Sotheby's Russian auctions is in New York

[ВЯЧЕСЛАВ]

Сообщение от Krylov

Dear Vyacheslav, categoriality your judgments assumes that you are a great connoisseur of art" independent ". So I do not know whether you mean something opinion OM Barkovsky, whose article "The Society of Independent Artists in Odessa," published in the book "Odessa Parisian" art criticism and the conclusion of examination, this deputy director for scientific work OHM VA Abramov, whose name is contained in the Bibliography of the same book "Odessa Parisians".

 I can assure you that the level of my knowledge I have a very long time and successfully get around without consultation Abramova, getting more interesting art than before you.
It seems as clear - on the basis of what had been expressed these views in an expert opinion? After all, guided by the same than the Barkovskaya and Abramov, having before my eyes this watercolor. I can not imagine the arguments that could lead art in this particular case.

[Krylov]

Dear Slava, I have no reason to doubt your knowledge. Too bad you did not ask to share them in the book "Odessa Parisians."

[gans]

Сообщение от Krylov

I do not know whether you mean something opinion OM Barkovsky, whose article "The Society of Independent Artists in Odessa," published in the book "Odessa Parisians"

Here the work of Michael Gershenfelda "Breton Landscape" 1908., From the book "Odessa Parisians."

[Krylov]

Dear gans, thank you for your attention. You were given one (unsigned) from the three works mentioned in the book "Odessa Parisians." The other two signed Michel Herschenfeld. Handwriting and signature on the Watercolor identical with archival autobiography (biography, as then written), written with his own artist 03/11/1924, the nature studies showing barges was apparently made in the province of Brittany in France. In 1917 in the exhibition catalog featured the work of the Society of Independent M Gershenfelda № 30 "Brittany, Concarneau small fishing town. In the II-nd exhibition of paintings, sketches and drawings of the Society of Fine Arts № 59 "Pont Aven.Bretan." The exhibition of paintings 1916. № 15 "Brittany", № 17 "Brittany etude.

[gans]

Сообщение от Krylov

you were given one (unsigned) of the three works mentioned in the book "Odessa Parisians. The other two signed Michel Herschenfeld.

1. Street in PONT AVEN. Brittany. 1908.

2. Port movers. 1914.

[Krylov]

Dear gans, perhaps you would be interested in this cover of the almanac.

[тандем]

Сообщение от Krylov

nature studies showing barges was obviously performed in the province of Brittany in France.

If you do not make it more difficult, say, the word obviously in the above sentence is set to is quite clear, no doubt or may appear..

[Krylov]

Dear TANDEM, everything that I wrote about nature studies, names of works and their catalog numbers, I rewrote the conclusion of the examination of art criticism. Leave this alone I could not, would not have enough imagination. However, the town of Concarneau was a place of pilgrimage for artists, so I think that your favorite word should be interpreted as approval. But this is only my opinion and nothing more.
Ladies and gentlemen, I have a big request. Because I have something happened to the smart car and I can not open the cover of the almanac, executed MK Gershenfeldom, please, do you see a wonderful sea landscape with a boat?

[тандем]

In such a situation (lack of provenance?), The opinion of the owner atributiruemoy work does not have any znacheniya.Mnenie makes the expert and is here every word of their weight in gold (not literally, of course <!--~ a ~-->) Any duality in the definitions are not in the set-off. Experienced experts critics know it and avoid dvoyakochitaemyh passages. After all, he and an expert in order to thoroughly study the subject, and throwing all the fluctuations to give a clear answer YES or None. if there are variations, as well write about it.
What really easier to write "It is clear that nature studies showing barges was completed in ...." This, as they say in Odessa, "are two big differences" in order that it was written.
Deliberately so it was written or not, but all other arguments and illustrations appear far-ushi.Takoe my opinion.

[Krylov]

Dear TANDEM you, I think, man concrete and decisive. I respect these! Totally agree with you that the view owner does not matter, especially because it was said: ... my opinion and nothing more. With respect to your opinion, which of course is far outweighed by the opinions of experts who are engaged in independent than a dozen years, which will be acknowledged in the same book, "Odessa Parisians" The works of artists from the collection of modernist James Change. Museum of Russian Art im.Marii and Mikhail Tsetlin, Ramat-Gan. Because of your opinion, of course, must be considered the only true. Totally agree with you.