Irina Zhdanko?

[Карамель]

Good day, dear friends! Please help to clarify the attribution and evaluation of the work of Irina Alexandrovna of Zhdanko - sketch for one of its Samarkand work ( the work itself "Old Uzbek woman" is in the directory Kiev, 2001)
There are a few of her sketches too 1960s and figure Kliment Redko (?) in bad condition.

tempera on cardboard, size 21 22 see
Thanks in advance.

[Карамель]

well the one that got away..and I waited all night did not sleep))

another work 28 cm × 17 cm ( seems to be "the Wife of a Potter"). In General Irina Zhdanko tenderly loved themes of the East (as well as L. Kramarenko, her husband), I think it has been extremely...

[redbor]

Сообщение от Карамель

another job 28 cm × 17 cm ( seems to be "the Wife of a Potter")

I can't judge about the authorship, the Imperial Idaniko is "the wife of a Potter" may your sketch?
That directory is almost 5 times more and in my opinion nicer.

[Карамель]

redbor, thank you very much ...Yes, I also wrote that the sketches for her work ( unpublished directories)...so "Old Uzbek" dimensions 52 cm to 44 cm in the directory

[redbor]

Yes, of course, it sketches the Imperial Idaniko. Caramel, and you that doubt the author?
And concerning the sale of these sketches, I think the prospects are not optimistic

[Dogel]

Сообщение от redbor

you that doubt the author?

of course .

[Карамель]

Сообщение от redbor

Yes, of course, it sketches the Imperial Idaniko. Caramel, and you that doubt the author?
And concerning the sale of these sketches, I think the prospects are not optimistic

purpose to sell I do not, there is a goal to begin to understand something...after the exhibition "the Way of the East" I'm a little hooked on the theme of Central Asia, and will not be cured) proposed several sketches and I could not resist...
http://forum.artinvestment.ru/showthread.php?t=253451

redbor, Dogel.. you have me confused) you at least a little to explain such different opinions? I will diligently to write

[Dogel]

Сообщение от Карамель

I will diligently to write

Recording is not necessary, you need to carefully watch, compare...

Your "Sketches", derived from the works of the artist, and not Vice versa.
cardboard and signature on the reverse side of 1960 can not be attributed.
In the network see a byline that is different from You.

Where did You get them ?

[redbor]

Сообщение от Карамель

redbor, Dogel.. you have me confused) you at least a little to explain such different opinions? I will diligently record

It is quite possible that Mr Dogel rights: some artist sang reduced copies of the works of the Imperial Zhdanko.
It would be good to understand what are the goals for these small copies ?

[Карамель]

Сообщение от Dogel

In the network see a byline that is different from You.

Dear Dogel, thank you very much for your help, please give links to networking with signatures of the author, I have seen signatures only on living and directories...also try to compare.

Сообщение от Dogel

cardboard and signature on the reverse side of 1960 can not be attributed.

I think the signature on the front side, on the back the inscription, Yes?