Opinions by Vasnetsov.

[Кирилл Сызранский]

redbor, all
Thank you.

[redbor]

But still, as previously written, look, please: the icon, which was sold at auction, as the work of T. Vasnetsovovoy

and previously unknown sketch (93h45. h.m), after examination found the work of V. Vasnetsov.
 
And probably a sketch, which can have a Mikhailovich much chance of a good author?

[Михалыч]

Max (Santa Claus) are seen for a long time > Tea in the same city we live >

Сообщение от redbor

... and probably a sketch, which have Mikhailovich ..

I do not consider the subject under discussion sketch.

Добавлено через 25 минут

Сообщение от redbor

... Five years ago a similar icon (not this one), attributed as the work of the artist's daughter, Tatiana, was sold at auction (quite well).

I've heard about it, hoping that someone will say about this thread.

Portrait of T. Vasnetsov.

Добавлено через 1 минуту
redbor, in your signature to the file specified "T. Nesterova"?

[Михалыч]

Сообщение от redbor

About five years ago ... looks like an icon (not this one), attributed as the work of the artist's daughter, Tatiana, was sold at auction (quite well).

I heard about it, hoping that someone will say about this thread.

Portrait T.Vasnetsovoy.

[Михалыч]

redbor, in your signature to the file specified "T.Nesterova"?

[redbor]

Сообщение от Mihalich

I do not think the sketch of the subject.

And for good reason.
I then folded pazlik, from the fact that it was here.

See 1 and third recognition sketches Vasnetsov, 4th - his daughter, Tatiana,
 
and then your "friend of his."

Добавлено через 3 минуты

Сообщение от Mihalich

redbor, in your signature to the file specified "T. Nesterova"?

Sorry, wrong.
(I thought about a similar sketch, M. Nesterova, who in his time, bought the family Prahova) Somewhere was a description of the auction, where the icon T. Vasnetsov sold.
If interested, I can find.

[redbor]

Сообщение от Mikhalych

redbor, in your signature to the file specified "T.Nesterova"?

Sorry, wrong.
(I thought about a similar sketch M.Nesterova that I have seen with her boyfriend)
  
Somewhere in the auction was a description of Kiev, where the icon T.Vasnetsovoy sold.
If interested, I can find.

[Михалыч]

Сообщение от redbor

  
Somewhere was a description of the auction in Kiev, where the icon T. Vasnetsov sold.
If interested, I can find.

I hope for you.
Thank you.

Added after 17 minutes

Сообщение от redbor

And for good reason. I then folded pazlik , from the fact that it was here .
See 1 and third recognition sketches Vasnetsov , 4th - his daughter, Tatiana,
 and your here " among their own ".

The fact that he was " among their own " - I do not deny it.
The concept of " design " - I think not premenimo to the work under discussion . I think its finished product.
Gold in a halo , the text in the scroll and signed "MP OY" - that's what makes me think so.

[redbor]

Mikhalich! If we assume that your sketch thing , which was later further developed by someone to give him the icon posredsvom the attributes - inscription . halos,
we can not exclude Vasnetsov , as a possible author of the sketch , and then - as lucky.
 If we assume that this icon is made by one master , it just does not Vasnetsov : it is not manufactured such icons .
 Auction with the work of his daughter found here
http://www.myslenedrevo.com.ua/ru/Sc...ticCenter.html
 As for the sketch, some experts as vasnetsovsky (in the puzzle of the 1st ) - is described in the magazine Antique Review № 1, 2004 ·

[Михалыч]

Сообщение от redbor

 As for the sketch identified by experts as vasnetsovsky ..

I'm not saying (yet) anything. But how can any reasonable guess - if the artist was a sketch (not odnin ) per plot , it is likely we can assume that there is a complete work (perhaps not yet known) .
In fact - even if that is the work of his daughter - I will satisfy also >