More CPV

[Captain]

I would like to get advice about my CPV . I bought it from a friend about five years ago , and he said he bought it in Moscow in 1979 komissionke year -80m . I did a laser expert at the Institute of Physics ... Signature and the work done by the same carcass composition at about the same time. Whatman not modern . Signature , well, very similar! Thank you for any comments.

[I-V]

Сообщение от Captain

signature, well, very similar!

Well, not very similar!


If you are, of course, Petrov-Vodkin, whose work this portrait is not (and not so much because of the signature, but because of manners)

[Captain]

And not all of the CPV in one manner?
I agree in the main, similar works ink I had not found.
Explain only about signatures.
What, what details do you find it to another (not his).

[I-V]

Сообщение от Captain

explain only about signatures.
What, what details do you find it to another (not his).

There Petrov-Vodkin line lettering tight like strained - look nice!
Signed as a click of a whip.


Your "CPV" dryablenky and insecure.

[Игорь Гурьев]

Kuzma Sergeyevich drawing soft, tremulous, and then hard and almost rude.

No it's not Kuzma.

[Captain]

I would like something more substantial to hear.
Signature he sometimes is not what a click is not like a whip ...
To put it mildly, it is sometimes quite primitive, unlike his finest works.
But this sin many ...

And that's about manners ink work I also have doubts.

Added after 2 minutes
Kuzma Sergeyevich drawing soft, tremulous, and then hard and almost rude.
No it's not Kuzma.

==================================================
========

Can morning drew soul burned?

Added after 11 minutes
About the picture, I can say that the softness and trepidation felt in toning, background, shade and contour the same figure by the way, sharp, confident and decisive ...

[Captain]

It would seem not exhausted the topic of discussion, I would like more specific arguments.
Or they are exhausted?

[camertus]

Certainly not Vodkin.
Like mascara 1930s so rare!
It can be seen that after signed and in place.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от camertus

As if mascara 1930s so rare!

And there is such?
And do not dry in 80 years?
Not spoiled?
Thickens?

And, most importantly, the difference between black ink 1930 from the current black mascara?

[camertus]

old ink contains shellac as a thickener, now probably replace it with something.
so that there are differences.