Alexei Petrovich Bogolyubov

[мистер-у]

If you went to such a spree, it propose to raise the criticism of those times on creativity hudozhnika.Vot then everything will fall into place, but I warn you in advance, the criticism of multidirectional orientation.
Popovodu "rarities" on the market works by the artist, information neobektivnaya.Otkroyte site "Russian Seasons," there are two big raboty.Dva Etude offered me this week.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Mr-y

propose to raise the criticism of those times on creativity hudozhnika.Vot then everything will fall into

And what will explain to the dispute about the segodnyaschney to assess the place AP Bogolyubov in world history, arts critic of those times? What "will fall into place?

[Jasmin]

Well, not introduced Bogolyubov contribution to the development of world art, well, did not say a new word in painting, and his style he did not have - a traditional academic, the average level for those days ... So what? He has a few good works, with quite impressionist notes ... One might think that modern artists all have their face, their style, their own way ... Everything repeats itself: and now have a bunch of "theorem" to the school, which chew the cud ...

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Jasmin

Well, not introduced Bogolyubov contribution to the development of world art, well, did not say a new word in painting, and his style he did not have - a traditional academic, the average level for that time ...

That's right. : D

Сообщение от Jasmin

So what?

Nothing is not added. You are all saying: "not made", "not told", "no" ... : o

Сообщение от Jasmin

He's got some good work, with quite impressionist notes ...

Yes. For example, I showed here my favorite work of Bogoliubov-"Winter in Borisoglebsk. : p

[SAH]

With Bogoliubov such as "figured out" is not whether we go to his two disciples who wrote ranzher?

Сообщение от ranzher

Without great achievements AP Bogolyubov to Russian culture, yet it must be admitted that all the superlatives in the determination of his creative contribution, given in your text, just loosely with one important reservation -- only for Russian art.
In the context of European art of the 19 th century he was an artist medium capacity.
Art world can do without his work, without losing its integrity. Here, for example, without and his disciples Polenova Pohitonova can not.

[Tana]

again quoting from ranzher on Bogolyubovo:
"art world can do without his work, without losing its integrity. And here, for example, without his disciples Polenova and Pohitonova can not."
  so did he brought his "contribution" - in the form of his disciples!
because quite often we talk about the artists: "Yes he's learned from the very ....!"
or "Do you know who was his teacher?"
but now what do we obtain Polenov and Pokhitonov learned from some kind of hierarchy there? (do not think that they both thought of their recent findings teacher)

in the end and at Kuinzhi famous paintings were all only a few, well, I do not know who will turn the language to call it mediocre artist.

[мистер-у]

All Russian artists contributed to the history of Russian art from the artist neklassnogo to professora.Pochti they hang in museums around the CIS and other museums of the world iskusstva.Vse they honored us, is "Our artists, as Bulgakov called his book.
Each in itself has to understand is his artist or net.Istoriya Russian painting has long been arranged everything in its place, and we are only spectators.
Ukraine is trying to rewrite its history, but you are trying to rewrite the history of Russian painting? Already reached Polenova and Kuindzhi? Who's next, gentlemen? Bryullov and Ivanov?
Fear God and gentlemen!

[Seriy]

IMHO, the dispute about anything, it means to anything, and will, rather, will be endless. Can close the topic? very sorry to see how such intelligent, education, people spend their precious time. In English, there is an exact expression-waste your time - sending their time in the wastebasket.

[Pavel]

I think, and increasingly convinced that it was we had a good, it ðóñêèé source of goodness, strength, and civilization, especially when we are together.

[Ухтомский]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

Voila!
  Battles.

You casually read the article published in the first post of this topic, if not read it.

Сообщение от Tjutchev

     In January 1841 Bogolyubov, with seventeen years old, graduated from the Marine Corps and was released with the rank of warrant officer and since then constantly went to foreign vessels.
 

As you can see in 1841 was Bogolyubov 17 and he had just graduated from Sea Cadet Corps. Given that this work has written a schoolboy who did not study at art school, and in the Sea Cadet Corps, where he was forbidden to paint, this work is impressive. Is not it?

Сообщение от Tjutchev

   
     In 1832, Alexey Bogolyubov was given to the Alexander juvenile case, where two years later he was transferred to the Naval Cadet Corps. Even then Bogolyubov discovered a great love for drawing. The young artist was "... a desperate gaiety and mischievous disposition ...". "A passion for painting ruined me, too, - he remembered - because I hit in his leisure hours in the cartoons, which also augmented my troubles."

     Once Bogolyubov was nearly hit by drawing a caricature of the examination board. Its simple, but take my word that he would not draw until I wear epaulettes.

   

to make conclusions about the artist's work, relying on his child's picture, in my opinion, stupid.

Fight 12-gun Luger "Maximum" under the command of Lieutenant NF Metlina with the Greek 60-gun corvette "Sketsiya in Monastery Bay (the island of Paros) July 27, 1832. 1841
Oil on canvas. 39 x 60 cm