lost.

[Маруся]

Сообщение от Pavel

I liked this theme. It is very important to identify and put everything in its place in our art

Paul, sorry, that pulled your quote out of context.
But: I am interested in the difference "critic" - "art" - "art historian"
Because in this discussion, all mixed up: and artistic research and publications about that "fashionable to hang over the sofa (very expensive). And all this is no less important to set the places ...

I agree with Paul, the theme - interesting, but might be worth, to start "from the stove and dull to explain, if you can ....

[SAH]

Сообщение от Pavel

artist needs podskazskah is not an artist. The artist is a person free, otherwise it is not interesting to anyone.

We all need support, prompting, it is normal I think. If otherwise, then we can fall into temptation. The role of criticism is important.

[Pavel]

Сообщение от Maroussia

Paul, sorry, that pulled your quote out of context.
But: I am interested in the difference "critic" - "art" - "art historian"
Because in this discussion, all mixed up: and artistic studies, and publications about that "fashionable to hang over the sofa (very expensive).
And all these messages - is no less important to set the places ...

I agree with Paul, the theme - interesting, but might be worth, to start "from the stove and dull to explain the difference in concepts, if you can ....

What is a critic of my understanding? I do not think that this is a man who walks around the workshops and talks to artists, what they did right and what is wrong. To do this, to understand all of what is an artist. If an artist has his or her work, then postoronnimu difficult to understand what he was doing. If an artist is criticized, he usually talks as if he himself did, as he sees it, and the author may be under quite a different effect or ... shorter than it should be different, no one else like, then it will be like himself.
Critics classify what has been done and is usually performed on narrow specializations styles, periods, etc. Historians claim islands involved in distant, ancient deeds.
The critic has his hand on his arm is not an artist, but on the pulse of current events and offers from the artist is raped or otherwise influence the extent of his somostoyatelnoe decision and not whether he almost stole it from the studio of his friend, whom he threw himself on the near vystavkome. Few know, he should say so publicly, making a fuss, scandal, etc., that allows him to promote their views, and the name of the artists, whether positive or negative, and should affect the growth of shopping and galleries everywhere.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Pavel

little know-it should say so publicly, making a fuss, scandal, etc., that allows him to promote their views, the name and those of artists, whether positive or negative and should be and affects increase purchases in galleries and everywhere.

Here! Here! Here it is-the main thing! "The growth of shopping"!
The rest is blah-blah-blah, right, comrade. Pavel?
"on the pulse of current events ..."," ... creativity ...", "... an independent decision "... blizzard it all!
"The growth of shopping"-that's interested. And more! Right, comrade. Pavel!

[Pavel]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzranskiy

Here! Here! Here it is-the main thing! "The growth of shopping"!
The rest is blah-blah-blah, right, comrade. Pavel?
"on the pulse of current events ..."," ... creativity ...", "... an independent decision "... blizzard it all!
"The growth of shopping"-that's interested. And more! Right, comrade. Pavel!
___________________
A key word-"everywhere", as some people in the galleries, and never will, and that some people "the growth of shopping" oh, how I want ...
but rather that simply "shopping"... <!--~ a ~-->

For the most astute, this is called an increase in turnover and price growth. Prices relate to the quality, glubokomyslyaschy you ours.