What distinguishes the true artist from not present?

[artcol]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

In-in, but it is often the artist his "seriousness" puts forward, and this "seriousness" is often salerievskaya next to Mozart's "not serious".
I did not laugh when a painter worthless
I stain the Madonna by Raphael,
I did not laugh when a contemptible buffoon
Parody dishonors Alighieri. (c)

It's all about the mask. I am different. For me, Kulik - this is serious, and Shilov - are long gone. Shilov not risk, does not investigate, Shilov - earns.
Talent in my opinion - is knowledge. But someone, they are given from birth, and some of their hard comprehend. And not the fact that the first result will be more HX than the second
In addition, success in studies of fine arts is very important as human material - people can simply not designed for this. Scoop proof.

[AlexanderG]

Сообщение от LCR

I'm very curious

The talent is immeasurable, and for me the only criterion - my taste,

Liubezneishaia LCR, imenno ob etom ia i govoriu, vsio eto ochen 'sub'ektivno, av dannoi teme predpriniata popytka ob'ektivizatsii.

PS Dlia menia moi vkus tak ze iavliaetsia osnovnym kriteriem

Added after 2 minutes

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

In-in, but it is often the artist his "seriousness" puts forward, and this "seriousness" is often salerievskaya next to Mozart's "not serious".

A kak rastsenit 'sopernichestvo Bernini i Boromini? Kto Sal'eri?

Added after 4 minutes

Сообщение от LCR

Talent is immeasurable

Kak v starom Odesskom anekdote, hochetsia otvetit ': "O!"

Esli ne znaete, napishu v lichku.

Added after 7 minutes

Сообщение от artcol

For me Kulik - seriously,

Iz togo, chto ia videl, i chital, i slushal, dlia menia on daze ne suschestvuet, skuchno do oskominy.

Uz luchshe Shilov

No, kak ia pisal ran'she, hudoznikom /zivopistsem on ne iavliaetsia, nekorrektnoe sravnenie.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от AlexanderG

A kak rastsenit 'sopernichestvo Bernini i Boromini? Kto Sal'eri?

Who's there was a "Salieri" I find it hard to judge the real composer Antonio Salieri nobody hunted, of course.
A Bernini and Borromini rivalry, yes. And there are all sorts of stories, legends, fables and stories to that effect. Neapolitan Bernini is merry and scoffers, teased a Roman Borromini.
And anyone who is just tell us how there was a suicide Borromini?
Versions are. I know one. Associated with a fountain.

I think that is meant Fountain of four rivers / Fontana dei Quattro Fiumi to Piazza Navona . No?

[AlexanderG]

Сообщение от v_r

If you can not compare, it can be assumed that these characters are artists.

Pozaluista, ne zabyvaite, chto eto na vash vzgliad.
Sudia po prodazam i blagosostoianiu, oni vpolne uspeshny i podderzany kollektsionerami.

From a professional point of view, it is the skills and responsibility for the outcome of their work, there is lame on all 4 limbs.

Obosnuite. Inache eto goloslovnoe utverzdenie.

In my opinion, you should not confuse art and show business.

Izobrazitel'noe iskusstvo po vsem parametram popadaet v industriiu razvlechenii, i vo mnogih gosdepartamentah imenno za etoi industriei i chislitsia.

Added after 4 minutes

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

Who's there was a "Salieri" I find it hard to judge the real composer Antonio Salieri nobody hunted, of course.
A Bernini and Borromini rivalry, yes. And there are all sorts of stories, legends, fables and stories to that effect. Neapolitan Bernini considered merry and scoffers, teased a Roman Borromini.
And anyone who is just tell us how there was a suicide Borromini?
Versions are. I know one. Associated with a fountain.

I think that is meant Fountain of four rivers / Fontana dei Quattro Fiumi to Piazza Navona . No?

Naskol'ko ia znaiu, eto byla sumasshedshaia zavist ', tk Bernini poluchal vse papskie kommissii (po-moemu oni byli chut 'li ne sosediami), i serioznuiu podderzku.
A vtoromu prihodilos 'rabotat' v men'shih masshtabah, hotia delal on eto potriasaiusche.

Vidimo i togda talantomerom ne pol'zovalis ', a pol'zovalis' universal'nymi metodami otbora.

[iside]

Cyril Syzransky, you simply prefer the man-dog than Shilov and Safronov, or indeed willing to put in a number Kulik and Rembrandt?

[Кирилл Сызранский]

iside, talking about Rembrandt was not, as far as I remember.
In one series with Kulik's difficult to place, that's quite ryadomnestoyaschie phenomena agree.
But Kulik interesting to me, I am interested in everything that makes this artist, I understand a lot, and often strange and interesting. I'm sure. At least the desire to understand, understand.
But Shilov and Safronov dents are not interesting to me, except that the phenomenon of their popularity, although it is clear to me, too, is understandable, but the technology rasskrutki is in place (and where's more, who knows them outside of Russia? - ->) may be helpful. Although ... And everything is clear with these "artists".

[AlexanderG]

Naskol'ko ia znaiu, Safronov i vne Rossii izvesten.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от AlexanderG

Safronov i vne Rossii izvesten.

Of course, personal fairground on the best venues in London, NY, Paris!
Press, output mnogotyasyachnymi The album, monographs in Spanish, German, Chinese, English!
Films on the world's leading channels!
Monoauktsion at Sotheby's, the fantastic goings on it, and as a result, the top lines in the list of top 100 contemporary artists.
Yes, it's so ...

[iside]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

Talk about Rembrandt was not, as far as I remember

No, but it is a logical conclusion.
Rembrandt - a true artist.
AlexanderG said that for him a true artist and Shilov Safronov.
You say that you a real artist Kulik - that Rembrandt and Kulik - real artists.

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

But Kulik me interesting, I am interested in everything that makes this artist, I understand a lot, and often strange and interesting. I'm sure. While the desire to understand, to understand

Cyril Syzransky, this means an urgent need to go to where the sun and heat, white sand and the whisper of the sea, such is the season in the Bahamas - it is much more useful than the sort in the dog-man.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от AlexanderG

Safronov i vne Rossii izvesten.

From the fashionable hotel "Passed Pawn" was released-time world champion Jose Raul Capablanca-and-Graupera. He was surrounded by ladies. The policeman, dressed in a special form of chess (breeches in a cage and elephants in their buttonholes), politely saluted. By the champion with the dignity of one-eyed man approached the chairman of the club vasyukinskogo four horses. Conversation of the two stars, who drove in the English language, was interrupted by the arrivals of Dr. Grigoriev and future world champion Alekhine. Welcome clicks shocked the city. Jose-Raul Capablanca-and-Graupera frowned. As the wave of the hands of the one-eyed to the airplane was filed with the marble staircase. Dr. Grigoriev ran on it, waving in greeting a new hat and commenting on the move possible error Capablanca in the upcoming match with Alekhine. (c)
Once remembered ... arrival of Dr. Grigoryev, who waved in greeting a new hat ..." JACARU " from specially of leather ...

Added after 3 minutes

Сообщение от iside

go immediately to where the sun and heat, white sand and the whisper of the sea

No, do not.
No urgency, to be held in February, the snow will melt, and the sand and we have many. Can he not so white as the Bahamas, but there the sand is the last on my list is mandatory for viewing.

Better a few extra days at the Orsay resemble ...

Added after 15 minutes

Сообщение от iside

You say that you a real artist Kulik - that Rembrandt and Kulik - real artists.

Yes, of course, in this series I can see them side by side, yes.