Question?

[SergeiSK]

Сообщение от artcol

Smart criticism is not harmful to anyone.

Exactly!

Artist: I am an artist!

Work: And I think you're shit!

Daniel Harms

[Konstantin]

After all, this investment will hang on their wall.

Interestingly, in which specific topics on the mediocre painting forum said another?
Quite the contrary forum users differ critically. In this regard, I have often been criticized modern galleries, which they say you do not show - all blamed.

[Allena]

Question Samvel very correct, but the answers are here already heard, in my opinion, the wise: Of course, the forum - a place for discussion and their opinions should be able to express tactfully.

It seems to me, NEO slightly exaggerated, talking about life and health. In fact, he was right, but must be treated carefully, not only to artists, and generally to people, is not it?
 
Artist - is not only a state of mind, but a profession, with profession of public. Without the audience there is no artist. If you keep this in mind, the question of Samvel immediately gets the only possible answer.
By showing his work to the public, the author must be prepared for her reaction. Moreover, he must be ready not only to delight, indifference and criticism, but to frank rudeness, because the cultural level of the public is not uniform. And the artist's ability to perceive the public comments - this is, so to speak, professional skill. Praise, abuse, indifference, and criticism on the merits - the artist should be able to, so to speak, to work with all this.

[тандем]

Moreover, he must be ready not only to delight, indifference and criticism, but to frank rudeness, because the cultural level of the audience is heterogeneous. [/QUOTE]

[iside]

Сообщение от Samvel

... how to be on this forum, if you suddenly want to criticize, to say that well, so the artist himself, nothing special ... Write what you think or not. Remain silent, not to spoil the theme, even if it's a personal opinion?

As already noted by other participants, criticism should be tactful (both in principle and any communication with anyone whatsoever), something normal people know about it, but these two gentlemen are the artists, often reaching new heights of rudeness and coarseness in the consideration of other artists , quite innocently feel right, so to speak, they say, they are also artists.

The second point that the competent and constructive criticism, we must all still be a critic or art historian (expert), ie enough to be a certain number artbiznese years as an art dealer, artist or collector, etc. Although one another and do not interfere, but does not mean that one automatically follows the other. As in any case in any other profession units reach and tend to have universal knowledge.

Here you are Samvel, are employed in a certain type of art, where you have vast knowledge, but do you feel as comfortable when meeting with little-known artists, which tells the sometimes Liana, you can also easily and exactly to determine the weakness or strength of contemporary artists?

The meaning of my message is that if you just suddenly feel like , it is best to restrain myself, as they say, silence is gold. And if you have something to say deployed with examples and explanations, please.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Yes, it is.
so about my brother. And as I might, they are all-all understand ...

[Fed]

Сообщение от iside

The second point that a competent and constructive criticism, we must all still be a critic or art historian (expert), ie
enough to be in artbiznese unspecified number of years

And if not an engineer, then and ever-memorable "Lada-Kalina kritkovat should not con-repair ...
etc.

[Allena]

easily and accurately identify a weakness or strength of contemporary artists?

The meaning of my message is that if you just suddenly feel like it is better constrained, as they say, silence is gold. And if you have something to say deployed with examples and explanations, please. [/QUOTE]

So, praise be everything, but not to praise - only elected? I think that is unfair. The audience - it's what the audience that motley. And everyone has something to say, at least at the level of like /dislike, and everyone has the right to speak.

Added after 3 minutes
do do. Write what you think or net.Promolchat, not to spoil the theme, even if it's a personal opinion? [/QUOTE]
In my opinion, very easy to be: you have his own point of view and you want to share it with others - so what's the question?

[iside]

etc. [/QUOTE]

Let me say that art does not lie in the plane of the engineering or construction and repair work and can not be exact measurements. Perhaps a lifetime is not enough to understand in a single artist.
But if you are so close theme of repair, I can recall that there are specialists on laying ceramic tile, bedding for flooring, linoleum, carpeting, etc. No matter how rick is it that everything is simple and commonplace, only a very superficial glance.

I think that is unfair. The audience - it's what the audience that motley. And everyone has something to say, at least at the level of like /dislike, and everyone has the right to speak [/QUOTE]
 
I do not remember that I forbid to express their views on the level of like or dislike - everything is in order. Difficulties arise when one begins to explain why not like? Some might say, I'm no expert, I can not explain, just not mine. While others let in the explanation, had read somewhere in fits and starts and gives them a great expert reasoning (for example). It is ridiculous to talk about it, is found on every corner.

[Fed]

No matter how rick is it that everything is simple and commonplace, only a very superficial glance. [/QUOTE]
Yes, the name of the specialist Moldovan builders ...

Better yet, impose a monopoly on the assessment of only their guild.