Need advice specialists

[наследник]

I'm afraid to apply in person ... but you serious?
Not a single emoticon for transfer to another plane.
 

Сообщение от heir

I Chur, chur!
Fastened to the tree picture ... former in poor condition at the edges, without paint, with a test in Munich - a rarity

[Amateur]

Сообщение от heir

Not a single emoticon for transfer to another plane.

So we have somewhere to post number 11 went to "another plane".

[наследник]

Сообщение от Amateur

So we have somewhere to post number 11 went to "another plane".

And who understand? Me and you?

[Amateur]

In my opinion, everything is all very understandable - K-Maler lucidly explained:
 

Сообщение от K-Maler

Someone trained and failed. Composition is confident and hand. Everything else ... He did not cope with "teploholodnostyu, all razbeleno, ideas, no scenery, the trees are the same ... A signature? Under this etude signature does not raise, the more so by the unsuccessful ...

In general, wrote the artist in explanation Shishkina as managed. A mock-why? Well, vdaril once, twice, and senseless why beat? And there is something in this sketch, for example, "veil of time". You, heir, they themselves have written: "I would take if you do not translate from French into Russian." About the translation can forget - take it.

[наследник]

Сообщение от Amateur

take.

I'm afraid that in the light of vsegovysheskazannogo will be a little expensive for me

[таша]

Сообщение от heir

I'm afraid to apply in person ... but you serious?
Not a single emoticon for transfer to another plane.

Well silly, I blurted out, forgive me generously! The question has been to specialists, I do not know why reply to the topic, in which no sense .... Bes misled ... not anymore. I'm afraid some wrong smiley slapped ... Well, in general, I'm embarrassed.

[LCR]

Сообщение от Tasha

Well, I blurted out stupid, forgive me generously! The question has been to specialists, I do not know why reply to the topic, in which no sense .... Bes misled ... not anymore. I'm afraid some wrong smiley slapped ... Well, in general, I'm embarrassed.

Oh, come on you, Tasha, for Christ's sake!
What kind of "stupidity" you "blurted out"? What are you apologizing for? And to whom, before the subject, which comes to the forum with the sole purpose obhamit and humiliate - almost always beginners because it is easier?
All the ones who understand what it is, just do not pay attention to him, let's join

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от LCR

What kind of "stupidity" you "blurted out"?

tasha agreed with razglyadevshem the end of the signature letter "e".
And I do not know why did she apologized, and what such a "stupid blurted out." : D

[Черномашенцев Владимир]

Сообщение от Andrej Sikorski

Painting (17,5 x 29) canvas board, age 120 years

  Sorry humbly amateur. I looked at the picture - for me, so the style is more like the Impressionists, but not both at the smooth end of the 19 paintings stoleniya. Even if we imagine that this sketch, which probably stems from the size. If the painting is really 120 years old - then it is a rarity. Unknown Russian Impressionist ahead!!

But I think that is more reminiscent of student etude and life to him - 20-30 years.

[Amateur]

Сообщение от Chernomashentsev Vladimir

But I think that is more reminiscent of student etude and life to him - 20-30 years.

Perhaps because turnover, alas, not to see:

Сообщение от Andrej Sikorski

painting, oil canvas, the edges of cardboard were in poor condition, some places non-kraski.Potom was attached a picture of a tree.

But 20-30 years ago, our students are likely to "subscribe" to in English, not French, that is, perhaps, sketch and older will be. This is - if the sketch of domestic origin.

Сообщение от Chernomashentsev Vladimir

I looked at the picture - for me, so style is more like the Impressionists.

So, copying Shishkin, student gathering of falling into the ranks of the Impressionists! Keep it up, students!