Prosecution photographer Umida Akhmedova in libel and insult of the Uzbek people "

[Сима]

Сообщение от Tjutchev

This is much more interesting movie!

Tjutchev, I, of course, the movies are not a specialist. What would they not want to do, in my opinion, turned out a parody of the French "new wave". There was a famous film "Paris vu par" - six short stories - Godard, Chabrol, etc. So there all the time different pairs of breakfast and swear. Or a guy with a prostitute at supper (they really do not swear). This easy absurdets existential being, some stories, however, ends sadly. Funny obtained from the French - what movies do, all the Kalashnikov obtained.

[Тютчев]

Сообщение от dedulya37

It is reluctant to get into in 1937!

How do you understand! In Haiti in the 37-m devils that happened!

"President Vincent introduced in 1935 a new constitution allows the president the right to make a list of candidates to the Chamber of Deputies, Senate to appoint and dismiss any member of parliament. He ruled with dictatorial methods and forced the parliament to ask his consent to the Head of State's re-election for another term. Complicate relations with the neighboring Dominican Republic, where in 1937 there were massive killings of seasonal workers Haitians. War was averted when the Dominican dictator Trujillo has agreed to pay compensation of 500 thousand dollars "

[Кирилл Сызранский]

Сообщение от Sima

all the Kalashnikov obtained.

Yeah ... Kalashnikov ...

[NATA NOVA]

Comrades fludisty, but what about support talented artist, whose face criminal penalties for the absurd charges of defamation and vilification of the people?
Such an impression. that each of its case only gnaws, (instead of "in the root of the mature and human moral support)
Or is it really believes ovineniya reasonable?
Show me this man (specifically and personally)

[Tamila]

Сообщение от Eriksson

"However, the logic of" insulting and slandering "I understand. This logic is based on deeply archaic notion of any image as an image of the festival, parade and colorful yielding abundance. Depict me? Take pictures?" So I фотографируй in a smart coat and skullcap in a new, not sweaty, half-naked, with a hoe in his hand. This is slander. Insults. And right would be me alone. People. Do you know how it smells?

Beautifully's not what happens in reality, not what we see every day, and what did not happen, but it would be good to make it. However, the aesthetics of socialist realism was all built on this simple enough principle.
Lev Rubinstein

After all, this is true. In Soviet times the photos were supposed to be happy, to show the prosperity of the country, the successes and achievements. These were the foundations of Socialist Realism. But if the photographer went to the side and shot what was actually a real picture, it turned out that he "opposed" the principles of a realistic reflection of life. That is the paradox of socialist realism.

Photos Umida Akhmedova beautiful and lyrical. The reason for "insulting people" I do not see. Would be desirable that all ended well for the photographer, but prosecutors were able to overcome the archaic (socialist) idea of the photo essay.
Photo report - it is true, to show everything as it really is. Of course, disagree, the author's opinion can not be completely objective, present the author's vision of the situation, but if the case Umida Akhmedova photo series about life in Uzbekistan does not look like slander, and I think, does not cause a sense of insult.

[NATA NOVA]

Сообщение от Tjutchev

can be explained that it was subversive in my posts? What are you not like? I'd like to understand what you call "hysterical"? What are my words and thoughts have troubled you?


Everyone will be very instructive to read about it. For that would not repeat my crime. Yes, and I do not quite understand why they were deleted ...

Dear Tjutchev!
I managed to see the wonderful collection of Soviet-era photos. They have a separate topic. "Soviet documentary," for example ...
I understand that this theme in defense Umida (criminal charges, you understand? "In a totalitarian country archaic man alive .. .. What's most important archives to lay or extend a helping hand?)

[Konstantin]

to lend a helping hand

And how to stretch something?
There is already correctly pointed out - sign up whom? Nicknames? And then what? Where to send the letter? In Uzbekistan?
Theoretically, we can come up with posters of the embassy, but it is under our law on meetings fraught with ...

[Posav]

Сообщение от NATA NOVA

Comrades fludisty, but what about support talented artist,

One thing blah blah under aplodismetny associates, and the other specifically to stand on the road by the powerful of this world with a particular risk of damage to yourself.

[Konstantin]

We here in the admin burst when the wind blows on the water, fearing that any discussion about politics or the former Soviet Union ends squabble. This has in part, and I even venture to support it.

I also love seen old photos

[NATA NOVA]

Сообщение от Konstantin

How to stretch something?
There is already correctly pointed out - sign up whom? Nicknames? And then what? Where to send the letter? In Uzbekistan?
Theoretically, we can come up with posters of the embassy, but it is under our laws rallies fraught ...

Leave a Comment in Support of (defense) Umida Akhmetova here:
http://www.ferghana.ru/comments.php?id=6411