National Idea

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от bykinist; 2367841"

But the choice should be.

In Jerusalem, I regularly cross the Prime Minister of Israel. Just walk down the same street at the same time when he goes to work. Sometimes I'm getting ahead of it. While the government convoy, shaking the air a bunch of sirens, wade through the morning traffic jam, I'm much more quickly overcome the street on foot.
To block the street for half an hour to travel bosses Israelis somehow does not occur. And rides on an old local prime (about ten years) Volvo with scratched sides. Long, I think, an armored car, but in Russia, even the most run-down governor disdained to ride on such a mangy old. Boys from a nearby kindergarten to raise a laugh! Three or four cars of also not distinguished either new nor breed.

I saw leaves his Elysee Palace, French President. Nobody covers the streets of Marina, with which he begins his journey. And other streets do not overlap. Well, the train flashing lights flashing, sirens howling. Well, who can take the right to miss them all. But the level of privelegirovannosti presidential limousine is comparable to conventional ambulance. And the train is the same scanty as the Israeli prime minister.
Another thing in Moscow. Kutuzovsky cover half hour before the passage of the president. Tens of thousands of machines before lunch then stand in traffic jams that paralyze sometimes almost a quarter of the city. Hundreds of thousands of Muscovites are late for work.
With the same pump drives and Ukrainian President Yanukovych. Hundreds of cops Kiev on dozens of machines cover all the streets and avenues along the way boss.
And how goes on your Grozny Kadyrov - words can not convey. It is better to look to the web. There on this subject a lot of rollers. The motorcade of hundreds of half-Maybach, Maserati, Bentley, Porsche, Lexus, Mercy ... King makes his entourage. And for Ramzan Akhmatovich dragged around a Codlea hangers ... To help him develop the Russian budget. That he, therefore, not ruptured alone.
In general, one can see, France and Israel - the poor countries of the third world. People are starving and curses his share. But in Russia and Ukraine ...
And as with the superpower Chechnya in wealth can not compete even Arabian sheikhs.

From the Internet.

[artcol]

Сообщение от K-Maler

Curious collapse ideas from conceptualist " vocation ".

They just do according to concepts of Derrida and Heidegger prefer hang gliding in the depths of the surface.

[color="#666686 " ]Added after 19 minutes[/color]

Сообщение от bykinist

Erring even in that " national idea" can be taken into the public debate , read, for all to ridicule. Moreover, any yard drunkard with Platonic- Glazunovskaja manners - according to organizers - may all of us (! ) To formulate a national idea , and even through a sculpture , painting or - God forbid! - Installation, even if it's in the best traditions of Kabakov .

In general , the idea is correct, except that personally I draw conclusions from it strictly opposite : just a mockery of (and I am sure that it is this mode in this action ) and the ability to show all the archaic and rudimentary and , most importantly , schizophrenic (sic!), all this talking- politicians homespun kitchen spill - style " join hands ... friends ."

[fabosch]

Something similar recently conducted Artguide only free.
Interviewed artists aktualschikov . And on the basis of the survey was compiled Top 10 artists and Top 10 works that best expresses the Russian mentality . The results often amusing, predictable part

artists
1. Kazimir Malevich - 71%
2. Ilya Kabakov - 46%
3. Andrei Rublev - 36%
4. Kuzma Petrov- Vodkin - 32%
5. Alexander Deineka - 29%
6. Ilya Repin - 27%
7-8. Isaac Levitan - 24%
7-8. Vasily Surikov - 24%
9-10. Vasily Perov - 22%
9-10. Vladimir Tatlin - 22%

