Benoit? Bilibin? Or anyone else?

[Homoludens]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

Homoludens, but all the same , where such confidence that " is the work of some of the famous artists who are drawing sektakli " Russian Seasons " , if not Bilibin Benoit then "?
From this ?

Cyril, these sketches were kept by N. Kuznetsova Benoit , along with other sketches of costumes and sets for opera performances , in which she participated . Kuznetsova Benoit performed in such theaters in such entreprise that unknown artists , pardon the truism is not made ​​out . As for the " Russian Seasons" , I proceeded from the fact of how participation in the singer, as well as from the fact that the inscriptions on the sketches made ​​in French.

[Toinen]

Сообщение от Homoludens

witty and vain I do know how

I can see!
By the way, my sharpness can be attributed to the first picture, too.

[Homoludens]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

But - but - but , I wrote wrong, and here's how :

Comparing this figure with Bilibin . Do you understand? Of the two you mentioned , on the one ( Benois ) design more is similar .
 <! - ~ 1 ~ ->

I understand , Cyril. I did not want to distort your thought . Just you and I have mentioned Benoit in connection with watercolor sketches , and reasoning Jane Doe touched another one. That's it.

[Homoludens]

Сообщение от artcol

In general , it seems that it is one and the same character and costume. And it is not painted - probably the final version .

And you , artcol, there is no suggestion that the character and general features of the costume may be the same , and artists - different ? Could it be that it is pictures of different artists who participated in the design of the same show?

Added after 5 minutes

Сообщение от Kirill I see the writing on the Spanish [I

Avila[/I] - the name of the city , and En los campos - in the field .

Cyril, we both know what I meant addressed costumers (obviously French ) label - explication , pointing to the fact of the matter which should be made to various parts of the costume.

[artcol]

Сообщение от Homoludens

And you , artcol, there is no suggestion that the character and general features of the costume may be the same , and artists - different ? Could it be that it is pictures of different artists who participated in the design of the same Performances ?

The costume designer is usually one and the same here suspiciously painted hands .

[Homoludens]

Сообщение от artcol

Costume usually one and the same here suspiciously painted hands.

Indeed, on the hand, I also noticed.

Spread another two figures who have Kuznetsova M. Benoit stored with the previous ones.

Добавлено через 7 минут

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

And as I understand spanish

And for me , I confess , this phrase is "dark place ."

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

First, in Paris, M. Kuznetsova Benoit gave the evening of Spanish dance , where she danced to his own accompaniment on the castanets , but kastyumy to those dances she sewed on sketches by L. Bakst

I was not aware of this fact biography of Kuznetsova Benoit , but the suit on under my rasporyaenii sketches , you see, is unlikely to have to do a Spanish dance and castanet .

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

Second, it is after leaving the big stage was living in Barcelona, ​​led pedagogical work and there was a musical advisor to the local opera

True, but logic dictates that opera costumes for her then not designed .

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

Well, in the third , do not forget , she was married to Albert Benois, and here too

Yes, but none that I know of Alberts Benoit was not a theater artist , or am I wrong ?

[Homoludens]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

And as I understand spanish

And for me , I confess , this phrase is "dark place ."

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

First, in Paris, M. Kuznetsova Benoit gave the evening of Spanish dance , where she danced to his own accompaniment on the castanets , but kastyumy to those dances she sewed on sketches by L. Bakst

I was not aware of this fact biography of Kuznetsova Benoit , but the suit on at my disposal sketches , you see, is unlikely to have to do a Spanish dance and castanet .

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

Second, it is after leaving the big stage was living in Barcelona, ​​led pedagogical work and there was a musical advisor to the local opera

True, but logic dictates that opera costumes for her then not designed .

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

Well, in the third , do not forget , she was married to Albert Benois, and here too

Yes, but none that I know of Alberts Benoit was not a theater artist , or am I wrong ?

[U_Z]

Сообщение от Homoludens; 2566051 "

I'll be honest - I myself this figure strongly reminded Benoit , not only the manner of performance , but the handwriting. Especially because , frankly speaking , from relatives Benoit happens. I enclose , in fact, that figure , which is marked with a monogram .

In my opinion , a monogram and inscription in the picture are made by different people.

Added after 39 minutes

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

This monogram could put a signature of the owner.

Cyril, signature is very good.
zamorochennaya for the owner.
In reality, with signatures, notes holders, etc.
situation was much more prosaic.

[K-Maler]

Сообщение от Homoludens; 2566051 "

I enclose , in fact, that figure , which is marked with a monogram .

 
Both figures - costume sketch of the same character and are made with one hand, just a second - it looks like costume behind.
Where the second picture , like towers , similar to Bilibin , a careful drawing and he used a peculiar combination of colors ( stripes ) .

[U_Z]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzransky

There are many things in nature, Horatio,

Than are dreamed of in your philosophy.
(C)

Is yes.

"What did not you hear, can not see in the forest at night" <! - ~ 6 ~ ->.