Could Aivazovsky subscribe so?

[progress-arte]

Dear connoisseurs !

Here is an example of the proposed one antique salon Aivazovsky, where the signature is in doubt. Painting issued as 1850 -60s , the motive - no marina .
And such speculation : could unreasonable holder works for more " credibility " to take da maestro himself to sign ? She - a red-brown color .

[Николай Левенко]

Сообщение от progress-arte; 3062541"

Dear experts !

Here is an example of the proposed one antique salon Aivazovsky, where the signature is in doubt. Painting issued as 1850 -60s , the motive - no marina .
And such speculation : could unreasonable holder works for more " credibility " to take da maestro himself to sign ? She - a red-brown color .

It is a reasonable doubt. This signature does not belong Aivazovsky . As for the work itself , it questioned its authorship is the very fact that it is the seventh work twin claiming authorship Aivazovsky. I can show you on the forum page like fabric. They are in the following museums : Omsk Museum of Fine Arts , historical and architectural Velikoustiugskii thin. Museum, Chelyabinsk , TG , One work sold at Christie's auction in 1997. In 2011 , a similar clone was sold at Sotheby's , the only difference in size. So that picture , autograph which you showed the seventh . Concludes .

Добавлено через 4 часа 16 минут
Number 1 - Velikoustiugskii Historical-Architectural and Art Museum-Reserve - " Sheep " ( 162h115 ) 1857 .

Number 2 and 2a - Chelyabinsk Region Picture Gallery - " flock of sheep " or " flock of sheep " ( 107h161 ) 1857 .

Number 3 and 3a - Omsk Museum of Fine Arts - " Sheep " ( 107h161 ) 1858 .

Number 4 - Sotheby's - 2011. " Shepherds with herd at sunset " ( 107,3 ​​x160 , 6) , 1859 .

Number 5 - Christie's auction - 1997 . " Sunset with the shepherds " ( 77h143 8 )

Number 6 and 6a - The State Tretyakov Gallery - " A flock of shepherds " ( 60h89 ) 1860s . (Formerly the web are in private collections S. Gorshina . Moscow)
Number 7 - Flock shepherds . Sunset. ( 90h155 ) oil on canvas 1860s . E.Shaginyana meeting . Yerevan . (Work on whom you ask )