Help assess icon

[Любознательный]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzranskiy

What is it "unreasonable"?


Everything is normal, I think.
Anyway, as you please ...

I have not given you reason to doubt my lack of knowledge in the understanding of the term "icon", but really, the more so in the understanding of Russian icon painting. Under such circumstances, I believe Your post is not ethical.
With all due respect to your opinion, I would not let anybody and will not allow you to treat with him.
I do not want.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от inquisitive

I have not given you reason to doubt my lack of knowledge in the understanding of the term" Icon "

But I do not doubt the Lord is with you ...

Сообщение от inquisitive

With all due respect to your opinion, I would not let anybody and will not let you so.
I do not want.

Do not allow to continue, as you wish ...
I have something before that?
"Treat a "...
Yes, I did not appeal to you, go to bed, once drank Liska.

[reriks]

initially I did not ask the icon or not a requested evaluation! And the icon or not there may be a long debate but wilt come to a consensus. But on the 2-3tysyach-let the painting such as Picasso, too, not because ICON shtosh it now price 2 3tysyachi ......?

[Евгений]

Сообщение от reriks

and asked for evaluation

Dear here is the site of wood carvings http://www.derevo-art.ru/work.php?fo..._home=&for_man = & for_event = & price1 = & price2 = & keyword = & f_interier = & work_type = 0 & lines = & work_material = & current_page =#start0
More than 230 artists and hundreds of different gadgets (including carved icons), prices, dimensions, interesting articles, etc.
Read it, you will understand ..

[Любознательный]

Сообщение от reriks

paintings such as Picasso, too, not so ICONS shtosh it now price of 2-3tysyachi ......?

Here in this forum is the result of a man can already tell Picasso from the icon.
 Rerikis, if would you propose to evaluate the cypress carved hinged (15 valves), and even age 16, the price would not be in the thousands and not in rubles.
Look, yes obryaschite!

[Мимопроходил]

"In the art scholarship icons commonly referred to as images in the framework of Eastern Christian tradition on a solid surface (mainly at limes board covered with gesso, then there is alabaster, diluted with liquid glue) and equipped with special inscriptions and signs.
From the theological and religious studies in terms of icons are also mosaic, paintings and sculptures in any artistic way, if they eat the fruit set by the Seventh Ecumenical Council reverence. "

Gentlemen, you are just in different positions in the perception of the term icon, do not break the copies.

[Любознательный]

[QUOTE=Cyril Syzranskiy;1086692] In light of the church and the prayer will be the image of the essence of the icon, not worse than printing, in my opinion. If the icon is a religious position, not with art criticism, for example.

For the consecration of the image in the Orthodox Church must respect the canons for writing ICONS.
 I have a book (title torn) edition of 1848, of which cite the preface.
Judging by the content, it is - a tutorial on writing icons.

[SAH]

curious, could you put a normal scan of the book, upside agree not convenient to read.

[Любознательный]

SAH,
Thank you for a fair comment - unable to see not noticed.

[Pecheneg]

Сообщение от Cyril Syzranskiy

Message from Cyril Syzran



Igor Guriev, but in Russia Madonna and Child with the icon can be?

Ukraine, the middle 19 th century. board, tempera.