Help evaluate the picture - Страница 6 - Форум по искусству и инвестициям в искусство

I-V · 03.03.2011, 01:30

Цитата:

Сообщение от SAH; 1543211"

Sometimes the authorship is established and the canvas can not be letters.

Totally agree with you. I just meant that the "selection" of alleged authors went mostly with an eye on available initials, although in the case of this landscape, I would just are less likely to insist on this. Always remember the words of Professor-gatherer Boris Nikolaevich Okunev, as contained in memoirs C. Schuster: "Despite the signature, something authentic."

наследник · 03.03.2011, 02:05

Цитата:

Сообщение от IV

I do not think that someone from prinimavshh part in the" investigation "seriously believed in the involvement of these famous artists to create this web. It is unlikely that all so naive as to hope to identify the author of two letters.

Several pages of posts, "chop", and not all serious.

Added after 2 minutes

Цитата:

Сообщение от "SAH

Unlock the mystery, but then I is not available, but the thirst for enlightenment.
What with the sky, that's wrong with him?

Looked closely at all times.
Indeed, the sky is the best there is in this picture.

I-V · 03.03.2011, 07:34

Цитата:

Сообщение от IV

I do not think that someone from prinimavshh part in the" investigation "seriously believed in the involvement of these famous artists to create this web. It is unlikely that all so naive as to hope to identify the author of two letters.

Цитата:

Сообщение от heir 1543263

A few pages of posts," chop ", and not all serious.

I was wrong, of course, that I speak for others, I apologize. Maybe someone has for themselves and identified with the author. I just wanted to say that the process of attribution - it's always (initially, anyway) way of trial and error. The more (within reason, of course) assumptions versions, the clearer it becomes a place of work in the world of art. What is so terribly irreparable you find in these discussions - "investigations"? Do you own is not that interesting?

наследник · 03.03.2011, 08:03

Цитата:

Сообщение от IV

Do you own is not that interesting?

In this case, completely uninteresting. Why discuss something? Is it just post stuff to improve the grade.

... You will be astonished if the owner put up pictures of her in a decent format for the study.
However, do not necessarily have an egg to know it tuhlost.

silent · 04.03.2011, 14:52

And I Arkady Rylov remembered, can somewhere close?

Игорь Гурьев · 04.03.2011, 15:28

Цитата:

Сообщение от silent

And I Arkady Rylov remembered, can somewhere close?

It is under the influence of Rylova, but he wrote is not yet formed an artist.

наследник · 04.03.2011, 22:27

Цитата:

Сообщение от silent

And I Arkady Rylov remembered, can somewhere close?

Google about drunken Savrasov.

Added after 2 minutes

Цитата:

Сообщение от Guriev, Igor

This is under the influence of Rylova, but also wrote not really formed artist.

That's why I Savrasov and remembered. When he was drunk, was not completely formed.
While the talent is, of course, is not fully spend on drink.

Сергей Дородный · 05.03.2011, 21:45

Painting is even nothing.
And that means "amateur" in this case?
The author's whole idea (at least) of heat-cold
painting. Expression, the composition works, the original idea.
Pap pasty, punctuated - in an amateur way paint with a brush does not leave.
Middle hill just failed - relative to other relationships ought to be
enhance the contrast and color.
We must look for the author.

Peter · 05.03.2011, 22:37

This could be as late Monticelli and early Purva.
<!--~ 1 "-" Work is quite professional.
The rest, on the evaluation, recalled a bluff (forgive me).

Кирилл Сызранский · 10.03.2011, 04:32

Цитата:

Сообщение от Sergei burly

Painting is even nothing.

Yes, a good landscape.
Agreed.

[QUOTE="Sergei burly, 1546421] Middle hill just failed - relative to other relationships'd have to increase the contrast and color.

[/QUOTE]

I do not understand what's right.
You see a hill?

[size="1"]Added after 8 minutes[/size]

Цитата:

Сообщение от SAH

What's with the sky, that's wrong with him?

Yes, everything is normal there with the sky.

05.03.2011, 21:45	Язык оригинала: Русский #58
Сергей Дородный Старожил Регистрация: 17.07.2009 Адрес: Москва Сообщений: 593 Спасибо: 1,280 Поблагодарили 953 раз(а) в 370 сообщениях Репутация: 1839	Painting is even nothing. And that means "amateur" in this case? The author's whole idea (at least) of heat-cold painting. Expression, the composition works, the original idea. Pap pasty, punctuated - in an amateur way paint with a brush does not leave. Middle hill just failed - relative to other relationships ought to be enhance the contrast and color. We must look for the author. __________________ сайт с моими картинами http://dorodnyy.wordpress.com/ Последний раз редактировалось Сергей Дородный; 05.03.2011 в 21:53.

Похожие темы
Тема	Автор	Разделы	Ответов	Последние сообщения
Help evaluate the picture	Katerina-m	Costs, valuation, attribution	28	09.03.2011 22:32
Help evaluate the picture	fun_rus	Costs, valuation, attribution	36	10.02.2011 14:41
Help evaluate the picture	psix75	Costs, valuation, attribution	1	22.10.2010 13:38
Help evaluate the picture	Snow	Costs, valuation, attribution	8	03.09.2010 10:06
Help evaluate the picture	YDVIN	Costs, valuation, attribution	3	15.04.2010 10:07

04.03.2011, 14:52	Язык оригинала: Русский #55
silent Пользователь Регистрация: 19.04.2009 Сообщений: 70 Спасибо: 1,038 Поблагодарили 19 раз(а) в 10 сообщениях Репутация: 38	And I Arkady Rylov remembered, can somewhere close?

05.03.2011, 22:37	Язык оригинала: Русский #59
Peter Гуру Регистрация: 27.01.2010 Адрес: Москва Сообщений: 1,168 Спасибо: 5,106 Поблагодарили 4,043 раз(а) в 921 сообщениях Записей в дневнике: 4 Репутация: 8099	This could be as late Monticelli and early Purva. <!--~ 1 "-" Work is quite professional. The rest, on the evaluation, recalled a bluff (forgive me).