Ukrainian lodge

[tivoli]

Do not deify Berkosa, it's different because Quay discusses and sign chestnoty M. Berkosa that I even forgot at the time about what was involved and provided that we are discussing Pohitonova. Berkos different is it an early one, typical and late talking on the terms Berkosa it too! Favre successor Vassilkovsky in his manner drew explanations S. Vassilkovsky, this schematic does not even lodge echoes the works Vassilkovsky (usually in his works the main character - the nature or public gatherings, market, going to the church, hunting) lodge cottages alike.

[Артём]

Сообщение от tivoli

Do not deify Berkosa, it's different because Quay discusses and sign chestnoty M. Berkosa that I even forgot at the time of what was involved

tivoli, you are a unique person, the topic shifted smoothly in philosophical conversation, but personally for you, (but of course, and for other members of the forum) Question! Incomplete work Crimean artists. Who is the author? In order! Read - Passed!

[tivoli]

I hasten to reassure you, I'm not an expert in such a narrow topic such as the Crimean artists, and do not undertake to comment on the fact that what I do not understand. Especially in the Crimean semi-finished products. But I would not if I would not trust his prof.intuitsii. Suppose, first on the left may Stolyarenko, the average may Zakharov.

Added after 3 minutes
But first on the left may be another similar Grigorieva

Сообщение от Artem

tivoli, you are a unique person, the topic shifted smoothly in philosophical conversation, but personally for you, (but of course, and for other members of the forum) Question! Incomplete work Crimean artists. Who is the author? In order! Read - Passed!

[Артём]

Average correct. I'm not nervous, you're just cool dealer, may I want to meet you?

Added after 16 minutes
Promised intar1 show sketches Pimonenko accept an apology did not, was busy exhibition Smirnova in Simferopol, two days after opening, but it's interesting, "Simon Semyonich" perhaps.

[Причал]

Сообщение от tivoli

Do not deify Berkosa, it's different because Quay discusses and sign chestnoty M. Berkosa that I even forgot at the time about what was involved and provided that we are discussing Pohitonova.

Berth personally (in person) - all completely indifferent to the artist Berkosu, but from the artists whose names were not indifferent to the subject (in person) only to Pimonenko.
And we are not discussing Berkosa and Vassilkovsky (alas ), as proposed in the topic-start work.

Berkos different is it an early one, typical and late

This is a common artistic skills, what are the necessary minimum in spite of any periods remain and the individual manner.

talk about the terms Berkosa it too!

No, say the terms Berkosa not too much. Do not forget that he was a teaching job, the public literary and artistic circle, and in general was for the province (about Moscow and St. Petersburg) "tricks of the capital" of Europe had seen.
Another thing that this picture is relevant to its terms except that in a second hand. That is, assume (assume! Not more) that it was written by someone who studied at Berkosa.
Similarly, with the same probability one can assume that he learned anywhere, much later .

Favre follower Vassilkovsky in his manner drew explanations S. Vassilkovsky, this schematic does not even lodge echoes the works Vassilkovsky (usually in his works the main character - the nature or public gatherings, market, going to the church, hunting) lodge lodge discord.

With such shabbiness of the plot and an abundance of lodges in Ukraine from this side to the problem are near useless in principle .
Only style, skills, abilities, ways of solving problems - nothing more. Given that these skills are not big enough to look useless among the masters, and the second to third quarters are too broad, so we dug up something there.
Why can say that the artist in a sense - a follower of Vassilkovsky (really since the owner is invariably attributed to the picture whose hunting or brush or at least somehow classify it)? Can only talk in terms of its artist saw, admired the love of Ukrainians, sunshine, technique. But, since this level of skill not possessed, and the reception is not unraveled, but clearly has the ability - something that's got what we got.
I in the picture, actually, just liked the overall color palette (not easy for such vysokostoyaschego sun and mid-summer) - the ratio of the sky green derevv and especially the wall color shaded cottages. Well solar blichki on all this.
 And here is the correct drawing (a sign of the academic school), I do not see here). What and conclude that it either was not (ie is already obtained through second hand and inconsistently), or it was already much higher , with the school when something happened that had happened.
The owner can choose a more pleasing him variant .
__________
under "academic school," I do not mean the Academy of Arts and did not even direct his studies at the academician, and the approach, consistent training, skills, painting the picture, etc.

[tivoli]

I have dealer since 1997 and very successful! Thank you! We probably just do not know.

Сообщение от Artem

Average properly. I'm not nervous, you just cool the dealer, maybe I want to meet you?

Added after 16 minutes
Promised intar1 show sketches Pimonenko accept an apology did not, was busy exhibition Smirnova in Simferopol, two days after opening, but it's interesting, "Simon Semenycha" perhaps.

Added after 5 minutes
My opinion is uniquely Berkos and that's that. All the above arguments - philosophy and no more. Smacks museum conversations naphthalene grandmothers.

[Причал]

Сообщение от tivoli

smacks museum conversations naphthalene grandmothers.

Thank you (quite sincerely).
There is no better compliment for a huckster, what I'm

[tivoli]

Respect !
I remember at the forum was the theme of traders or dealers? Question has remained rhetorical

Сообщение от Berth

Thank you (quite sincerely).
There is no better compliment for a huckster, what I'm

[Причал]

Сообщение от tivoli

I remember at the forum was the theme of traders or dealers? Question has remained rhetorical

Purely casuistic question.

The watershed between the trader and the dealer could be held to that man sitting on the implementation of the (then "huckster") or on an exclusive purchasing or sales (dealer). However, in pure form I finally stopped seeing those and others. We all have both in different proportions.

[uriart]

This work is just like your story to work Berkosa, and no more.
I would not write her that "attributed as" Berkos.
I spent a comparative analysis of the works Berkosa and concluded that there is not Berkos.
And someone wants, let him be as he wants!
Everyone is eligible.
And these stories can be found in the Ukrainian artists sea!
And not only in Ukrainian.