A collection of female portraits.

[алексанр]

Thanks for any info!

[redbor]

Сообщение от aleksanr ; 2131221"

portrait of the second - A.Harlamovu .

I doubt very much .
Alexey Kharlamov wrote many wonderful portraits.
In this he was special ! Here nevysokoprofessionalno drawn.
And it's not a portrait , a sketch for the next Madonna and Child.
Over there and shine under the haloes around the heads harvested .
(if and Kharlamov , then , unless , by a youth copying someone else )
 But the work of the Orenburg - N.Dmitrieva quite plausible .

[Серафима Вершинина]

As for "Kharlamov," so this is some third-rate copy of a Murillo unknown author.

[redbor]

Yeah, that Murillo?
Or suggestion?

I did not see a Madonna by him.

[Серафима Вершинина]

Сообщение от redbor; 2131751 '

Yeah, that Murillo ? Or suggestion ?

I did not pretend to know all the so - Madonnas of Murillo 's face <! - ~ 1 ~ -> But that is a copy of it, in my opinion , obviously. Since digging through his numerous Madonnas to find exactly the one copied in this case , I'm too lazy to <! - ~ 1 ~ - > excuse me <! - ~ 12 ~ ->, we assume that this assumption is is the subjective opinion!

[Дилетант]

Сообщение от aleksanr ; 2131221"

first attributed the portrait on the left - N.Dmitrievu Orenburg .
The second portrait- A.Harlamovu .
The third portrait without signatures .

 
The first portrait is attributed to Dmitriev , Orenburg , without the slightest reason. Offend the stranger , kindly offered the for all to see his collection, would not want to , but - alas!
N.D.Dmitriev - Orenburg - an artist who worked at soundly academic manner , and not one iota of it is not retreating , the author of several very expressive portraits of Alexander III and the Grand Dukes . Tunic , ND - Sweet, harmonious, brilliantly written (whether it Reaper , peasant women from the " Fire in the village ," or ladies with custom portraits) . In short, N.D.Dmitriev - Orenburg - master, who spoke beautifully of his profession . And then , excuse me, a mug . ( The inscription on the reverse of the argument can not be considered ).

The second work also has no relation to the claimed author. ( Explain why it is not Kharlamov - I think, too ).

[алексанр]

Thank you for the discussion! I now have a clearer idea of ​​the location of these " pictures" in the same range of human values ​​... Some time ago I received an offer to sell them in bulk for 5000 p . However, it seemed to me that this price is below the real cost of this entire collection. I asked for exactly 2 times the amount that is 10 000 p . In order to ascertain an independent opinion , and I posted the above topic here at the suggestion of a potential buyer.
Parting without regret !

[Дилетант]

Сообщение от aleksanr ; 2132461 '

Some time ago I received an offer to sell them in bulk for 5000 p .

The attraction of unprecedented generosity ! Give without delay , while the buyer is not intercepted . ( And that to- and-a -ak raid on his competitors <! - ~ 1 ~ -> <! - ~ 1 ~ -> <! - ~ 1 ~ -> Ka -a -ak offered him a five - eight pieces that tysch hierarchy with Lagorio !

[алексанр]

I apologize , but I do not understand the last comment .
Understood only by the presence of humor ... probably at an inadequate price possible ..? Do you think that the marked price is low ? Unrealistically high or vice versa ? I then printed calendars perelistnye seen in 3500r . Are these pictures may not be worth 5000r . ? After all, someone has painted ... Or do you think that these pictures for free , and no one needs , and if someone something for them to pay , you should give?
I once spent a nesorazmerimo them a large sum . Certainly not because of the signatures on the back , but only on the basis of how-to unusual expressive portraits ( though of course it's also my perception of the amateurish , as I now realize played a not a good joke to me)
Please excuse my diletanstvo ...
Thank you in advance !

[Дилетант]

Сообщение от aleksanr ; 2132561"

I do not understand the last comment .
Understood only by the presence of humor ... probably at an inadequate price possible ..? Do you think that the marked price is low ? Unrealistically high or vice versa ? I then printed calendars perelistnye seen in 3500r . Are these pictures may not be worth 5000r . ?

Alexander, please accept my apologies. I was just joking inelegant . Of course , these pictures are worth 5,000 rubles . Yes, and 10,000 is probably worth ...