I. Brodsky, help with examination of the picture

[Вивьен]

Brodsky studied at the Higher Art School Academy of Arts of five years ( 1902-1907 ). That is, if this work and Brodsky, then he wrote it in twenty years of age at the beginning of their training . Maybe this version that the work was not signed, but the owner knew for sure that the work of Brodsky and signed , it was easier to sell.

[Elek]

Сообщение от Vivian

owner knew for sure that the work of Brodsky and signed to make it easier to sell .

Sold abroad as " nerazborchovo signed " with the consequent cost. But was it worth to bother ? What I am concerned - and not fabricated gained confidence in the auction.
I still had no reason to distrust the seller.

[Вивьен]

Сообщение от Elek

sell abroad as "nerazborchovo signed" with the consequent cost.

But can credit for this auction is not?

[Elek]

Сообщение от Vivian

But can credit for this auction is not?

I would like to leave with him.
>

Добавлено через 20 минут
Go on back side and then that went "complete."
This x /m, mounted on cardboard.
Age (I) can not be doubted.


Maybe it's something to add to the discussion?

[Elek]

Go on back side and then that went "complete."
This x /m, mounted on cardboard.
Age (I) can not be doubted.


Maybe it's something to add to the discussion?

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Vivian

Maybe this version that the work was not signed, but the owner knew for sure that the work of Brodsky and signed, it was easier to sell.

"I knew for sure?"

This is not Brodsky, there was nothing to Brodsky, who had studied in 1903 in Repin's studio, in my opinion.

Added after 1 minutes

Сообщение от Elek

I would like to leave with him.
>

like this, "Brodsky."
>

[Игорь Гурьев]

Yes, it does not seem to Brodsky.


But the last two pictures - it's just amateurish entertainment of a gentleman, in my opinion.

[Elek]

Advise whether someone (preferably in Europe), who could take a closer look? I would like to know if the signature is forged, whether contemporary or our contemporary Brodsky?

Is there already available methods for determining the age of paint (in the sense , paid the money, " Spectrometer " checked and given conclusion ?)

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Igor Guryev ; 1804103"

Yes, it does not seem to Brodsky .

You can imagine frantovatogo Odessan and stylish , 20 -year-old young man, a student Vysschego Art School of Painting, Sculpture and Architecture at the Imperial Academy of Fine Arts in St. Petersburg, after studying this to 6 years in the Odessa Art School in Ladyzhenskaya , Kostandi and Iorini , pischuschego though academic study on fanerke so even with the two sides?
 >

He's not a man , " dye-works " of Yaroslavl province Poshehonsky County. >

[Вивьен]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzran

let pischuschego and academic study, but fanerke so even with the two sides?

I can not.
You should have seen on any "rags," wrote a palm-sized Kostandi their studies from St. Petersburg.
In this opinion, I in no way is not to say that the work in the subject painted by Brodsky.