VATropinin, interested in the opinion of experts - Форум по искусству и инвестициям в искусство

Art_beauty · 11.03.2013, 21:37

Hello! I propose to discuss such work VATropinin (allegedly , of course) . I would like to hear the views of the maximum number of competent professionals. Questions he or is not he (and if not him, then on what grounds )? What is the opportunity cost ?
Portrait of a Man : oil on canvas ; 38h32 . Portrait of a Woman : oil on canvas ; 42h34 .

мистер-у · 11.03.2013, 21:58

In such pictures can not say anything, and generally such items to donate to the circumstantial evidence atributsiyu.Po back side Tropinin never written on these canvases and did not put them such stretchers.

Art_beauty · 11.03.2013, 22:21

Thank you.
Canvas duplicated each other.

K-Maler · 11.03.2013, 23:18

Цитата:

Сообщение от Art_beauty

such works VATropinin (presumably,

Show the "theater-goers" - the first portrait of what looks like a well-known actor in the role.
second seems ponovleno face, it is rustic for Tropinin.
Such portraits only for examination.

Art_beauty · 11.03.2013, 23:39

Found such a portrait.
Konstantin G. Ravich Tropinin.
Like the same character?
But the signatures such that the "T" was a capital is not found.

Toinen · 12.03.2013, 00:02

Цитата:

Сообщение от K-Maler

Show the "theater-goers"

And as the theater begins with a hanger, then we can show cloakroom!

Кирилл Сызранский · 12.03.2013, 00:04

Цитата:

Сообщение от Toinen

we can show cloakroom!

Think, for a fur coat recognize?

>

Toinen · 12.03.2013, 00:48

Цитата:

Сообщение от Mr-y, 2495251

and did not put them such stretchers.

This is not it!
Novodelnye stretchers, covered with stains.

(But also portraits of themselves not him turns out that Vasily A. generally here not in the business.)

Игорь Гурьев · 12.03.2013, 03:32

Well what is Tropinin, no it's not Tropinin.
The first picture - perhaps with a small copy of a portrait Tropinin, a neat , but unprepossessing . ( Since when do not know. Yeah , and know all things Tropinin never desire not to burn ).

Second - it is closer in style to fellow Zaryanko SK than to Tropinin.

However, given the quality of photos, more can be said.
Even we can not say whether it is painting or a reproduction of a painting.

uriart · 12.03.2013, 09:17

A portrait of a man's hand?

Is Tropinin could write so?

11.03.2013, 21:37	Язык оригинала: Русский #1
Art_beauty Местный Регистрация: 08.11.2012 Сообщений: 141 Спасибо: 53 Поблагодарили 12 раз(а) в 10 сообщениях Репутация: 24	VATropinin, interested in the opinion of experts Hello! I propose to discuss such work VATropinin (allegedly , of course) . I would like to hear the views of the maximum number of competent professionals. Questions he or is not he (and if not him, then on what grounds )? What is the opportunity cost ? Portrait of a Man : oil on canvas ; 38h32 . Portrait of a Woman : oil on canvas ; 42h34 . Миниатюры

11.03.2013, 23:39	Язык оригинала: Русский #5
Art_beauty Местный Регистрация: 08.11.2012 Сообщений: 141 Спасибо: 53 Поблагодарили 12 раз(а) в 10 сообщениях Репутация: 24	Found such a portrait. Konstantin G. Ravich Tropinin. Like the same character? But the signatures such that the "T" was a capital is not found. Миниатюры

Похожие темы
Тема	Автор	Разделы	Ответов	Последние сообщения
A.K.Beggrov, interested in the opinion of experts	Art_beauty	Costs, valuation, attribution	10	01.03.2013 12:06
Experts on cultural values. Can we trust the experts and how?	Artem	Appraisal	50	13.02.2011 02:25
Icons are interested in expert opinion	PAGANEL	Costs and attribution of icons	2	12.01.2011 06:45
What is it? And could these sheets, or anyone interested?	яков	Costs, valuation, attribution	5	14.01.2010 20:21
Продам: IK Parkhomenko - Who is interested?	bykinist	Sell	8	25.06.2009 18:56

11.03.2013, 21:58	Язык оригинала: Русский #2
мистер-у Старожил Регистрация: 02.09.2008 Сообщений: 700 Спасибо: 222 Поблагодарили 484 раз(а) в 201 сообщениях Репутация: 861	In such pictures can not say anything, and generally such items to donate to the circumstantial evidence atributsiyu.Po back side Tropinin never written on these canvases and did not put them such stretchers.

11.03.2013, 22:21	Язык оригинала: Русский #3
Art_beauty Местный Регистрация: 08.11.2012 Сообщений: 141 Спасибо: 53 Поблагодарили 12 раз(а) в 10 сообщениях Репутация: 24	Thank you. Canvas duplicated each other.

12.03.2013, 03:32	Язык оригинала: Русский #9
Игорь Гурьев Гуру Регистрация: 01.07.2009 Адрес: город П. Сообщений: 4,939 Спасибо: 6,544 Поблагодарили 6,620 раз(а) в 2,829 сообщениях Репутация: 13305	Well what is Tropinin, no it's not Tropinin. The first picture - perhaps with a small copy of a portrait Tropinin, a neat , but unprepossessing . ( Since when do not know. Yeah , and know all things Tropinin never desire not to burn ). Second - it is closer in style to fellow Zaryanko SK than to Tropinin. However, given the quality of photos, more can be said. Even we can not say whether it is painting or a reproduction of a painting.

12.03.2013, 09:17	Язык оригинала: Русский #10
uriart Banned Регистрация: 05.06.2008 Адрес: UKRAINE Сообщений: 8,039 Спасибо: 5,979 Поблагодарили 7,017 раз(а) в 2,462 сообщениях Репутация: 12461	A portrait of a man's hand? Is Tropinin could write so?