N /A France 18vek landscape. Prompt
 

Hello!

Tell me the price

1.
N /A

2.
Oil on wood

3.
Size 32.8 x 50, 8

4.
Time to create 2nd half of the 18th century

5.
No signature

6.
Condition: talus, chipped corner

7.
Expert opinion - GRC Grabar.
Exp.
Makhotina, Kiseleva.


More details in the expert opinion

Gentlemen,

Something I probably misunderstood.

Why "Grabar" issued on the conclusion of the notorious H?

At the request of the customer?

But are they simply "to put money," such-Makar ...

We had to return the work after oral consultation ...

The owner wanted to confirm (not oral) time writing, painting and country of origin.

You are absolutely right , + still had a little hope to establish the author's work . In the old picture of the expert opinion was determined to holland art school , but one of the buyers, and probably a good connoisseur said , and suggested that this is France. He also said that the first expert report ( nobody Antiqua . Salon 90 ) at this picture - complete nonsense < - ~ 2 ~ ->

Well, Grabar as if by n /x is not given custody?
:)

Shakes titanic work of experts :)

They initially refused to do the work and was told that they could not guarantee the result. But none menie , I think they did a good job , perelapatili bunch of stuff . 2 months doing the examination.

" every whim for your money !"
(C)

And in my uneducated opinion - Makhotina completely fulfilled money paid by the client . Set the time to create and school, to reliably determine the specific nature of the picture of the beautiful original and its replica staging , etc, etc, etc.
In general, it seems to me A.Mahotina lady literate, well-educated , passionate, sincere , able to think logically, not lazy ("you gather the materials themselves , and that I have no time to hang around libraries - Business in bulk" ), not Tolstoguzov , and by age - not hidebound *. It is a pity that she quit. (Michael Matusovsky with Matthew Blanter just cried away in the left wings , the right word ...)
* ESLICHE : this - not advertising :)

I just see how they 're going to ... consultation and Kiseleva blinded the monitor sitting up after midnight , lapatila stuff ... sneezing from the dust in the archives ...

Dear all, I ask you to give a price!



I think that the discussion of employee Grabar deserves a separate topic on the forum.
Regards :D

As you storge .
So all the scare of his theme, do not hear anything .
Participants of the forum are not robots at the information desk - goes freestyle conversation, which may ( mozhet! ) display the answer to your question.

I wonder how the result of this work - expert opinion - will help it to sell and make a profit.
For me, so throw out one thousand dollars down the drain.

want to know the price , give it up for auction.
In Europe, only high quality and fine copies of old masters , made n /x , are 1000 - 5000 evrov .
If the quality is not very decorative and extremely low cost of such work is rarely higher than 1000 euros.
Ebee on your job without expert opinion and with a hint of authorship famous Frenchman, would have brought 800 - 1000 euros.
In the event that two buyers would strongly believed in the authorship of the famous Frenchman, 1000-3000 evrov .
With the price of an expert report would have been no higher than 600 - 800 euros.

Although there are exceptions , such as a master copy made ​​from another great master ordered Flemish king.
Then the balance of the other.

Auction average hand , say in Germany, would put this work on sale from the start 800 - 1000 euros , although now everyone is trying to start as low as possible .

Price in Russia , in this situation , do not tell .
I'll be at the Kunsthalle next time , I'll try to find and photograph the work , it will be interesting to compare the good photos.

Added after 6 minutes
as experience shows , hope and imagination , the great engine of commerce .
In this case, the expert opinion is killing the hopes and fantasies in the bud.

Thank you of course, but the picture was bought in the 90s for the 6 so ye
Show me where to buy a painting of the same performance level 250 years ago for 800-1000 Euros, I think I would take a number ve :;