Mikhalkov vs Art

[Nara]

Interestingly, after the Cannes festival is something about him did not hear.
Do I understand that about Mikhalkov any good, or nothing?
Or did I miss something? ..

[Allena]

Сообщение от Nara

Do I understand that on Mikhalkov any good, or nothing?
Or did I miss something? ..

Nothing is missed, Nara! In my view, there simply have said everything that can be said. Very good in the past director, has now become a manager. And, both of our movies should be, only one person is always bad things are combined. Either will make a film, or will not make a film. In my opinion, he has at all times have their own position, but that's always different ...

[Nara]

Сообщение от Allena

I do not miss, Nara! In my view, there simply have said everything that can be said.

I mean not here on the forum, but generally in the media. That he was always in the TV and in newspapers and on the Internet, and suddenly ischezzzz.

[Allena]

Сообщение от Nara

ischezzzz

Naturally "Who wants to comment on their own failure in Cannes! No comments

[NATA NOVA]

Сообщение от Allena

In my opinion, he has at all times have their own position, but that's always different ...

There are entire family's dynasty, which under any circumstances, have their (vital) position, which is always different, (depending on the appropriate necessary) ..
Here's a mystery of nature! Here's to you and Darwin! (Learn how to survive, kids!)

[Eriksson]

Brilliant article title Bogomolov "Do not Canna"!
And intelligent text. http://grani.ru/opinion/m.178348.html

My personal opinion on why his old movies because we all like.
Mikhalkov - very bad artist. In a sense - an artist, but anger remains.
And in "Native" and "Unfinished Piece ..." beautiful talented actors embody their evil and, yes, accurate vision of the world and human nature.
Everything Else - golimaya conjuncture. "Slave of Love" - "revolyusennoe" movie zavulirovannoe by love and costume drama. "At home among strangers ..." - The same thing and hidden under a western. About "12", "55" and "Hitchhiking" say nothing.
"Five Evenings" must successfully remarkable dramaturgy, film with Mastroianni - a set of nested dolls.
The main secret Mikhalkov - gather in front of the camera of the best actors and use their potential to its fullest. They themselves will do everything. Plus - always - the best operator. And as a director he is, of course, a strong professional, but - alas - not a genius.
This is the issue - a genius and villainy. Inconsistent, however, spend all baldness "higher-ups ...

[Vladimir]

Сообщение от Eriksson

"At home among strangers ..." - The same thing and hidden under a western.

I do not agree that the movie was opportunistic. What a propaganda promise it does not feel - just for entourage. A scene where Shakurov tunes fighters before the campaign - just a masterpiece. You can revise endlessly. Horse on dybah ... vile snake bites ... defend to the last drop of our worker-peasant red blood ....

[Buscador]

Сообщение от Eriksson

The main secret Mikhalkov - gather in front of the camera of the best actors and use their potential to its fullest. They themselves will do everything. Plus - always - the best operator. And as a director he is, of course, a strong professional, but - alas - not a genius.

I do not know what a bad artist. I'm used to evaluate only works created by the artist. Those works of N. Mikhalkov, which I listed, I like and think they are very strong ... In terms of game actors, the operator and, of course, directed by. And in the fact that he "gathered in front of camera best actors," then, as you know, film - the art of directing. Are so many examples where collected strong actors and a wonderful script, and film - alas ...

Added after 9 minutes

Сообщение от Eriksson

"Slave of Love" - "revolyusennoe" movie, zavulirovannoe by love and costume drama.

Do not perceive it as a "revolutionary" film. On the meager plot material created a beautiful film with wonderful acting job ...

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Buscador

The meager plot material

"Subject material" there just did not "tight".
Filmed in "white" Crimea runaway film cinematographers from the Reds. Among them, red operator secretly films the "atrocities" of white that is fun, knowing now what it was, and how. And so on + love line.
This is a "meager plot material"?
Actors there, yes, play nice ... Much props, tinsel, children are running around in white hats with the ladies ...
But the film itself works as a whole I do not see.
Yes, Nightingale-exalted in their makeup: well, here-Nakhapetov, stems funny voice said Basilashvili, Kalyagin, "terrible" spy Captain Fedotov (K. Grigoryev), music, then, behold, and the final: "Gentlemen, you beasts, Gentlemen!
For 76-year - super, now - funny ...

Added after 25 minutes

Сообщение от Buscador

's too many examples where to build a strong script and fine actors, and film - alas ...

If the examples are many, and bring a couple of such failures from your point of view movies. Just wondering ...

[Allena]

Сообщение от Buscador

I do not know what a bad artist.

I too do not see any harm. It is my deep conviction that evil can not be the driving force behind creation of anything there. A bad artist - is generally nonsense. Or evil, or artist (creator, the creator - no matter what he creates in this case).