Can you believe this expertise?

[Прохожий]

Describe not want to - makes me sick, frankly. Here's the official website of the figures. There you can see the little articles so the transfer on the subject (though only a small part).

http://artvremya.ru/7355.html

It's clear that the journalists were taken to different provocation - how can that be, antique dealers, thieves, forgery, copied pictures ... Brain-no, think nothing! Only one publication (unfortunately, now I do not remember where) reading a thoughtful material, which was held a few cursory analysis of proposed materials and stated that in order to make these directories, without any initial information, to visually see the results of a huge number of auctions to examine tens of thousands of products, and work on it can only fairly large team of highly skilled professionals.
Built catalogs, of course, nor of any research methodology is not told, but there are serious doubts that the people who worked on the project did not know that and where to look ...
Whatever it was, but for many buyers of these little books have become a pretext in order to switch from classical Russian art to other areas, in particular the fact that the gallery exhibits the "Triumph" with the support of which was published catalog.

[eva777]

Сообщение от passers 164075

Whatever it was, but for many buyers of these little books have become a pretext in order to switch from classical Russian art to other areas, in particular the fact that the gallery exhibits the "Triumph" with the support which was published catalog.

Seems to be true, unfortunately. : (

[uriart]

pedestrian, not once heard from Moscow and from Petrograd that the purpose of publishing these directories to attract buyers of Western European art.
We can say that they coped with their task. Frightened many.
But everyone understands (artdilery) that the beginner is very easy to frighten.
And it all naooborot. Rather than expand the circle of buyers used Russian-wah, Russian is imposing Western.
Although the catalog a lot of really obvious alterations. There is published and controversial work, the authorship of which just under doubt, but not explicit falshaki.
How then should have been more delicately with catalogs!

[Sandro]

Сообщение от passers-164075

, these little books have become a pretext in order to switch from classical Russian art to other areas, in particular the fact that the gallery exhibits the "Triumph" with the support of which was published catalog.

One of our clients that we have collected a crazy collection of early twentieth century (the first names of Russian lives XX cc) just at this time we read a long and emotional lecture about the painting that this is not good for anything, nobody is buying it (especially from intelligent Americans, which should be equal to investment) and what to invest in contemporary art - video art, topical (bought a couple of AES S) ( "And I remove the large oil Kulik!"). He assured that all his friends at Rublevke stands, weighs only illuminates video art. Our arguments "video-art is always already passed stage", "Russian school of painting, the strongest to date", "an art-ever" were perceived as myamleniya "antique" (meaning old) gallerists.
Then he discovered that he had something much bought a Triumph.
But come now, and with it a crisis, and it turned out that he had "always said that we should invest in Russian Art", "Russian painting - the only thing you need in a crisis," but some of these Rastak Tr-F "me their city ... but do not need the money from the chi ..... do not pay."
That's the whole story about ruined the market

[Allena]

Сообщение от Sandro

That's the whole story about ruined the market

Well, who said that the antiquary life boring?!: D: D: D

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Sandro

we have collected a crazy collection of early twentieth century (the first names of Russian lives in nach.H1H)

19 th century? Beginning. 19-th? Who?

[Sandro]

Cyril Syzransky, my mistake - HHveka

[Прохожий]

uriart, so I'm not saying that in the catalog - inadequate examples. I'm not saying that antiques dealers - crystal honest people. I wonder how is it possible to collect "sources" for the alterations, not having the original information? Imagine, someone thinks that is on the hands perelitsovannuyu picture and need to find the source of which is a rather vague information: the approximate size (and suddenly crooks "Crop"?), About the plot and ... everything! And so, we must enumerate all fifty catalogs of auction houses, publishers refer to the buyout, or live on artprayse ... That is really even see such a huge amount of material that even the thought scared.
That's a thought that some people (your fingers will not show) with the necessary information, have attracted Blazhnov Fool on the role of publisher's provocative catalog, but the near official, who has long tried clamping down antiques market, because the circulation of black money is huge -- they issued a little book, collected on roasted avid zhurnalyug (the very eve of the next Antique Fair in CHA) and Hurray! By all means, in all the newspapers. Agree, only lazy did not write about the scandal with Preobrazhensky and about black catalogs.
But our so-nazyvaaemaya Confederation of antique and art dealers reacted - squeezed tiny tearful little letter in Kommersant. On the Rights of advertising - in a different way but could not. That little letter - because otherwise he gutless sob and call something impossible.
Is the people and escape any herstnyu buy.
I do not claim that my conclusions are correct, just a lot of questions and no answer ...

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Sandro

my mistake - HHveka

You are ... accurate over time. I've had enviousness, well, think-Shchedrin, Kiprensky, Ivanov, Venetsianov ...

[Sandro]

Сообщение от passers-164275

[On the other hand our so nazyvaaemaya Confederation of antique and art dealers reacted - squeezed the tiny tearful little letter in Kommersant. On the Rights of advertising - in a different way but could not. That little letter - because otherwise he gutless sob and call-you can not.

Respond quickly and cost only 2 and 4 of the catalog, because there is no dokazatelst questioned paintings. In so far as I know, in this regard are some trials.
And, in fact, already when all the initial passion and indignation had subsided, the majority simply does not react to these knizhenki. And those who sold pictures of 1 and 3 parts, which are converted to the West, forced to be responsible with money, they can only sympathize.

[color="# 666686"]Added after 2 minutes[/color]
Cyril Syzransky, yes, sorry, although some of Х1Х there too (Surikov, Repin (cool, two hands, one of whom - exactly like BB) and the usual set)