The most influential

[zarajara]

Top 50 most influential figures in Russian art magazine's "ArtChronika"
Here's the list.
I'd love to read comments. members of the forum. What are your opinions?
Rating TOP-50

1. Roman Abramovich and Daria Zhukova
2. Olga Sviblova
3. Vasily Tsereteli
4. Joseph Backstein
5. Gelman
6. Catherine Tar
7. Shalva Breus
8. Boris Groys
9. Stella Kesayeva
10. Vladimir Ovcharenko
11. Victor Misiano
12. Andrew Monastery
13. Sofia Trotsenko
14. Emilia and Ilya Kabakov
15. Michael Piotrowski
16. The group "War"
17. Alexander Brodsky
18. Helen Selina
19. Teresa Mavika
20. Andrei Erofeev
21. Ekaterina and Vladimir Semenikhin
22. (New) Dmitry Ozerkov
23. (New) Andrew Kuzkin
24. (New) Alice Prudnikov
25. Irina Lebedeva
26. (New) Anton Belov
27. Michael Mindlin
28. Marina Loshak
29. (New) Viktor Pivovarov
30. Aidan Salakhova
31. (New) Anna Gore
32. (New) Boris Mikhailov
33. (New) Ilya Tsentsiper
34. Oleg Kulik
35. Irina Antonova
36. (New) Yuri Albert
37. (New) Peter Weibel
38. (New) Gherman Titov
39. (New) Valentin Dyakonov
40. Viktor Pinchuk
41. Arseny Zhilyaev
42. (New) Vladimir Gusev
43. (New) Leonid Bazhanov
44. (New) Alina Saprykin
45. Paul Khoroshilov
46. Paul Pepperstein
47. (New) group Recycle
48. Alexander Avdeev
49. Alexander Mamut
50. "AES + F"

[Konstantin]

Сообщение от zarajara

I'd love to read the commentary

I would put the question more broadly - if needed at all such a list?

[Селена]

Сообщение от Konstantin

I would put the question more broadly - is necessary if such a list at all?

Or ... who needs such a list?

Top Ten - only art managers, top twenty have not changed since last year ...

[Konstantin]

Сообщение от Selena

Or ... who needs such a list?

Well, yes and I have - who needs this list except for those who got it?

I have an answer to this question, but I will not until his voice.

[zarajara]

Сообщение от Konstantin

Well, yes and I have - who needs this list except for those who got it ?
I have an answer to this question, but I will not until his voice .

I think this is a trend of our time, from the TV ratings "very , very ," to all kinds of tops. If the criteria do not , you can create lists of up to infinity.
We can reformulate the question: " what is the criterion in the ranking of the most influential ?"
 What do you mean " most influential "? Affect the market? the fashion in art , develop a new style ? Have an authoritative opinion? attract the largest number of viewers' attention ?........
By the way, is about the " need - not needed ", I think that is still needed. Too great a flow of information, any rating one way or another helps navigate the robot, especially those on the periphery of the flow.
Any rating - the subject of analysis , and different , economic , artistic, psychological , etc.
The views expressed by you and Selena - this is just an example of psychological analysis : who are seeking and what the drafters of the rating , that is - the identity and motive >

[artcol]

Сообщение от Konstantin

Well, yes and I have - who needs this list except for those who got it?

I have an answer to this question, but I will not until his voice.

In anticipation ...

[Konstantin]

Сообщение от Konstantin; 1876071"

I have an answer to this question, but I will not until his voice .

Сообщение от artcol; 1876891"

Waiting for ...

Yes, the answer to the surface, then a deep drop is not worth it.
This must be the very first magazine . And another pair of top three people on the list ( there are fans find themselves in the rankings and magazine wants them to be on good terms ). All . Sense for the business in this no .
And I am not in terms of critics now writing - a normal attempt to create newsworthy.

[artcol]

Сообщение от Konstantin

Yes, the answer to the surface, then a deep drop is not worth it.
This must be the very first magazine . And another pair of top three people on the list ( there are fans find themselves in the rankings and magazine wants them to be on good terms ). All . Sense for the business in this no .
And I am not in terms of critics now writing - a normal attempt to create an episode .

 > I agree, but hoped that there will be more than the original version.

