Vekselberg has accused Christie's in counterfeit trade

[Игорь Гурьев]

Сообщение от Eriksson; 2127521"

And did not become a commonplace object , the Vakselberg domestic " wiring "? It's necessary to understand how many people earn a good couple of years to prove his pravodu

Vekskelberg - this is a typical nerd , what with the demand of Loja , if he bought fifty semi- kitsch of the Imperial eggs for a hundred lemons ?

Well, who after him will be treated seriozno ?
Idiot , but as it is called ?

[Дилетант]

Сообщение от Guriev, Igor; 2127391"

Tov. Amateur, I do not know whether to read the above my humble opinion.

In my opinion, this picture is written exactly as good Kustodiev.

Genosse Guriev, Igor, read, of course (I did carefully read most of the reviews posted here.) And in general - absolutely agree with you.
However, it seems to me, discussing the topic in the role and place of Boris Mikhailovich Kustodiev in the art world, we will contact you run the risk of slipping in the perpendicular plane. (And I roll - well, not. I'm afraid to break the neck of the femur. Age, osteoporosis, ivsetakoe ...)
So stupidly shared his conservative views on a particular work in context. "He" - he did not. "And not because he believes in the authenticity of the picture, not at all. Tokmo And because not everyone here is so low.
And the picture - not novodelny zadurok. And her first appearance on the public relates to the period when they lived, and long live artists, art critics and collectors who are familiar with the work of Kustodiev.
And I have a lot of questions about technology. And I do not know what the results of chemical and X-ray studies ...
And yet - a cloud Khrenova moments, without explaining that this question is resolved, in my opinion, can not be.
Oh, and that the evidence base can not be based on the "brilliant" arguments such as "short kolchuzhka," "is not as good women are" and "I have not seen such blankets, means - it's not Kustodiev" - is obvious.
And more. Let me make a heretical thought (such as "hard-to-height-to speak, and height-to-a-say '): whatever decision is handed down a London court, the question (for me) still remains open. Before the advent of a more serious and credible arguments. With komprivetom, Dilettante.

Added after 35 minutes

Сообщение от Guriev, Igor; 2127481"

valance - is something that goes vertically along the bottom of the bed (on verovochke stretched from right to left nozhke bed nozhke),

"Along the bottom of the bed" and "from the legs to the leg" - this is called "horizontal".
Although overhangs - it's me in a polemical fervor - that mahanula little. Maybe where he held out. (Vaughn, and under the keel on the rope - stretched ...)
PERSONAL AND SOBSVENNORUCHNO I saw in the province Yaroslaskoy feather blanketed the lower sheet (from severe or unbleached fabrics), trimmed with lace around the edge (perhaps where - and Brabant, and in such Tutaev he has never seen). But it certainly was a strip of lace scalloped, so that was out of the top sheet was beautiful to see. Who sledvalo.
Not only seen, but with the permission of the hostess personally rip off ...
All of them - to teach the materiel! (And I - in the processing poplyalasya).

Сообщение от Eriksson; 2127521"

I suddenly came up with this idea ... strange And did not become a commonplace object, the Vakselberg domestic "wiring"? It's necessary to understand how many people earn a good couple of years to prove his pravodu in court: lawyers, critics, journalists and others paid up.

Here! We stared the same thought occurred five years ago. Came, and there nestled snugly. Especially gambling, even blocked, as law firms and for how many generations will be able to comfortably exist in this one case ... (The last scene of Gogol's "The Tale of how Ivan Ivanovich quarreled with Ivan Nikiforich").

Added after 1 minutes 36 minutes

Сообщение от Guriev, Igor; 2127481"

Ay-ay-ay, comrade. Amateur, awkward somehow naschot overhangs ....

Yes, I too pochuvstvola some awkwardness. And instead of immediately putting on boots with galoshes and pentyuhat to work (to perform a personal financial plan), the cat ran like mad to check the meaning of "valance".
And that's what I tell you, Genosse Guriev, Igor. From time immemorial the word "valance" in Russia (for clothing, curtains, sheets and other furs) was used exclusively in the sense of "fringe, fringe, frill." And no fringe, no fringe, no frill on their own (ie - not that they otorochivayut and fringe) can not exist. Become bored. Sick. Search for, what would they, poor thing, to cleave.
And neither of which strings have not been contacted either Dahl or Ozhegov or others like them. So - right fellow dabbler (and I wondered whether it differently. Well I - my own eyes! Own hands!)
 And you - "on a string" ... It's Tom Sawyer was "on a string." Dead rat. (On a rope - to turn over their heads was more convenient). She got it from someone of his friends for the right part of the lime Aunt Polly's fence ...
Regards, dabbler.
As aptly put one of the forum - "offim is terrible." Excuse me, Admins. Not anymore.

