The auction is over - long live auction! Your opinion?

[docent]

Well, first, let's start with the fact that the auction rules was a ban on bids below the launch. Moreover, it was not my initiative, and I noticed that the administration had not responded to such removal rates of the relevant communications, decided to participate in the auction.
 Secondly, for example, on 27 February this year under Operation Smile with the support of Christies and a number of banks and consulting firms was carried out charity (even online) auction in which the work Nesterova left to start for $ 5000, and then no one Bidding continued this work on the next day due to the fact that the price was four times less than the market. It does not talk about other jobs, sold for a reasonable price at the auction. In my opinion, the purpose of such auctions, collect as much money as quickly as possible, rather than support the ratings of sales galleries, and, if my bid was accepted, the auction would be collected for a quarter more money right now, not six months later, when there are willing to buy at such prices.
 And by the way, for some reason Buch, except mine, there was no bet? Where have you been?

[Маруся]

Сообщение от docent

that the administration had not responded to these bets

Apparently the administration was busy with something else ...

[Peter]

Admins warned it seems that it is necessary to adhere to launch a number of tsen.Po rates exactly.

[Самвел]

Сообщение от Maroussia

Apparently the administration was busy with something else.

I think she was taken by you, your comments, in the subject, where they were banned.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от docent

First, start with the fact that the auction rules was a ban on bids below the start.

This is the usual practice of any auction.
And as for online auctions and even more so.
Many prospective buyers are sent to auktsin their rates below the launch.
Sometimes these suggestions auctions react if the lots do not go during the auction, I understand that Star was overstated, and if there was no wish to start.
Normally.

[Черномашенцев Владимир]

Сообщение от docent

.... In my opinion, the purpose of such auctions, collect as much money as quickly as possible, rather than support the ratings of sales galleries, and, if my bid was accepted, the auction would be collected for a quarter more money right now, not six months later, when there are willing to buy at such prices.
 And by the way, for some reason Buch, except mine, there was no bet? Where were you?

Where were we? We hesitated so cheap to evaluate Buha - 20 thousand - were not ready to buy his pictures.

It is possible that other parties were on this account other arguments.

Or do you think you would be able to buy it at your price, if the underreporting rates below the starting price would be allowed at the auction? Do not be naive and do not take other fools. I would have this lot still got more for your 20. Charity Auction somehow does not involve lowering the already reasonable prices. Want to buy cheap - go to an ordinary auction, maybe you are lucky. Want to combine the purchase of paintings at normal prices and charity - not to lower prices.


In general, despite the good publicity, the auction did not go beyond the limits of shtetl. Unfortunately. However, it seems that the main shopping is only just beginning. I mean buying at a starting price, but not lower.

[docent]

Сообщение от Peter

Admins seems warned that it is necessary to adhere to launch a number tsen.Po rates accurately.

 Where, if not secret? Before you participate in the auction, I carefully read the rules. And on the purchase of pictures, just were not ready, then the question? I was ready-set rate.

[Черномашенцев Владимир]

Сообщение от docent

Where, if not secret? Before you participate in the auction, I carefully read the rules. And on the purchase of pictures, just were not ready, then the question? I was prepared, placed a bet.

There have been reports in the themes of the auction administrators, you can not underestimate the stakes. For example, here:
http://forum.artinvestment.ru/showthread.php?t=70651

However, it seems to me that this is a question not of the rules of the charity auction, but a question of conscience. With nothing there to discuss? You want to buy a 20 thousand rubles. Aron Bukh, but failed. And could not take place, as such rate would unambiguously bit. And not a fact that would have been a bit just me.

You can now sue the organizers of the auction.

PS

Each Lot has been specified details. These include the specified starting price. It is starting, and not estimate. I hope that the difference in these terms understood by all bidders, so if even a simple construction realizes this. START - he was in America, START. I translate into Russian: "beginning". Most bidders are aware the Russian language and did not perekoverkovat conditions in their favor. But I admit that someone could have first chance to make a mistake.

[Peter]

Сообщение от Maroussia

This was an auction to benefit victims of the terrorist act in Moscow, and not in favor of the poor collectors and dealers!

think I am, that somehow unseemly to buy the work in the "post-auction trade" below starta.Zdes thin ethical moment.Auktsion charity, heirs or artists confront a moral choice, thus rendering them davlenie.Tsel-get the job done cheaper to own vygode.Esli wanted to do a good deed, he had to buy at auction.

[docent]

Сообщение от Chernomashentsev Vladimir

There have been reports in the themes auction from administrators, you can not underestimate the stakes. For example, here:
http://forum.artinvestment.ru/showthread.php?t=70651

However, it seems to me that this is a question not of the rules of the charity auction, but a question of conscience. What is there nothing to discuss? You want to buy a 20 thousand rubles. Aron Bukh, but failed. And could not take place, as such rate would unambiguously bit. You can now sue the organizers of the auction.

 Please note that the fact that I was not able to buy Aron Buch on my (among other things, adopted) rate during the major trades (not posletorgovy period) more concerned with you than me.