Help attributing "Peony"

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Vivien

Your "Peony" - weaker, they are very good, but somehow more carefully written out, without recklessness, without virtuosity.

And what "foolhardiness" in the still lifes I. Katz? I was there vanity but only flickering and saw. And educational setting in huduchilischah.
The only thing that unites Peonies and still Kac-availability vase shape LPF big round in the first and last.

[Вивьен]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzranskiy

What kind of "foolhardiness" in the still lifes I. Katz? I was there vanity but only flickering and saw.

Dear, Cyril Syzranskiy, I did not write what I see "foolhardiness" in "frivolous and melteshnyh" productions I. Katz. I expressed my view that pionchiki discharged conscientiously and carefully, without special features. And you ask ...

Added after 1 minutes
You yourself agree that

[Кирилл Сызранский]

[Вивьен]

[chealex]

Сообщение от Vivien

Signature not exactly it.
However, there is still Michael S. Katz (August 29, 1945, Perm - June 11, 2004) - Soviet film director, screenwriter and production designer.
He graduated from the theater and art school in Odessa and Leningrad Theatre Institute. Worked at Odessa Film Studio (artistic director since 1976, director since 1988, screenwriter since 1991).
I think that Mikhail S. was not weak in any picture or painting.
But his work as the sample signature, I have never met.

Сообщение от Vivien

looking. What can I say: I think the work I. Katz, in particular, still lifes - pictures with a professional style and distinctive handwriting. Your "Peony" - weaker, they are very good, but somehow more carefully written out, without recklessness, without virtuosity.

Sweetheart, Vivian!
Why such a categorical about the signature? I spread a few options signatures Kac-they are all different. Yes, he still lives different from mine "Peony", but, because landscape painting is quite out "carefully", as you pointed out. Perhaps, early in his still lifes were similar. By the way, thanks to Cyril for his attention to such details as the vase. I also drew attention to it. Sometimes the details can play a role.
Mikhail Semenovich Katz, I also considered, but did not find any data. Perhaps he was a good painter, but somehow it seems difficult to work recent graduates was purchased by the Commission of the USSR Union. One has to admit that "Peonies" 1970-80-ies. After all, we know how to purchase and whom.
I am very grateful to you for your attention to my "Peony".

[dedulya37]

[chealex]

Сообщение от dedulya37

That's about it more in detail you can, please?

What is clear?
In my opinion, a well known fact that the Soviet Union the picture before you get to the exhibition was the selection of so-called Art Commission. Even membership in the SC is not guaranteed hit. And the more it concerned procurement. Can a handful - who at 25-30-year became a member of the USSR Union and its work purchased. This is the age at the most unlikely scenario, stayed mentioned Michael L. Katz. I repeat, is not familiar with the work of this artist, so I can not judge his talent. Maybe someone familiar - then answer!

[dedulya37]

Сообщение от chealex

who is the 25-30-year became a member of the USSR Union

Now I understand you.
By this age, as a rule, young artists have already become members of national associations (in your case - Ukraine), and only then, with the active participation in the exhibitions they may have been admitted to membership in the USSR.
As for Hood. Commissions - I agree (but they called art councils), not all of them missed, but he was a positive thing, as a rule did not allow any d --- about. And it was not an ideological barrier, but a purely professional.
You may be just the opposite view, of course.

[K-Maler]

Сообщение от chealex

Why are you so categorical about the signature? I spread a few options signatures Kac-they are all different. Yes, he still lives different from mine "Peony", but, because landscape painting is quite out "carefully", as you pointed out. Perhaps, early in his still lifes were similar.

On the "Peony" at the bottom is clearly visible the first letter "M" initial name. But the name clearly, there seemed to have a "continuation", twirl, like this ... Art and especially the composition vary widely, it is not done with one hand ...

[Артём]

Сообщение от K-Maler

surname unclear, there seems to have a" continuation ", twirl, like that

I think so too.
In addition, divorce on the other side talk about bad sizing the canvas and later applied to him emulsion paint. So did the "cheap and quick" artists 70's, 80's in art mills, and to stretch the canvas shows that this bartovka sots.vremen, linen canvas so natyanesh (very tight where the nails, between - slack).
Strong Still Life seventies.