Where is the line between plagiarism and influence of another artist

[Pavel]

Сообщение от художник Федотов

of Course this is more so, but I assume other exotic cases for potential justification of plagiarism...for Example, "plagiate", accidentally saw on the Internet, freely available, beautiful picture, small format(in pixels), thought it is a beautiful photo, signature small and barely visible, and took my picture...

Or: to him who brought the picture of the original, where it was not visible signature and asked me to make her a picture...Then not take her...the Artist, who is suspected of plagiarism, say, @1,@I blame, he came to me... [/B]

I don't like painting with photo. It kind of dull ,though the profane creates the impression of complexity, delanote and buy.
Plagiarism is a repetition of the work for commercial purposes-this is theft.
And creativity is the notion of influence, but it is for creativity.

[Peter]

Сообщение от iside

Good evening !

Got an interesting artist \\\\ sculptor in years already , interesting work , but ... it's all someone else's work. And he had periods , then an artist, a sculptor, is yet another artist . So many went through . Some work directly copy , he said that only " inspired ", but seen as a strong inspiration was what came out the same way. >

I wonder where the line between copying ( plagiarism)

The border runs for the money ... (oh, the money) . If he (the artist ) of copies , then put in his wall in his studio is one thing , if it makes a profit - border drugoe.Est sostoyaniya.Mane wrote his " Olympia ," Titian borrowed the composition for the " Venus Urbinskoy " and "Breakfast on the Grass" ( or "Bath ") at least Rafaelya.Tem he introduced the modern paintings (he ) characters , processed and written to svoemu.Nikto now they are not considered plagiarism ...

[iside]

Сообщение от Peter; 1797283"

Manet wrote to his " Olympia ," Titian borrowed the composition for the " Venus Urbinskoy " and "Breakfast on the Grass" ( or "Bath ") at least Rafaelya.Tem he introduced the modern paintings (he ) characters , processed and written on them now svoemu.Nikto plagiarism does not believe ...

Ok, let practical terms need to be able to determine the percentage of borrowed and interest added by the artist to realize his idea of ​​a force and that he settled down well in the style of famous artists who uses just his mercantile purposes. >

[fabosch]

Well, too appropriatsionizm of this opera. One of his most famous representatives - the notorious Koons.
In addition to the Internet in Russian is such an entertaining book - Ekaterina Andreeva (works in RM), "Postmodernism ," which appeared in the series "New Art History " published by ABC Classic in 2007
In general, the entire culture is based on postmodernizam plagiarism ( in the old sense of the term, now replaced by kotorok a series of glamorous new catchphrases )
But in general, agree with the " previous speakers ": a complicated, inefficient and unpredictable test (but it seems to me , the only accepted ) - this Court
With regard to all the other criteria can refer only to " gitikam ."
By the way noteworthy in this regard, numerous disassembly on " mimicry " brands. That's remarkable instances of plagiarism ...

[Кирилл Сызранский]

In connection with the case of the Belgian artist Luc Taymans/Luc Tuymans, recognized by the civil court of Antwerp guilty of plagiarism when creating a portrait of a Belgian politician Jean-Marie Dedecker problem over again became a subject of discussion.
Luc Tuymans now receives broad moral support from the public and artists, his defense has been even Queen Beatrix of the Netherlands.
The artist believes that the process against him was inspired by far-right politicians, against which Taymans constantly acted, in fact, a photo of one of them, used by the artist in his painting, and became an occasion for the court. However, the policy did not expect such a sharp reaction of the international community and is now accused of Tamasa that he mobilized against them all their international relations.
And the artist is not going to give up - he is preparing to appeal the decision of the court. According to experts, have taken place in recent accusations of plagiarism against Richard Prince, Shepard Fairey and Jeff Koons become a definite trend, already out of control, and if this goes on, the work of Warhol, created with the use of appropriation, soon can be considered illegitimate.

[I]Picture of Tamasa "Belgian politician" 2011 the court found a reproduction of a photo taken in 2010 by photo-reporter of the van Kathrein Gil@

[Гриф]

[QUOTE="iside;1795693"]Wonder where is the line between copying (plagiarism) style of one artist ( sculptor, installer) and the influence of which was provided on one drugogo@

So: copy style is NOT plait never.
Plagiarism is out of copyright, and the copyright extends only to the "subject" of creativity.
Style? Yes for God's sake! Write
"The way of writing of paintings using ink, characterized in that is used only white with a lead content of not less than 76 and not more than 79 percent."
All. The expert can't find (Malevich there is a similar, but let them prove procentowe!). The patent at hand. Style reserved.

And plagal - this refers to the fact that patents (technical) is not given. Vneshniy...
So, if your friend makes one-on-one - he's not plagiorchis. No.

(from the point of zrenija applicable law, of course... "obshestva" may be their opinion different from the opinion of lawyers)

[iside]

Wow, how nice that the subject is still living.

She believed herself (very interesting after all these years, as if not I wrote), revered others - thank you all.

Cyril Syzran Marusya as always for the excellent level of awareness about everything that happens.

I started the topic in 2011, and this was one situation, and now instagram is still more complicated. Yeah I wonder how things will develop further.

[iside]

By the way I forgot about the cases with singer Rihanna.

It is certainly not an artist, but modern singers are not just sing, they create their image and become like media artist. That does not prevent podvorovyvaet ideas from other Naousa, but no less talented colleagues.

1

Link 2