Yu Yu Clover (senior)? Your opinion

[uriart]

VYACHESLAV, It may even be a clover!

[Тютчев]

No doubt this is not clover. Can have different attitudes to creativity Julia Yulievicha, but he was an academician of the Imperial Academy of Arts, and there is taught as a professor. In other words, Clover was a professional and could not, even if it is wanted, to write such an amateurish thing. Do not forget also that Julius Yulievich was quite in demand during his life and his work paid substantial sums. He was truly a fashionable artist and popularity rivaled by Ivan Shishkin. These facts sufficient to eliminate this picture from the number of works that claim to its authorship.

[Marjana]

Сообщение от Tjutchev

Clover was a professional and could not, even if it is wanted, to write such an amateurish thing

I would like to know on what grounds you listed as the work of amateurish things? And sketches from nature in oil on paper - the most that neither is on the academic "chip". In the sketch pad of paper more fit, and easier to wear - not a bundle of stretchers from the canvas sketch could easily belong to brush Julia Yulievicha, the state desperately grasped, and the characteristic tune.

Do not forget also that Julius Yulievich was quite in demand during his life and his work paid substantial sums.

Orders lot and for some reason to paint in oils on a small piece of paper rather than on canvas. Then the picture: for clover empty, he podremuchee landscapes.

Do not forget, we are talking about a small sketch, written with energy and emotion from life, and not on the trends Easel Landscape Painted for sale in the shop on the canvas with solid subframe.

[ВЯЧЕСЛАВ]

Marjana, Here you got me beat. Respecting all opinions expressed above, I still wanted to say. In my paintings on canvas and on paper may not look the same even akademika.Ya seen many pictures of "western splint." Here the level above, and from fans who would write so halftones to "What a piece of paper." A professional will do this automatically, especially in the often wrote the story.

[Тютчев]

Сообщение от Marjana

I would like to know on what grounds you listed as the work of amateurish things? And sketches from nature in oil on paper - the most that neither is on the academic "chip". In the sketch pad of paper more fit, and easier to wear - not a bundle of stretchers from the canvas sketch could easily belong to brush Julia Yulievicha, the state desperately grasped, and the characteristic tune.

Do not forget, we are talking about a small sketch, written with energy and emotion from life, and not on the trends Easel Landscape Painted for sale in the shop on the canvas with solid subframe.

Symptom at dilentatizma only one - is the lack of professionalism.
       Mariana, if you carefully read my text, it could not find there arguments about the material, which the artist uses in his work. But if you hoitet know my opinion, it will tell you that you write at least lipstick on a mirror, but if you are incompetent and amateur, it immediately becomes clear.
      All counterfeits Klever just differ in that they all "keenly grasped" in the "typical tune. A Q-factor of the stretcher and the size generally a secondary matter. What is there to say something!!!: Rolleyes:

[ВЯЧЕСЛАВ]

Сообщение от Tiutchev

But if you hoitet know my opinion, it will tell you that you write at least lipstick on a mirror, but if you are incompetent and amateur, it immediately becomes clear.

As for me - " killer "argument. Type-"Who stain the walls in the toilet?" And the one who hand washing after using the toilet! "

[Тютчев]

Сообщение от VYACHESLAV

As for me - "killer" argument. Type-"Who stain the walls in the toilet?" And the one who hand washing after using the toilet! "

  What is the connection? I do not understand ...