[EvgeniyMarkov]

Kustodiev or Kustodiev from Vekselberg , I do not know

but it looks like , and you are an amateur and you are right about the Guriev , Igor valances ,

apparently there were two ways of mounting : on the ropes and sewn to the sheet

Here pictures of authentic Ukrainian huts and valance for cot

can mount the type of bed changed <! - ~ 1 ~ ->

P.S. Even heard about the wedding valances that go with the dowry and handed down .

[K-Maler]

Сообщение от Guriev , Igor ; 2127391"

In my view , this picture is written exactly as good Kustodiev .

You have expressed very correct observation. This picture is well written, but it does not have those " strange things " that are so distinguished Kustodiev.
I showed this image of a good artist, which had no idea about this dispute, she immediately said "no, not there 's this , only it ... " ...
And believe Kustodiev in 1919 redrew its most precise way shtudiyny drawing a nude model in 1915 , I can not . Moreover , in the same 1915 he created one of the most attractive of their " beautiful ." Without looking into the studies. In all three cases, this song or the theme itself the image of his character has nothing to do with the usual pattern, I would say , on the contrary , he defiantly unusual, in that the whole point of these pictures .

[Дилетант]

Сообщение от EvgeniyMarkov; 2128371"

but it looks like , and you are an amateur and you are right about the Guriev , Igor valances ,

apparently there were two ways of mounting : on the ropes and sewn to the sheet

Here pictures of authentic Ukrainian huts and valance for cot

can mount the type of bed changed

 Dear EvgeniyMarkov!
At first glance it may seem that you only have clarified the question of the valances . Not very , quite frankly, a substantial household items. A humble , forgotten , and have not disturbing the public consciousness. But it is - at first glance .
In fact, you have managed to bring together the two oldest scientific schools , we can say - almost to reconcile the " two worlds - two Shapiro !" ( Why I like being quiet, shy and completely devoid of even the slightest ability to defend itself , be grateful you are sensitive ). Hurrah, comrades!

[K-Maler]

Сообщение от K-Maler; 2128491"

In all three cases, this song or the theme itself the image of his character has nothing to do with the usual pattern, I would say , on the contrary , he defiantly unusual, in that the whole point of these pictures .

I'll try to upload images from the book V.E.Lebedevoy 1966.
And the controversial picture.

[Pavel]

Сообщение от K-Maler

I'm trying to upload images from the book V.E.Lebedevoy 1966.
And the controversial picture .

It seems to me to do this was to begin. It's all clear , it can not be work Kustodiev. Kustodiev master of composition , and everything is shifted to the right that the figure was in the middle. Some folds in the curtains . Kustodiev there would be such a figure would be made ​​and changed . You are absolutely right . Pictures should always be compared side by side. It is not even , I said , the idea is as old as the world.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

It is known that BM Kustodiev often repeated their work and in a few years after writing the original, and even once - in one year.

"Beauty " in 1915 from the State Tretyakov Gallery, titled its 1918 version of the Tula MII and reduced version of the twice - a repetition of 1921 in the same TG .
"The Russian Venus" from 1925-26 and the TG - repeat variant of the same period of NNSAM (N- Novgorod).
" Merchant's Wife at Tea" in three versions I remember - 1920 h c. , 1923, Lower , 1925 , RM + in the same essay , " Merchant's Wife , tea -drinking " in 1918 (!) , The
We can recall a few of his " Carnival ," at least two versions of " Palm bargaining at the Spassky Gate in Red Square in Moscow," two versions of "Winter . Maslennichnoe festivities ," two - " Bathers ," two - " Portrait of Fyodor Chaliapin " (Russian and theater ), several versions of famous landscapes , etc.

[Wladzislaw]

Сообщение от dabbler

Do not think for work, find a magical book Yevgeny Ivanov Platonovich "Label Moscow word", and read it at least a chapter on trade in antique

As you say, blagodarstvuem <! - ~ 1 ~ ->.
Knizhentsiya amusing.
It is written and the person involved.

[Eriksson]

Сообщение от "Wladzislaw; 2129821 '

How do you say, blagodarstvuem.
Knizhentsiya curious

A wonderful book.
Often, re-read.
<! - ~ 1 ~ ->