Single feature ranking

[Самвел]

Сообщение от DSF

Our artrynku needed no rating, but a good reference book, which will include: Name of the artist, a brief biography, links to online resources where you can see his work, references to the results of the auction sales of his works ( if you have), galleries or dealers with whom he collaborated (if any), assignee (if any) and contact information. Reference should be in electronic form.

This guide was produced he r e 2005,2006,2007 i, but then apparently descended crisis, and they nevypustili else, or had other reasons. This is a directory of DAR on Russian art. http://www.gif.ru/afisha/dar-3/. He was in electronic form, but now he's gone. I have a 2007, got lost somewhere, must be found. In 2006 he was named directory http://www.newsru.com/cinema/22feb2006/dar_prices.html prices on Russian art from the avant-garde to the present day DAR. It swill produced an edition of five thousand copies, but now it does not find it.

[artcol]

Сообщение от Samvel

This guide was produced he r e 2005,2006,2007 i, but then apparently descended crisis, and they nevypustili else, or had other reasons. This is a directory of DAR on Russian art. http://www.gif.ru/afisha/dar-3/. He was in electronic form, but now he's gone. I, 2007, somewhere lost, we must find.

It was good that there were no misty ratings, and were given ishodny6 biography, collections, and auction sales.

[Самвел]

Сообщение от artcol

M-mmm ...
er ...
This ...
Well, you understand

 
It reminded me that's what.
Joseph Brodsky

Twenty-six years of continuous shaking,

digging in his pockets, judging Tasca,

Practice makes perfect build the Act eyes,

represent silent.
http://www.litera.ru/stixiya/authors...prishel-k.html

[artcol]

Сообщение от Samvel

This reminded me of this. Joseph Brodsky
Twenty-six years of continuous shaking,
digging in his pockets, judging Tasca,
Practice makes perfect build the Act eyes,
represent silent. http://www.litera.ru/stixiya/authors...prishel-k.html

In general - yes. But Brodsky was pressing humanitarian issues, and we are now in full swing dehumanization. Own-but, I know.

[K-Maler]

Сообщение от Olga Ozolina; 1316871"

because the books are sold, an indicator of the effectiveness and relevance of EXP.

I know of at least one collector who bought this rating (800 rubles). And reading the content, so indignant that threw him ...

Posted 20 minutes

Сообщение от fabosch

I am absolutely not going to defend the exp, I like it, frankly, not needed, but I do not understand, by and large, that so ganged up on him (except for Paul)? Well, people publish their opinions, well, scream about it at all angles, well, argue that they are the right and the rest - are fools. So what?

This is indeed an interesting question. Once upon a time I have led tours. And definitely was as follows: if three times (ie in different groups) have asked the same question, the text should be changed.
Here is something similar: many are unhappy. This may not be accidental. Moscow Union of Artists, not only refused to help, but deployed explained the motivation of failure (it was here somewhere unpublished).
Partly not true that applied a form of art criticism assessment, claiming even to the analysis, then it is clear from the materials themselves and the number of artists that such analysis was not. Many do not even know they were there and what criteria they are in one group or another. Many are incorrect ...

[Wladzislaw]

Сообщение от "Inquisitive

However, EXP is not approved as such is not one of the regulations applicable Russian laws.

What a rare beauty of delirium

[fabosch]

Сообщение от K-Maler

This is indeed an interesting question. Once upon a time I have led tours. And definitely was as follows: if three times (ie in different groups) have asked the same question, the text should be changed.
Here is something similar: many are unhappy. This may not be accidental. Moscow Union of Artists, not only refused to help, but deployed explained the motivation of failure (it was here somewhere unpublished).
Partly not true that applied a form of art criticism assessment, claiming even to the analysis, then it is clear from the materials themselves and the number of artists that such analysis was not. Many do not even know they were there and what criteria they are in one group or another. Many are incorrect ...

I totally agree that in respect of 80-90%(my number is arbitrary, but thinking that it is not far from the truth) unwitting participants in the rating is no real art history analysis could not be, if only by virtue of purely physical causes, it is more precisely on the assessment " without thinking. "
But it seems to me that the main stumbling block for many is unacceptable at the very idea that artists can build a portfolio and rank relative to each other. Everything else, including specific claims on the absurdity of many (in fact it's all subjective oche), in essence, a form of expression of the global dissent.
Yet, I regret that Olga Ozolin left forum. Forum has lost yet another paint. The more different voices, the better the chance to learn something new, to see the world in all its contradictions, complexity and depth, not as one-dimensional, even if harmonious picture

[Posav]

Сообщение от fabosch

unwitting participants in the rating is no real art history analysis could not be, if only by virtue of purely physical causes, it is more precisely on the assessment" without thinking ".

This rating in principle not possible. Eg Safronov for someone can be sucks, but on other indicators such as sales, he can rise to the occasion. Or, for example, that in terms of some "liberasticheskaya daub" to someone means nothing but "a famous gallery owner," it can evaluate the high prices, or someone to put up for auction to buy and "fix" the price, etc. ..

[Самвел]

Сообщение от K-Maler; 1321081"

bought this rating (800 rub.

I bought this book directly from them at the office, number 15 and worth it inexpensive, it is available to 350-360 rubles.

Сообщение от fabosch; 1321301"

And yet, I'm sorry that Olga Ozolin left the forum. Forum has lost yet another paint. The more different voices, the better the chance to learn something new, to see the world in all its contradictions, complexity and depth, not as one-dimensional, even if harmonious picture

 I do not quite understand her care, because of some resentment, almost frivolous, in our forum this happened, but almost all of stroyu.Forum this is very good, and go do not recommend, it turns out you have surrendered, who will be responsible not arise Questions? Whether we like it or not there is EXP, and it is used.

[Grigory]

Сообщение от "Olga Ozolina

I conclude that this site or no effective moderation, or a tone is normal.

Dear Olga!
At the forum there is no clock duty managers!
We have the right to rest on weekends, or not?
And the conclusions you have made hasty ...