Back to the gallery of Russian art in New York filed a multimillion-dollar lawsuit

[Ukraine]

Schematically , this situation looks like this ;

In America Bekkerman suspicion of fraud , the buyer - the victim of an honest man .

In the CIS Bekkerman victim claims negligent buyer , the buyer is a victim of a careless seller.

Such a matrix itself , which can be controlled .

Simply , this situation will be closed in various planes.
The seller will dry in America, the CIS knows that he is so professional.
The buyer will be highlighted in the west ( in the end may end up the settlement details of which are not disclosed ) will eventually be remembered by everyone as a person rich and powerful , not only capable of solving problems in their own country but also abroad and in the Western media will be highlighted and Google will be more of it see .

That's because the air can sculpt an intangible asset !

Added after 1 minutes
Another situation can be managed like a pro in Russian art, and just ordinary people perceive it differently.
For some, it is white, others black.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

According to Arthur Properties, in 2007-2008, its buyer , Alexander Savchuk purchased from Beckermann 18 works Russian painters of the XIX and XX century. In total, the plaintiff has paid for a painting 9,5 million dollars.

But the List of 18 paintings and prices:

I. Aivazovsky "Peter the Great on a red hill ", $ 4,000,000 ;
GI Shishkin, "The Forest" , $ 1 million ;
S. Bakalovich " gourmet dinner ", $ 150 thousand ;
K. Korovin, "Boats on the beach ", $ 760 thousand ;
J. Schultze , " Boats at Sea ", $ 150 thousand ;
A. Altman " Natyumort with flowers ", $ 60 thousand ;
A. Altman "Landscape with hills and a lake ," $ 75 thousand ;
Burliuk "Walk ", $ 150 thousand ;
A. Isupov, "Still Life with Lilac ", $ 240 thousand ;
I. Payles "Still Life ", $ 25 thousand ;
M. Larionov "Sleeping Dog" , $ 300 thousand ;
K. Vestshilov "Woman , fingering the flowers ," $ 70 thousand ;
Alexander Archipenko "Dreams ", $ 300 thousand ;
Alexander Archipenko " Naked blonde ", $ 350 thousand ;
G. Semiradsky "Roman family on holiday ", $ 1 million ;
Goncharova , " Magnolia Flowers ", $ 250 thousand ;
K. Gorbatov, "Capri ", $ 450 thousand ;
I. Aivazovsky , "Traveler in the Crimea" , $ 250 thousand

[Promo]

On Sunday, Nov. 11, at 59, died MP from the Party of Regions, Alexander Savchuk, reports Donetsk regional organization of the Party of Regions.

[uriart]

Promo, probably the children will continue to sue, or later, all the brakes.

[Konstantin]

Сообщение от Promo

The plaintiff died, what the outcome of the story

So it seems really over.
Anatoly Bekkerman some courts have already won.
I agree with him about three weeks ago talking about it.
Detailed comment until it does not, but he had promised.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

almost two-year battle between Luxembourg company Arthur Properties, president of the Ukrainian oligarch "Azovmash" Alexander Savchuk and a Manhattan gallery owner of the ABA and its former citizens of Leningrad, Anatoly Bekkermanom completed. The parties came to an amicable agreement.

As stated in the lawsuit, filed in July 2011 in the Federal Court for the Southern District of New York, in 2007-2009. Savchuk purchased from Bekkerman 18 paintings of Russian masters of the XIX and XX centuries, paying for them in total, more than 9.5 million dollars.

According to the plaintiffs, getting pictures, the buyer discovered that four of them are not written by those artists whose authorship have Beckerman.

These works - "Roman family on vacation" Semiradsky, "In the Forest" Shishkin, "gourmet dinner" Bakalovich and "Flowers of Magnolias" Goncharova in aggregate were worth $ 2.4 million.

The petition also alleged that Beckerman strongly overestimated the market value of the 14 paintings, the authorship of which is indisputable. For example, the price of paintings by Aivazovsky "Peter the Great", according to the plaintiffs, was overstated "by about 80%."

"Do not you want to buy - free"

The last claim from the very beginning has produced a strange impression on observers.

"One of the main conditions of the contract of sale is the price - wrote in the New York site RUNYweb.com former Moscow lawyer and expert on Russian marine painters, Boris Kuznetsov. - In other words, you want to buy Aivazovsky at the price offered by the seller, buy. Would you buy - free. "

No wonder the Federal Judge Lewis Kaplan has long rejected this argument, the plaintiffs, who twice had to rewrite the statement of claim.

And a few days ago in the database Court laid down a document signed by both parties, whereby they prekrashayut lawsuit and will pay their own legal costs.

The parties' agreement

The parties undertook not to disclose details of the settlement agreement on the termination of the claim, but according to reports, Beckerman took back 4 of the canvas with the controversial authorship, the plaintiffs returned the money to him.

Three different source, who asked to remain incognito, confirmed the substance of the transaction.

"We have no doubt about the authenticity of these works, but what's the point of wasting millions of dollars on it to prove it in court? - Explained to me by one of them, simpatiziruschy side Bekkerman. - The federal courts absurdly expensive."

"My brother, unfortunately, had to fight in court, and it is worth the money and health - sigh younger brother of the defendant artist Edward Beckerman. - These people were wrong in every way. People have money and they do what they want. Thank God it's over! "

Anatoly Beckerman said that it is pleased with the outcome of the litigation.

"The matter was settled to the mutual satisfaction of the parties" - echoes the plaintiffs' attorney born in Gomel Oleg Rivkin. Kozlowski[/FONT][/I][/B].[/URL]