How to make such ratings. Written questionnaire and sent to the list of experts. Eats , but that the expert has given time and completed this questionnaire must be with him in some respects ( usually). Therefore, proponents of the survey ( magazine ), and experts are well aware of each other , so to speak narrow circle of people. And then a simple quantification , and woo a la , the rating is ready , you can print > As you can see - nothing complicated, and suitable material , and even aroused the interest of Zara .

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от artcol; 1877001"

How to compile such rankings.

HOW rankings
C 2007 "ArtChronika 'annual rankings of the most influential figures in the art world. This year the voting has been invited 16 experts, among whom were the art critics, journalists, collectors, gallery owners and museum employees. The experts also suggested that 16 of its candidates for listing. In addition, each expert chose the 50 most important people in his opinion and made their ratings. After the editors received the votes of all the experts, was produced by the scoring. Depending on the location assigned to the candidate who is charged from one to fifty points, their sum and the winners were revealed. The figure next to the name of the finalist ranking indicates the position he now holds, the number in parentheses - like the place he occupied in the rankings last year.
EXPERT RATING BOARD
Constantine Agunovich, magazine columnist "Bill"
Faina Balakhovskiy, art critic and editor of Time Out
Victor Bondarenko, collector, businessman, publisher, philanthropist
John Varoli, to the end of 2010, art agency Bloomberg News and the newspaper The Art Newspaper, from 2011 - Art mediakonsultant
Gelman, director of the Perm Museum of Modern Art
Volker Diehl, the owner of the gallery Galerie Volker Diehl, Berlin /Moskau
Dyakonov Valentine, correspondent of the newspaper "Kommersant"
Olga Kabanova, the correspondent of the cultural department of the newspaper "Vedomosti"
Irina Kulik, a columnist for the "Culture", Lecturer at the Institute of Contemporary Art and the Moscow Art Theatre School
Igor Markin, collector, founder of the Museum of Contemporary Art Art4.ru
Anna Mongait, a leading television channel "Rain"
Milena Orlova, the chief editor of "ArtChronika"
Elena Selina, the director and curator of the XL Gallery
Vladimir Semenikhin, collector, founder of the Cultural Foundation "Ekaterina"
Olesya Turkin, art critic, curator, researcher at the Department of Contemporary Art at the State Russian Museum
Alexander Shatalov, journalist, television presenter and producer of documentary films

__________________

[artcol]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzran

HOW rankings
C 2007 "ArtChronika 'annual rankings of the most influential figures in the art world. This year the voting has been invited 16 experts, among whom were the art critics, journalists, collectors, gallery owners and museum employees. The experts also suggested that 16 of its candidates for listing. In addition, each expert chose the 50 most important people in his opinion and made their ratings. After the editors received the votes of all the experts, was produced by the scoring. Depending on the location assigned to the candidate who is charged from one to fifty points, their sum and the winners were revealed. The figure next to the name of the finalist ranking indicates the position he now holds, the number in parentheses - like the place he occupied in the rankings last year.
EXPERT RATING BOARD
Constantine Agunovich, magazine columnist "Bill"
Faina Balakhovskiy, art critic and editor of Time Out
Victor Bondarenko, collector, businessman, publisher, philanthropist
John Varoli, to the end of 2010, art agency Bloomberg News and the newspaper The Art Newspaper, from 2011 - Art mediakonsultant
Gelman, director of the Perm Museum of Modern Art
Volker Diehl, the owner of the gallery Galerie Volker Diehl, Berlin /Moskau
Dyakonov Valentine, correspondent of the newspaper "Kommersant"
Olga Kabanova, the correspondent of the cultural department of the newspaper "Vedomosti"
Irina Kulik, a columnist for the "Culture", Lecturer at the Institute of Contemporary Art and the Moscow Art Theatre School
Igor Markin, collector, founder of the Museum of Contemporary Art Art4.ru
Anna Mongait, a leading television channel "Rain"
Milena Orlova, the chief editor of "ArtChronika"
Elena Selina, the director and curator of the XL Gallery
Vladimir Semenikhin, collector, founder of the Cultural Foundation "Ekaterina"
Olesya Turkin, art critic, curator, researcher at the Department of Contemporary Art at the State Russian Museum
Alexander Shatalov, journalist, television presenter and producer of documentary films

__________________

Something different from what I wrote?