Please help us to define and evaluate the author's picture

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от annacz

The painting was purchased at the beginning of the 30th years.

Сообщение от K-Maler

According to the plot (Crimea?) And the manner of painting was written much earlier than the date of purchase.

To me, the painting of the first decade of the 20 th century., Not later, and before-possible.
The 19th century. quite possible.
For story: soon the South of Russia (Little Russia, New Russia). I have not seen the Black Sea, rather river.

[redbor]

Сообщение от DSF

Canvas signed back mainly on those works that are sent to the exhibition. It is easier to understand, what-where-someone. And the paperwork is less. Naturally, Levitan is no point was not to sign the little sketches in the back, because he never planned to send them.

I do not say why Levitan did not sign the sketches behind, and - why Levitan and others still sign yourself work ? To attest to authorship.
A canvas or a frame sign already in a variety of reasons (sending and mn.) And it can not be signed by the author.
This is all to the fact that not every name written differently as to the painting itself, assume the signature of the author.
  Signature of author-obviously only on the product.
  In other places - unconditional.
  This picture is very well written (from the fact that you can see from this photo&gt, it would be strange to the author it is not signed. But if it is a copy, then another thing, the signature can not be.

[наследник]

Сообщение от Eugene

SergeiSK, You're right, not a bad painting ..

But me - strike me thunder! - Imagine, that the author is not Russian breed. And the landscape is not Russian.
But mind you!=Is the only sensation that can push an expert on the search in another direction.

[Marjana]

Сообщение от redbor

At the stretcher can be written by anyone, and the author as well. Do not you think?

The museum's practice is not accepted to write on the canvas, so all the tagging options for attribution and so forth, are doing on a stretcher. Written on the canvas, or its reverse side - the exclusive right of the author. However, the signature stretchers - a common practice among artists, but not the fact that the canvas stretched on a frame and recorded owner onogo!

[redbor]

Сообщение от Marjana

.. but not the fact that the canvas stretched on a frame and recorded owner onogo!

Of course. Only the signature on the painting - a fact that the author.
That's the question - why not always signed by his picture?
Something does not allow him to sign?

Сообщение от heir

But me - strike me thunder! - Imagine, that the author is not Russian breed. And the landscape is not Russian. .

  Wood, definitely not Russian!

[SergeiSK]

Сообщение от redbor

tree, just not Russian!

Big tree on the left - this is poplar. Well, or a huge cypress tree with discolored with age, bark

[redbor]

Сообщение от SergeiSK

big tree on the left - this is poplar. Well, or a huge cypress tree with discolored with age, bark

So - Sochi, a river Kudepsa or Mzymta?

[SergeiSK]

Сообщение от redbor

So - Sochi, a river Kudepsa or Mzymta?

For the Caucasus is very quiet river painted ... But for the Kuban and Don landscape is well suited.

[наследник]

Сообщение от SergeiSK

For the Caucasus is very quiet river painted ... But for the Kuban and Don landscape is well suited.

I've considered the house ... clothes for women ... the ratio of trees, water ... Emanate from all this is not Russian appeasement. Burgher some. Before the First World.

... That I'm talking about the second picture.

[Анна_Шут]

Tell me please, I ask a question on this forum about the pictures and insert the picture. If possible, all stages. I sit for a third day, and I do not get. Thank you in advance.