Copyright recurrence

[kropotkina-o]

Dear forum users, here are laid out several works, as you see it different variants of the same paintings. It's no secret that auctions often exhibited paintings, which are already known from museum and private sobraniyam.V This raises many questions: is the work of a later copy of how the repetition of his own work is characteristic of a particular artist, etc. . etc.? propose to talk about copyright repetitions as a phenomenon

Вложение 144445Вложение 144455

Вложение 144525Вложение 144535

Вложение 144515Вложение 144545

[kropotkina-o]

1.A.Gerasimov.Piony.Sochi, museum 2.A.Gerasimov.Piony.Sotbi, November 2008
3 and 4. A.Gerasimov.Piony (unfortunately now I can not say where)
5.N.Feshin. An elegant lady in white, Christie, osen2008 6.N.Feshin. An elegant lady in belom.Russky Museum

[dedulya37]

kropotkina-o,

C my point of view, the artists make the author's repetition in several cases:
- Young artists had success with the public, sold well
- When the motive of a picture or etude like the artist himself and he is ready to repeat it again and again
- When they need money badly, but no inspiration
- When the artist is already old and new ideas is not enough and in the open air to go hard
- At the request of someone else - in memory
- According to customer

Here, in my opinion, the main.

[dedulya37]

Here is the sketch and two paintings from him.
I think there are three reasons for repeat copyright: second, first and last.

[Tana]

if possible, and there sold by auction "copyright" repetition, though it was sold without examination?
http://forum.artinvestment.ru/showth...45&page=11

[dedulya37]

Tana,
I can only respond to works Stozharov.

[Pavel]

Repetition is one of the reasons why the picture of our artists do not reach the high prices at auctions. This is largely rezudtat learning and decency. By the way here on the site someone offered to sell the replay. Deep-error myself before doing repetitions of 100 dollars. loss of reputation. Also the name of the artist should be original and two artists from the same family, especially families, can not be on the top rating is, ie very expensive.

[kropotkina-o]

dedulya37, thanks for the exhaustive answer. However, the question of how the repetition of his own work is characteristic of a particular artist, remains open. Yes landscapes Stozharov (your three reasons for repeat copyright), yes, still lifes Gerasimov (although in the case of Sotheby's is plagued by vague doubts about me "). But Feshin?" When I got out the online catalog Christie, I was sure that it is free as a copy (with similarity of motive, the authenticity of texture, brushwork, touch not obvious) for so surprised to learn that the work went very well, and the site she was given the green metku.To same is the case with an example of Tana.

[Артём]

The first painting stolen from me, it was a pity - repeated, a third on order. So there were repetitive. My story.

[dedulya37]

Сообщение от Artem

My story.

I Stozharov I counted a total of six repetitions of copyright.
They were written as gifts.