Artworks
1. Kazimir Malevich. Black Square - 51%
2. Andrei Rublev. Trinity - 29%
3. Vladimir Tatlin. International Tower III - 20%
4. Kuzma Petrov- Vodkin. Bathing the Red Horse - 19%
5. Ilya Kabakov. A man flown away into space from his apartment - 17%
6. Oleg Kulik. Shares of the man- dog - 15%
7-8. Vera Mukhina. Worker and Collective Farm Girl - 14%
7-8. Vasily Surikov. Boyar Morozova - 14%
9. Group "War". Dick in the thrall of the FSB - 12%
10-11. Victor Vasnetsov. Heroes - 10%
10-11. Anatoly Osmolovsky. Bread - 10%

all the material here
http://www.artguide.ru/ru/articles/18/204

[Fed]

What might be the national idea in the divided country?
Yakut: "Empire were born, achieved greatness and left. May soon be gone, and Russia. We lived together for a long time - it was forced, but in many ways useful for Saha alliance. Was! Empire attractive when it can give its satellites is that they can not achieve by themselves or they can, but too slowly.

Yes, the Russian colonization of Yakutia was the catalyst of the Sakha people. We have technology, management, education, health, justice, and further develop and improve it all, being part of the empire. We were worthy subjects, our work strengthens the empire, we fought for it, bowels of our earth replenish the imperial treasury.
What can it offer us now? It is economically and ideologically bankrupt, it is on the verge of collapse and disintegration.

We have managed to preserve their national identity. Most Yakuts know and remember their ancestors to the tenth generation. The same can be said about the Tatars, Buryats, Bashkirs, Kalmyks, Chechens, Russian ... How many can boast of at least knowledge - who and what he was great-grandfather?

Does it retain the imperial enclosure or crumble - not in the Kremlin decide. It is necessary to understand all of the titular peoples of the republics of the Russian Federation today. And be ready for that day to come. "

But the national idea is still there, physically survive the oil end of the 20's and 30's., Creating core areas of financial survival, and treatment.
Physical survival, even with affordable housing DC power, with the complete end infrastructure, local food, not imported.
Financial survival, such as the idea is embodied Sterligov with gold treatment.

But anyone interested in the future survival of this extinction ...
So a national idea can be simplified to save yourself as who can. Not counting, "and suddenly everything will be fine."
Once it was in your area? Although if you already 59 can not worry.

[Konstantin]

Сообщение от Fed; 2367971"

physical survival , even with affordable housing DC power, with the complete end infrastructure, local food , not imported .

Horror-horror - horror ...
And the end of the world December 21 forgotten ?
Forgotten. And I would not worry about the oil.
But seriously - it certainly laugh and only. Every man who can ...
But however if you like the idea of ​​a national capital city Kiev residents - a flag in hand.
And I would have participated in the search of the idea itself. But to start interesting to discuss - and is it necessary?

[Магнолия]

Сообщение от Fed

How can there be a national idea in the divided country?

The idea of ​​common thinking.
The idea apo_kali_psi_sa - Beautiful Exhortation - as deciphered an ancient word.
The beauty of thought - the engine of life.
Creative people - the vanguard of the crowd, society, society.

[artcol]

Сообщение от Konstantin

horror - horror-horror ...
And the end of the world December 21 forgotten ?
Forgotten. And I would not worry about the oil.
But seriously - it certainly laugh and only. Every man who can ...
But however if you like the idea of ​​a national capital city Kiev residents - a flag in hand.
And I would have participated in the search of the idea itself. But for the beginning is interesting to consider - and it need ?

Clearly , the Fed is inspired to such posts looking out the window . ChTto see - on and sing.

Added after 1 minute

Сообщение от Magnolia

The idea of common thinking .

The idea of common thinking - this is a national idea. I agree. I would also add " your own ", thus adding a bit of subjectivity , personaliti in the national idea.

[Магнолия]

Сообщение от artcol

personaliti a national idea

Without it?
She also national!

[artcol]

Сообщение от Magnolia

How do without it?
She also national!

And who is the subject of this idea?

[Магнолия]

Сообщение от artcol

And who is the subject of this idea?

 

Anyone who thinks for everyone.

For example, J. (not modest, but with a sense of humor!)