[DSF]

Сообщение от fabosch

From this thesis, I somehow implicitly read in what you think is the abstraction of being on pole, in color and realistic painting - on the pole shape. This is so?

So.

Сообщение от fabosch

According to Bernson, Florentine School vsegdv tended to develop problems drawing, perspective, composition at the expense of development ... Kloristicheskie coloristic delights were the prerogative of the Venetian school.

Yes, you are right in art history is a point of view. It is not entirely true, in my view pure practice. Giotto - pure colorist, Taddeo Gaddi - surprisingly harmonious, and Masaccio, Botticelli, Lippi, Fra Angelico ... I still can not forget those of harmony, where everything is subordinated to bloom. Yes, they worked on a drawing, perspective, composition. But all of this - not at the expense of color, and it is amazing! How they managed to combine everything into a coherent whole? It is very difficult. Venetian school more inclined to form, whatever the historians wrote.

Сообщение от fabosch

Probably too extreme point of priority of color should be called, for example, Klein, Rothko or his famous blue.

Let me explain. Black square - is one tsvetoforma. One simple shape - square, and one color - black (conventionally black, it is rather dark gray). Just as, for example, the red dot - it will also be a simple tsvetoforma. Rothko, still, uses several tsvetoform on canvas. Therefore, his work, I can not say very much at the point, although very close to it. But Klein - yes, I agree.

About abstract art written many texts. This is due to the fact that people still want to understand and realize what they are seeing. But what can you write about a certain combination of color spots? Only one - the mystic, the unconscious, the deep intention, etc. Initially, the artists are not very pleasant, but he threw good "bone", they were told - you're visionaries, mediums, the researchers of the new realities, innovators and geniuses. And the artists included in this game. Since then, as Renoir said: ".. Artists see themselves as exceptional beings, imagine that, putting the blue paint instead of black, they change the world. " Time will pass, will come new generation of artists, will replace the blue paint in black and once again "turn the world."

Сообщение от iside

... I can get a professional opinion, how much good work and whether they were work of genius or a scribble, from someone who decided to become an artist?

Thank you for your kind words, dear iside! "I write here often, because I have really very little free time.
Responding to your question is - can not. Painting, based on a harmony of color, very difficult, almost impossible to evaluate the monitor, we can not see the "quality" of the original color and its scale. You need to look original. On the internet you can more or less to evaluate only the form of: proportions, angles, volumes, etc. All this is a totally objective criteria. With color - more difficult.