Constantine Azadovsky: Russian Museum v. Benoit

[Vladimir]

Everything happens. Just keep in mind that the experts may be mistaken as one and the other way. That is sometimes true things wrong "zaparyvayutsya" on examination. This is how some people forget. It is believed that once the conclusion is negative, then this sentence. A similar case was discussed here: http://forum.artinvestment.ru/showth...=625&highlight =%D0%94%D0%B5%D0%BD%D0%B8%D1%81 +%D0%9B%D1 %83%D0%BA%D0%B0%D1%88%D0%B8%D0%BD
When a mistake in the opposite direction in the examination of Yavlensky.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

[Евгений]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzranskiy

Perhaps there are situations arose?

I think this problem:

"... You can, of course ... to conduct examination in full, but it will take from half to two months (remember that the examination in the Russian Museum was carried out over two or three days )..."

as possible for three days to make an expert opinion on the two works? conduct a study: art criticism, style, Chemical Engineering ekspetizu, X-ray, and-R, UV, etc. understand clearly the experts .. hurry ..

watercolor by Alexander Benois, who had allegedly been investigated in infrared and ultraviolet, X-ray fluorescence analysis was subjected to, etc., returned to me intact, ie zakonvertirovannoy (under glass in a frame).
Fourthly, it was unclear how the experts identified the age of paper (it comes sudeykinskoy gouaches). Such studies are extremely complex and require special skills.

[uriart]

Everything is much easier.

[тандем]

Сообщение от Vladimir

All happens. Just keep in mind that the experts may be mistaken as one and the other way.

An interesting formulation of the question, but if one considers that the expertise of the monopoly and the results can not be challenged in court, it turns out - You justify unprofessional and bias of a handful of vozomnimshih about themselves that they are holier than the Pope and chaste wife Tsezarya.Nu yes, for them, because the state itself - the chief rogue and mzdoimets.A against the wind .... not recommended - splash varnished boots!

[мистер-у]

This article reminds me of the hysterical cry of a man who is motivated denied in peer opinion on two watercolors and Benoit Sudeykina.Prichem he writes the truth from the nachala.Ekspertiza-kontsultatsiya any job in the timing is 17700 rubles, multiplied by two will 35400.Otkuda 50000 -70,000 rubles??
Refusal to sign a group of experts, including experts, technologists and graphics, approved E.N.Petrovoy.Evgeniya N. Petrov, deputy director for Science rabote.Kto timing of members of the forum knows her personally, met and kontsultirovalsya? Probably very few.
Evgeniya Petrova, deputy director of the Russian Museum of Science, Ph.D., a very competent critic of Russian grafiki.Ee works are European and world recognition.
In 2005, by decision of the Scientific Council of the State Russian Museum, edited by Evgenia Petrova, a catalog of "Drawing and Watercolours in Russian Culture, the first half of the 19th century, and" Drawings and Watercolours in Russia ", the second half of the 19th century.
What is the meaning of staff GRM "fell" two some watercolors that price??
Now information is for those who do not znae Peter, RM, and museum staff.
In the courtyard is a small parish, built during the time of Alexander 3.Let 7-8 before the museum staff for their funds restored the parish, was consecrated him, and at lunchtime walk molitsya.Po big holidays have to visit my friend, is moleben.Bolshaya part of the museum staff deeply religious lyudi.Svetlana V. Rimsky-Korsakov, a deeply religious man.
Why people are taking my money and the amounts of bribes? Why all the dealers and owners of items that receive negative responses blamed for all the experts? I do not understand this approach.
I do not know how other expertized organizaziyah, but we are not prityato.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Mr-y

Examination-kontsultatsiya any job in the timing is 17700 rubles, multiplied by two will 35400.Otkuda 50000-70000 rubles ???

You should read carefully this passage about the money, I think.

You can, of course, the argument goes, examine fully, but it will take from half to two months (remember that the examination in the Russian Museum was carried out over two or three days), and the cost of the work will be from 50 to 70 rubles.

Added after 2 minutes

Сообщение от Mr-y

In the courtyard is a small parish, built in the days of Alexander 3.Let 7-8 before the museum staff for their funds restored the parish, was consecrated him, and at lunchtime walk molitsya.Po big holidays have to visit my friend, is moleben.Bolshaya part of the museum staff are deeply religious people.

Ha-ha-ha-ha, now in almost every CTI has a chapel and even a temple.

[мистер-у]

Do you personally know at least one employee GRM?

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Mr-y

What's the staff GRM "fell" two some watercolors that price??

That's strange, but the fact is, and intelligible to his explanation, no. And after this article, Konstantin Azadovsky for examination "deeply religious people" of the timing, someone will look askance.
No, St. Petersburg dealers and owners of the St. Petersburg Antique shops will also everyat all in the most honest and unbiased examination of the Russian, it's clear ...

[мистер-у]

You can always spend an additional examination in any other expertized instantsii.Na complex, serious about the work of one-examination kontsultatsii enough.