Authenticity??

[Маркович]

Hello!
Advice on the authenticity of this picture? Is Aivazovsky?

[Toinen]

Сообщение от "Markovic; 2081041 '

Is Aivazovsky?

Of course not!

[Маркович]

Сообщение от Toinen

Of course not!

Ponyatno.Spasibo.

[Eriksson]

Bang-bang cool!
<! - ~ 7 ~ ->

[uriart]

Eriksson, more of a "bunch"!
<! - ~ 7 ~ ->

[Тихая Сапа]

Markovic, wait to bury in Feodosia gallery was something very similar.
This site is an expert on Aivazovsky, ask him in person (perhaps he had not seen the theme), and I look for it, it reminded me so

[Николай Левенко]

Сообщение от Markovic ; 2081041"

Prompt for the authenticity of this picture ? Is Aivazovsky ?

Unfortunately, just today I saw your question. I can confidently say that this Aivazovsky . Technique, as can be seen from the photo, it is likely - ink, pen . In favor of Aivazovsky by the following arguments: as a Ayvazovkogo (see samples ), a light touch painted waves, which even in the form of repeated waves of the other drawings wizard compare the pattern of your sailboat to sailing vessels in the views will samples , they are absolutely identical ; figures people originally written - without leaving the pen on paper , just so they portrayed Ivan Konstantinovich, and so they have drawn in your case , the handwriting at the bottom right of the figure , no doubt the handwriting Aivazovsky , often in graphic artist did the work on the label image , refines the picture action, or his place (in this case - a volley ) is not in doubt and autograph Aivazovsky (see the autograph in the samples ).

[Kaffsky]

Markovic, with all due respect to the opinions of al:

Сообщение от Nicholas Levenko

Unfortunately, just today I saw your question. I can confidently say that this Aivazovsky. Technique, as can be seen from the photo, it is likely - ink, pen. In favor of Aivazovsky by the following arguments: as a Ayvazovkogo (see samples), a light touch painted waves, which even in the form of repeated waves of the other drawings wizard compare the pattern of your sailboat to sailing vessels in the views will samples, they are absolutely identical; figures people originally written - without leaving the pen on paper, just so they portrayed Ivan Konstantinovich, and so they have drawn in your case, the handwriting at the bottom right of the figure, no doubt the handwriting Aivazovsky, often in graphic artist did the work on the label image, refines the picture action, or his place (in this case - a volley) is not in doubt and autograph Aivazovsky (see the autograph in the samples).

I think membership Aivazovsky image titled "Zalp" - highly questionable ... <! - ~ 9 ~ ->

All there seems to be as described by Nicholas Levenko ...

But not so ...

Many differences in handwriting, in comparison with the reference of your work, and, main, in the construction of tracks ...

The very same ship a salvo does not hold water ...

He can not be a reactive rocket ... <! - ~ 10 ->

[Toinen]

Сообщение от Kaffsky

I think membership Aivazovsky image titled "Zalp" - highly questionable

I join the opinion of colleagues.

[Николай Левенко]

Сообщение от Kaffsky; 2086901"

The very same ship's volley does not hold water ...

I can not agree that a volley marked by all his colleagues just as unrealistic, in fact, far from being perfect, I do not like it too. But we must bear in mind that for the 23-year-old novice artists, in 1839, took part in the amphibious operation, an attempt to convey the dynamics of the initial flight of the nucleus. In this figure the search. This picture Aivazovsky - is a secondary, supporting detail, and depended on the quality of the picture, he will be used in the work, or will remain in the folder for the pictures. Or Road album artist and improviser.

Сообщение от Kaffsky; 2086901"

A lot of differences in handwriting, in comparison with the reference of your work, and most importantly, in the construction of tracks

In his work, Aivazovsky did not use the classical scheme of writing a cloth, because almost did not write sketches, which is formed by composition. The Master said: "The story is composed in my mind as the story of the poet's poem, making a sketch on a piece of paper, I begin to work ..." Because in this figure is characteristic of paintings by Aivazovsky songs we do not see is just a sketch, a song by the artist most often built directly on the canvas.