##Help identify the author - Страница 3 - Форум по искусству и инвестициям в искусство

тата · 20.11.2013, 17:22

Цитата:

Сообщение от ant

Picture probably always been to Moscow .
My great-grandfather was a painter . What's his name I do not know.
There was only a signature in another picture . Who can and will learn from experts.

By the way, why is not Nikolai Fechin ?

Who is your great-grandfather or sketch from Ukrainian hut ?

Муравей · 20.11.2013, 17:26

Цитата:

Сообщение от acetate

Who is your great-grandfather or sketch from Ukrainian hut?

Sketch with Ukrainian hut <! - ~ 1 ~ ->

тата · 20.11.2013, 17:41

Цитата:

Сообщение от ant

Sketch with Ukrainian hut <! - ~ 1 ~ ->

How can you explain because Feshin to do with him or with any side does not have to be equally as Vrubel, Vasnetsov , Korovin , etc.

I wonder Where did the message from Toinen, with the first page of topics?
About Shishkin and Calama - all on the subject, why do not I do not understand it ?

camertus · 20.11.2013, 20:16

this hut to Repin far as the sky.
And the signature is not Repin.
How do you do about Repin took the Lord??

rms1980 · 21.11.2013, 12:23

stumbled ... I still think - you should show the job ...

Кирилл Сызранский · 21.11.2013, 12:37

Цитата:

Сообщение от rms1980

You should show this job ...

Who?
Who can?
Where do you send the owner to display this hut?

rms1980 · 21.11.2013, 13:48

I expressed my opinion and brought arguments to defend their point of view, and I see no reason to abandon it , but I do not know why it's out of it , in the form of a madman as something not very nice to be where it is easier to say - in the furnace , prividilos evidence to identify the author , give an alternative ... and I can tell you thank you and agree.
With deep respect to all forum members.

I'm obviously in a losing position and I know it.

Муравей · 21.11.2013, 14:10

By the way, how much can cost such expertise?

Кирилл Сызранский · 21.11.2013, 14:12

Цитата:

Сообщение от rms1980

I expressed my opinion

I saw, yes:

Цитата:

Сообщение от rms1980

afraid to seem ridiculous, but not whether Ilya Efimovich?

As I understand it, you are in the signature "NF" could see "IR" and assume the authorship of this picture Repin.

rms1980 · 21.11.2013, 14:23

My opinion - the author discusses the work can be Ilya Repin 1844 birth, it is I mean.

In my letters legible signature IR

21.11.2013, 13:48	Язык оригинала: Русский #27
rms1980 Местный Регистрация: 17.01.2012 Сообщений: 165 Спасибо: 246 Поблагодарили 63 раз(а) в 37 сообщениях Репутация: 122	I expressed my opinion and brought arguments to defend their point of view, and I see no reason to abandon it , but I do not know why it's out of it , in the form of a madman as something not very nice to be where it is easier to say - in the furnace , prividilos evidence to identify the author , give an alternative ... and I can tell you thank you and agree. With deep respect to all forum members. I'm obviously in a losing position and I know it. Последний раз редактировалось rms1980; 21.11.2013 в 13:53.

21.11.2013, 14:10	Язык оригинала: Русский #28
Муравей Новичок Регистрация: 19.11.2013 Сообщений: 26 Спасибо: 3 Поблагодарили 1 раз в 1 сообщении Репутация: 2	Examination By the way, how much can cost such expertise?

Похожие темы
Тема	Автор	Разделы	Ответов	Последние сообщения
Help identify the author	Allex	Costs, valuation, attribution	3	16.10.2010 14:25
Help identify the author	belmar	Costs, valuation, attribution	2	14.10.2010 16:31
Help identify the author	fro71	Costs, valuation, attribution	0	18.07.2009 20:47
Help identify the author	spirit	Costs, valuation, attribution	6	22.05.2009 11:59
Help identify the author	Vladimer17	Costs, valuation, attribution	2	14.05.2009 20:02

20.11.2013, 20:16	Язык оригинала: Русский #24
camertus Местный Регистрация: 30.01.2013 Сообщений: 220 Спасибо: 127 Поблагодарили 75 раз(а) в 55 сообщениях Репутация: 150	this hut to Repin far as the sky. And the signature is not Repin. How do you do about Repin took the Lord??

21.11.2013, 12:23	Язык оригинала: Русский #25
rms1980 Местный Регистрация: 17.01.2012 Сообщений: 165 Спасибо: 246 Поблагодарили 63 раз(а) в 37 сообщениях Репутация: 122	stumbled ... I still think - you should show the job ...

21.11.2013, 14:23	Язык оригинала: Русский #30
rms1980 Местный Регистрация: 17.01.2012 Сообщений: 165 Спасибо: 246 Поблагодарили 63 раз(а) в 37 сообщениях Репутация: 122	My opinion - the author discusses the work can be Ilya Repin 1844 birth, it is I mean. In my letters legible signature IR