Help evaluate the picture

[kr555]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

And I do not understand.
Can give an example of some.
So I imagine the situation: someone has a copy ... Well, I do not know ... "Boatmen" Repin. And who just want to understand this copyist says: "Viktorych-on, and you have a better picture of something ..." My colleague, the viewer, critic, art critic or the Directorate of the Russian Museum went out into the hall, and comparing, anyone? The buyer of the copy?
I'm no art is not bad, alas, and perhaps, therefore, to understand you do not do it.
Not explain?

Well, I certainly will give the Japanese example.
That's one of the world's most famous works of Japanese art, screen, "Waves at Matsushima" great Ogata Korin (1658-1716), from the collections of the Boston Museum of Fine Arts (picture below).
The picture is not the trailer. Here is the link to the website of the museum, there is true quality is not very
http://educators.mfa.org/objects/detail/195795
But not everyone knows that a free copy of the work of his predecessor, Tawara Sotatsu (? -1643). The original can be seen at the newly opened website, he of the meeting Galleries Freera.
http://www.googleartproject.com/muse...matsushima-126
Original weaker and much less is known ...

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от kr555

But not everyone knows that a free copy of the work of his predecessor, Tawara Sotatsu

And how much it is "free"?
Dimensions?
Some bringing their own?
What's copyist nasvobodnichal?

[kr555]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

And how much is "free"? Dimensions? Some bringing their own? What's copyist nasvobodnichal?
____________________
Oh, he has already seen everything.
Well, listen, what kind of "copy"? It is "based on" no more.

Well, yes, it is not literally of course
But the idea of something stale in its pure form, just a little improved.
And we are suspicious of the copies in the first place probably because the idea is not his own. So something in the painting under discussion is probably some kind of change is, in the photo a bit difficult to tell how strong.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от "kr555

It's the picture in the discussion is likely some changes there

There is a "change" is - for the worse.

[Grigory]

Сообщение от "kr555

Picture not the trailer.
Here is the link to the website of the museum, there is true quality is not very

Trailer, where she was going to go away ....

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Grigory

the trailer where she was going to go away ....

Now just "appear" pictures in messages is not as soon as I noticed.

[kr555]

Сообщение от Grigory

trailer, where she was going to go away ....

And now, and my attachment manifested itself in 2 hours ... Something really slow the last couple of days.

Posted 40 minutes

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

times of the copies went to such a conversation, and I show copy Sudkovskaya with this stuff, and its author - Bogaevsky Konstantin. Itself, this copy is in Feodosia in the National Gallery of them. IK Aivazovsky.

Can be compared.

Oh, but this generally cool. Do not be surprised if now she is just better than the original (for lack of a normal image of the original can only guess).
(Until answered, a message somewhere and lost ... but I still survived)))

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Time went on copies of such a conversation, and I'll show you a copy.
With this thing Sudkovskaya, and its author - Bogaevsky Konstantin.
Itself, this copy is in Feodosia

[fun_rus]

can be summed up ...?

whether to bother with the sale of this painting?

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Time went on copies of such a conversation, and I show up with this stuff Sudkovskaya, and its author - Bogaevsky Konstantin.
Itself, this copy is in Feodosia in the National Gallery of them.
IK
Aivazovsky.


Can be compared.