Whose job?

[polimpa84]

after 2 weeks of taking pictures, I will make a good photo and then continue the discussion


THANK YOU ALL!

[Алек Сандер]

Do not waste time discussing. Look for the author. This is always true, and guaranteed. Why do with someone to consult, if the author still alive? And more so, when there were cases of forgery, even bizarre cases? If the author does not confirm to you these pictures, all other views have no value. Well you know the name - that is enough. The author is alive, you can find it, and it can be addressed. What else is there to discuss? Well, unless you are pursuing some other goal.

[I-V]

Сообщение от Alek Sander; 1548213"

the author is always a joy to see my old paintings.

Сообщение от Alek Sander

Do not waste time discussing. Look for the author. This is always true, and guaranteed. Why do with someone to consult, if the author still alive? And more so, when there were cases of forgery, even bizarre cases? If the author does not confirm to you these pictures, all other views have no value. Well you know the name - that is enough. The author is alive, you can find it, and it can be addressed. What else is there to discuss? Well, unless you are pursuing some other goal.

Alec Sander, if it were that simple "In honesty Kalinina, I have no doubt, but just in case, look ->

http://forum.artinvestment.ru/showth...=765&highlight =%D0%BF%D0%BE%D0%B4%D0%BF%D0%B8%D1%81%D1%8C +%D0%B0 %D0%B2%D1%82%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%B0

[Алек Сандер]

Yes, thanks, I read about it. But what other option? Attributing a Silaeva? Maybe. Although I think that the force will soon send to the author. But all the forum will not say anything else except "I (almost) 100 percent sure that it Kalinin. So I just said it. It was obvious. But who will give papers on authorship? I? Igor Sasha? Thus, again we return to Silaev. And if Valeri will give atributatsiyu, pictures surrender to the auction, and there - see the story on the first link?

Since I was such a strange example, better access to the author, wait, what he says.

Assume there will be a piece of data laid out the pictures. Its all be considered. Someone may say: yes, it Kalinin. Someone may say: well, yes, certainly Kalinin. It would give the owner? These words have been uttered. Next, what? John Preston, too, was absolutely sure of the authorship, and look how it turned.

Well, or there is a way out: keep painting until such time as their creator will go into another world, much farther to confirm.

There were mixed two completely different issues. First, the original question was (quote): whose job? Answer: probably Kalinin. And so began a discussion on the second question: whether the original picture? Were given some interesting facts. And now at this moment, I believe, go to the third question: how to testify authorship documented? I gave my recommendation. Next business owner - to follow them or not.

[I-V]

Alec Sander, really, I see that you and better than I know all this.
Of course, if the author is still alive - all questions to him, there not going anywhere.
Only wish the distinguished polimpa84 good luck.

[redbor]

Reproductions or copies of works of Vyacheslav Kalinin.
Photos should be better

Work known, Index: Tea drinking and who will cut cock? Seems

[I-V]

Сообщение от redbor; 1548363]reproduction[/QUOTE]


[QUOTE="redbor; 1548363

photo should be better

Correctly, would not prevent <!--~ 10 "->

[redbor]

Yes, in principle, not necessarily.

That and pictures found

[Алек Сандер]

And then everything curiouser and curiouser. Reproduction? But read the first message: "oil on canvas." Moreover, about 20-30 years, according to the store ". Hence, either copy and then copying Kalinina, it seems, is on a grand scale, or the originals, but do not know the previous owner that has the catalog works? Very lyubopytstvenno.

[I-V]

Сообщение от Alek Sander; 1548491"

Then all curiouser and curiouser. Reproduction? But read the first message: "oil on canvas." Moreover, about 20-30 years, according to the store ". Hence, either copy and then copying Kalinina, it seems, is on a grand scale, or the originals, but do not know the previous owner that has the catalog works? Very lyubopytstvenno.

Alec Sander, I think we are all just hoping for the best
But I'm afraid we deal with this "terrible" phenomenon:

Our artist using special filters will process the original and creates the illusion of brush strokes. After drawing the image onto the canvas, this effect is enhanced by varnish and gel texture. Now safely enclose the photograph in a frame and amaze your guests!