"Classical Painting Collection" auction at the gallery "Euro-Art"

[Altim]

What is a " museumification "? This term is another story .
And in this case under the guise of the museum made ​​things to the museum have nothing to do . Rent a hall - it's not a museum exhibition. And the conclusion Vakulenko - this is not a museum expert , he signed in his conclusions as a special "expert engineer " rather than an art historian and museum director is not alone .
Greater fool theory is , not museumification .

[Liza]

Lee Tsi Syanshen Oleg, I, in general, is on your side. Our objectives are the same - to prevent the false work at the antique market. We just have different areas of competence and, accordingly, the methods. The aim of our research - to determine the probable period of job creation and to identify signs of tampering. Next, enter critics, scholars (from the word znatochestvo - unfortunately, the outgoing nature), and of all interested persons to express their views. That is, My output: Work with the signature Burliuk "Bay of Positano," was founded in the mid-20th century, the same is signed, when it was created have been used, including Western and paint production. At the end, my area of ​​expertise. I can not say anything about the author of this work. Do you think - it's not Burliuk, another expert believes that Burliuk. Everyone probably has their own arguments and to me personally to argue with this argument is meaningless. Your arguments are heard, and the arguments of your opponents - no. I do not know what the auction house "EvroArt" and those who advise them of the art. Vakulenko and Gorbachev to treat with great respect, although there were differences Vakulenko. In the Ukrainian museums have very good work Burliuk, they are in private collections and they are in Toronto with his granddaughter. That is, Our studies are without a base. All of your opinions I consider and analyze. Also take into account the views of people who pointed out to you at some umm .... inaccuracies in your reasoning.
Sese, dzay Zen.

[OlegTsi]

Сообщение от Liza; 2102011"

This is my area of ​​expertise ends. I can not say anything about the author of this work.

Once again, dear Liza, I have no complaints to you personally does not show. Thank you for always respond to my messages. Just at the base of research data on the Elbe Art Burlyuk has made the data carrier erroneous information as chem. analysis was performed with a fake work that the Art Laboe credited as the original work. That is alarming.

Сообщение от Liza; 2102011"

Burliuk work, they are in private collections and they are in Toronto with his granddaughter. That is, Our studies are without a base

 
What does Art Lab and its database to the private collections of Burliuk, say in the U.S., and especially to the works from the collection of his granddaughter Burliuk that does not live in Toronto?

Сообщение от Liza; 2102011"

All of your opinions I consider and analyze. Also take into account the views of people who pointed out to you at some umm .... inaccuracies in your reasoning.

What are the errors in my reasoning, and you find you can imagine is here? If I have opponents in the topic of fake Burliuk, their erroneous opinions were dispelled, especially after your words:

Сообщение от Liza; 1894811"

And I Respect Oleg Tsi - he was right in his time on individual work with the signature Burliuk - they get the technology for years to the life of the artist, but do not fall on the palette to the overall series (we are working in the article attributed to the controversial.).

http://forum.artinvestment.ru/showpo...11&postcount=3

PS. In general, it would be great to work before the test the next Burliuk, you would have shown it to me ...

[etranger]

no, not at auction by chance?
what it was over?

scanned the photos on this page http://infomisto.com/uk/rivne/catalo...ries/yevro-art on the walls of the directory

"Erdely" with the museum's expertise, even

[KIEV-ART]

Was pre-auction exhibition " EvroArt " looking pictures. Got a great pleasure. I will not argue about the authenticity of Dawn or Konovalyuk (they did not interest me ), but the works of Russian artists on 19-20 cc. , No doubt, not fakes. Come and see live , and you will see for yourself . Do not even need to watch is not the most recent examination of experts of Ukraine Vakulenko, Tsitovich , Gorbachev.
As Semiradsky , thing, of course, is true and to the same level of the museum . Signed, painting - all in place , even the frame 19c . with a sign "Henry Semiradsky . Hephaestus . "

[Дилетант]

Сообщение от KIEV-ART; 2103691"

, even the frame 19c . with a sign "Henry Semiradsky . Hephaestus . "

" Genrih Semiradskiy "

From the ad : " Framing label serves as a perfect complement to the film gift , decorated in a chic frame. Made of brass, or with the effect of " aging " , it does not just decorate your gift , but emphasizes its value" ( add , " and certifies the authenticity of the picture frame decorated in " ... <! - ~ 1 ~ -> <! - ~ 1 ~ -> <! - ~ 1 ~ ->

Сообщение от KIEV-ART; 2103691"

signature paintings - everything is in place

Thank God - painting on the spot!

[Toinen]

Сообщение от KIEV-ART

with a sign "Henry Semiradsky.
Hephaestus. "

Plaque - the argument and the main feature attribution!

[Дилетант]

What a pity that died Stanisław Lewandowski, and not seeing the hateful beauty ...

[KIEV-ART]

Dear amateur, " label " refers to the author and the title of the picture and believe that the frame , and this " label " for over 100 years . And you should first go and see with my own eyes before you make any conclusions .
As for the "Glory to God , painting on the spot" and you actually saw a picture Semiradsky "live" ? And it gets the impression that there is .

[Дилетант]

Сообщение от KIEV-ART; 2103771"

As for the "Glory to God , painting on the spot" and you actually saw a picture Semiradsky "live" ? And it gets the impression that there is .

Oh, you saw through me! We have something Vesyegonsk museum Semiradsky gone, and in the region to go - do not have the means . And do not let bratovya ...
So far - in pictures current. Found in the attic of a file of "Spark" in 1964 , out of knowledge and to draw. Well, Lord have mercy : that's the victory in the socialist competition , and the commander may be much in my own teeth. You do not know, Zubtsova Semiradsky there ?
And what if in Zubtsova no - straight I do not know , Th and do ...